Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPC Agenda Packet 02282024ART NGELES DEPARTMENT OF P A WASH I N(-- T o N. U.S, COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT REGULAR MEETING AGENDA PLANNING COMMISSION February 28, 2024 6:00 - 8:00 PM Notice is hereby given that the Port Angeles Planning Commission will meet on Wednesday, February 28, 2024, starting at 6:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers in City Hall located at 321 E. 5a' Street, Port Angeles, WA. This meeting will be conducted as a hybrid meeting. In hybrid meetings, members of the public, Committee members, and City staff have the option to attend the meeting in person at City Hall or remotely through the Webex virtual meeting platform. For those planning to attend remotely, learn how to watch the meeting live and participate during the public comment period by visiting: https://www.cityofpa.us/Live-Virtual-Meetings. For audio only please call: 1-844-992-4726 Use access code: 2559 373 0589 Webinar password: 78exNAQJCc4 (78396275 from phones and video systems) Once connected press *3 to raise your virtual hand, if you wish to make a comment or public testimony. You will be notified when it is your turn to speak. This access code will only work for the February 28, 2024 meeting. If you are joining the meeting through the Webex link and wish to make a comment or provide public testimony, please use the "raise your hand" feature in Webex. You will be notified when it is your turn to speak. Virtual Webex Meeting Link: http s: //cityofpa.webex.com/cilyof pa/j.php?MTID=m2ba64f87db45a87a96607704c 8 dc5 c3 4 The meeting is open to the public. I. CALL TO ORDER II. ROLL CALL III. PUBLIC COMMENT IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Minutes of the January 24, 2024 Regular Meeting V. ACTION ITEM(S)/DISCUSSION ITEM(S)/PUBLIC HEARING 1. Action: Facade and Sign Improvement Program Grant Application No. 24-01 222 North Lincoln Street — Harbortowne Mall 2. Action: Appointment of Planning Commission Liaison to the Housing Solutions Committee Appoint a member of the Commission to attend the monthly Housing Solutions Committee meeting the first Friday of the month at 9:00 AM at the Clallam County Courthouse and report back to the Commissioners. 3. Discussion/Action: Election of Vice Chair to the Planning Commission Discuss Article III of the Planning Commission Bylaws and options for the election of the vacant Vice -Chair position. 4. Discussion: 2025 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update Scope of Work Staff presentation and Commissioner discussion of the scope of work and housing focus for the 2025 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update. VI. STAFF UPDATES 1. New Planner Introduction 2. Lincoln School Update 3. Housing Website 4. 2023 Building Report 5. Mandatory March 13t" Board and Commissioner Training 6. Consolidated Application Review Policy and Procedures 7. Builders Roundtable 8. Department of Commerce Short Course on Local Planning VII. REPORTS OF COMMISSION MEMBERS VIII. ADJOURNMENT Approval of Minutes January 24, 2024 Regular Meeting MINUTES PLANNING COMMISSION Hybrid Meeting - In Person and Virtual City Council Chambers: 321 E 5th Street, Port Angeles, Washington 98362 January 24, 2024, at 6:00 P.M. REGULAR MEETING CALL TO ORDER Chair Stanley opened the meeting at 6:01 P.M. ROLL CALL Commissioners Present: Benjamin Stanley (Chair) Richie Ahuja Tammy Dziadek Marolee Smith James Taylor Colin Young Commissioners Absent: None City Staff Present: Pat Bartholick (Senior Development Services Specialist) Shannen Cartmel (Deputy Director of Community Services) Calvin Goings (Deputy City Manager) Ethan Walker (Housing Administrator) Zach Trevino (Associate Planner) Public Present: Francisco Alvarez, Ashlyn Ameliani, Dan Anderson, Dan Beam, Charisse Bennett, Tom Butler, Gail Cripe, Laurel Cripe, Holly Decker, Alex Fermanis, Jason Fisher, Holden Fleming, Leslie Forsberg, Mike French, Dan Green, Jim Haguewood, Jim Halberg, Brian Heberling, Donnette Hope, Stanley Hope, D. Hutchins, Costan Ivga, Kelly Johnson, Carl Krauskoff, David Mattem, Greg Maust, Ellen Menshew, Lorrie Mittman, Matthew Moore, Steven Pelayo, Jake Purvis, John Ralston, Ron Richards, Andy Rowlson, Sarah, Carole Scholl, David Squires, Stacy, Peter Stedman, Stephanie, Caitlin Sullivan, Bruce Swenson, Karen Swenson, Shawna Turner, Joyce Underwood, Shawn Washburn, David Wegener, Tim Wheeler, Carolyn Wilcox, Justin Williamson, Chelsea Winfield, Marvin Witherow, additional unidentified members of the public PUBLIC COMMENT Chair Stanley opened the meeting to general public comment. The following individual provided comment: Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 2 • John Ralston explained that he submitted a development application to the City that had not been accepted and will follow up by submitting written comments pertaining to the situation. He is unhappy about having to pay an increased fee for the application. Chair Stanley closed the meeting to general public comment. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Taylor noted that the draft minutes from the December 27, 2023 regular meeting mention Chair Stanley's discussion with staff about agenda topics. He requested information about what transpired at the meeting between staff and the Chair that other Commissioners did not attend. No changes to the minutes were proposed. MOTION: Commissioner Young moved to approve the minutes from the December 27, 2023 regular meeting of the Planning Commission. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Dziadek and passed unanimously (6-0) through a consent vote. PUBLIC HEARING 1. Short -Term Lodging — Title 17 Port Angeles Municipal Code Amendment Chair Stanley introduced the item by stating that the Commission was not given the opportunity to provide input in the process that led to the development of the draft short-term lodging (STL) regulations. Deputy City Manager Goings provided a comprehensive overview of the proposed municipal code amendment using a slide presentation. He explained the options that are being presented to the Commission and the public for consideration, noting that the staff report summarizes the proposal and detailing the public engagement that occurred prior to the hearing. He provided background of short-term rental (STR) regulations beginning with the 2017 adoption of a definition of "short-term rental" to the present. The presentation also included explanations of the proposal's development process, data collection, community survey results, and anticipated next steps. The four months between the anticipated City Council decision in February and the licensing system's launch date allows time for staff to carefully implement the process based on which alternative is chosen. At the end of the presentation, he explained the staff recommendations for the Commission's consideration. Chair Stanley provided each Commissioner the opportunity to provide brief comments following Deputy City Manager Goings' presentation. Each Commissioner provided a statement about the topic in response to the presentation. Chair Stanley opened the public hearing to comments at 6:45 PM and limited comment time to two minutes per individual. The following individuals provided comments: • Holden Fleming noted that the Commission's bylaws allow for five minutes of public comment per person. He stated that he is a resident of the City and pointed out that 12% percent of survey respondents reported they were struggling to find adequate housing. He provided comments on the divergent survey results that demonstrate the Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 3 need to make careful decisions. He noted that "strongly disagree" was a common response to each alternative in the survey. • David Squires is a local resident who owns an STR on Cherry Hill. He explained that City staff advised his realtor in 2017 that the City was planning to amend regulations to allow for more VRBOs. He explained that his STR was closed after receiving a cease -and -desist letter from the City. He stated that he is angry and believes all STR zoning regulations in the 2017 version of the PANIC are null and void. He urged the Commission to stop the punitive fees. • Brian Heberling expressed hope that the Commission does not simply regurgitate the 2017 PANIC regulations. He stated that staff misled residents by giving them permission to operate STRs in prior years and then going back on their word. • Costan Ivga grew up under communist rule and came to the United States of America thirty-five years ago. He emphasized that taking money from someone to give to others has never improved anyone's lives. He related the idea that transferring wealth from some to others will not help the situation to the STR issue in the City. • Leslie Forsberg believes the City is on the wrong track with the proposed STR regulations. The focus has been taken off much more important issues. She claimed that the 2017 email from staff makes the current code null and void. STRs have nothing to do with affordable housing. The solution is dealing with the large numbers of dilapidated homes in the City. She also stated that STRs are a business and should pay the same fees as any other business. • Ron Richards explained that STRs affect the whole county. The procedure is flawed because the proposal should be considered by the City Council before a recommendation is made by the Commission. • Laurel Cripe handed the Commissioners a summary of the STL feedback that the city has received since June. She noted that 38% of feedback indicated a desire to put strict limits on STRs. • Caitlin Sullivan stated that the proposed alternatives are flawed. The 2017 regulations were unenforceable, and the proposed set of replacement regulations is too complex. The City should start with enforcement of the existing simpler code and explore other options than what is being considered. • Bruce Swensen urged the City to register all preexisting STRs and all newly established STRs, establish a reasonable licensing program, and allow transfer of existing STR licenses. He stated that the City should not require any inspections of STRs because insurance companies will require inspections if they deem it appropriate and necessary. He also encouraged the City not to require a site plan for STR uses. • Karen Swensen operates an Airbnb and feels that STRs should be allowed. She explained that STRs provide a unique experience in the neighborhood distinct from hotels. She is pleased to pay lodging and occupancy taxes and noted that the City is dependent on tourism now more than ever. Chair Stanley called a break beginning at 7:10 PM. The break ended at 7:16 PM and the hearing resumed. Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 4 • Chelsea Winfield has been a resident of the City for 30 years and owns a company. She states that she was told she could start an STR. She explained that the proposed fees are outrageous, and the community has felt intimidated by the City Council. • Matthew Moore is a City resident and stated that there is a mention of STRs having an impact on renters but was disappointed by a lack of analysis in the proposal. He stated that there appears to be a bias toward the property owner class. Renters have a difficult time finding housing. Workers are not a commodity, and the Commission should consider how the policies will impact non -owners and their access to permanent housing in Port Angeles. • Holly Decker is a City resident who purchased a home in Port Angeles but was relocated to the east coast on a work assignment. She wants to know what success looks like and how metrics are being used to evaluate success. She wants to know how the City is thinking about the big picture in relation to the tourism economy rather than reacting. • Andy Rowlson owns a rental home in the City of Bellingham and explained that Bellingham has a licensing program and inspection system that causes 100% of the homes to be inspected every three years. Doing a $500 safety inspection each year on a home is excessive. He explained that STRs are good for the housing stock by causing dilapidated residences to be purchased, fixed up, and then used. • Tim Wheeler lives near Sequim and stated that the County is affected by the STL issue. The homelessness and affordable housing situations are affected by STRs. STRs drive up home prices. Elderly people are living in their cars because they cannot find housing. Olympic Medical Center employees are not able to find housing in the City that is affordable to them. Teachers and other professionals are in the same position. STRs must be regulated if they cause a negative effect on the availability of affordable housing. • Ellen Menshew lives in Clallam County and has seen a lot of transition in the City over time. She is far more concerned about making housing available for those who live in our community than facilitating tourism. She checked with the school district and there are 144 unhoused students in the Port Angeles School District. The City cannot allow students to be unhoused. If a fraction of STRs were put back on the market, they could be affordable to people who want to move here. • Dan Anderson operates an STR in the R7 zone. He is hopeful that there will be an opportunity for him to achieve compliance. He noted that preventing houses valued around $500,000 from being used as STRs will not help people who have housing challenges. He stated that many people knowingly break the law because it is unenforced. Hospitality and tourism are important to a community because they result in wages. He expressed support for some derivation of Alternative #1. • Steven Pelayo explained that the City indicated to people that they could operate STRs and never enforced the 2017 code. He expressed agreement with Commissioner Ahuja that data is important when considering STR regulations. He stated that tourism has replaced the loss of mills and other industry in the City's economy. He expressed Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 5 agreement with Commissioner Young that lodging is crucial for economic growth. Sequim is ahead of Port Angeles in many ways, including in the matter of STLs. • Gail Cripe stated that staff assigned itself the role of drafting code and enforcing the code through inspections. She noted that the survey was only about the five proposed alternatives and did not offer the chance for freeform comments. The survey responses constitute a nonrandom self-selecting sample of Port Angeles residents. • Donnette Hope move to Port Angeles almost 30 years ago, started working for the school district, and has watched economic drivers in this town disappear. She explained that limiting tourism in the City is not going to help anyone. The same people who cannot afford housing now would not be able to afford housing once STR units become available on the real estate market. She stated that the City does not lack housing, but lacks affordable housing. • Stanley Hope is a City resident who operates an STR that would need to be rented for approximately $2500 a month for him to break even financially as a long-term rental owner. Charging more would need to be a part of any long-term rental situation. If his house were sold it would be priced at $500,000. He noted that the City's infrastructure is strained, which poses a challenge to developing more housing. He mentioned that buying an apartment complex and turning it into an STR would be an investment opportunity. • Jake Purvis lives just outside of the City and repaired several blighted properties in the R7 zone. He was told by staff that he can operate a by -appointment only rental business. He believes STRs should be permitted in all zones. He proposes a low-cost permit system. Many people operating STRs already possess a business license from the Washington State Department of Revenue. He stated that it may be necessary to reconsider the 2017 code and suggested a simplistic framework incorporating a business license fee for STRs consistent with what is required for other businesses. • Kelly Johnson is a local realtor and explained that short-term rentals are not the reason that the city has no affordable housing. She states that record low interest rates were the most significant factor in the market frenzy in 2019. She explained that people purchasing STRs have turned blighted properties into beautiful homes to the delight of their neighbors. • David Mattern believes the Planning Commission should have the opportunity to help in the drafting the STL regulations. There are some instances where senior citizens depend on an STR income, so he proposes an amnesty program allowing those people to stay in their homes and use them as STRs. He raised the example of Chelan County as a jurisdiction with a program that allows money to stay in the community. • Charisse Bennett stated that she operates an STR in a commercial zone. She suggested ending the conditional use permit (CUP) requirement for STRs in the CO zone because it is redundant to require a CUP in addition to the licensing. • Carol Scholl identified herself as one of the only people present who does not run an STR or bed and breakfast. She sees the impact of unregulated STRs on neighborhoods. It is difficult to have community when people are constantly renting out homes. Many small towns cannot keep employees because housing costs are so high. She raised the Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 6 example of Sedona and noted that many cities are dealing with the STR problem. She agrees that 2017 code is a mess because it was never enforced. She wants to hear from more homeowners who do not operate STRs. • Mike French thanked Planning Commission, City Council, and staff for their service. Port Angeles is the most innovative small town in the state. He believes that the City has not been hearing from tourism policy professionals because the professionals say that the need for cities like Port Angeles is to enable service industry workers to afford housing. Housing shortages are created in part by an excess of tourism. Sustainable tourism is the goal, not more tourism. He noted that STR guests are less likely to eat at local restaurants because they have a kitchen. • Sarah explained that she owned a business for 43 years and advocated for STRs as a way for self-employed people to supplement their income. She noted that STLs incentive property owners to keep buildings maintained. She disagrees with those who say that STLs are not a viable part of the Port Angeles community. • Carl Krauskoff is a full-time multi -family developer in Washington who owns property in the City. He has spent money on local contractors in the City and has had more than 34 families stay in the STR he operates. He advocated for 506(c)s, expressed support for STRs, and stated that he would love to see the code more thoughtfully put together. • Jason Fisher lives in Cherry Hill. He described the neighborhood, stating that next door to his mother's house was a party house that created lower property values. Another neighbor is an STR that has helped improve the neighborhood. He noted that people have invested money in their neighborhood through STRs. • Tom Butler lives just outside the City but has been here for 30 years He tried to operate as a STR in another town and the neighbors begged him to stop because of the noise, so he stopped. He believes the government's responsibility is to provide for the residents of the community, so the City should let STR owners operate and focus on the majority of property owners instead. He is an investor and explained that money is not circulating in the community when investors own properties. • Dan Green claimed that the talk about affordable housing is a joke. He stated that what is not being addressed is the issue of those who operate STRs and live on the property. He is a registered nurse and retired from Olympic Medical Center. He was diagnosed with prostate cancer and his family has operated an STR since 2020. Since 2020, they have been super hosts and seven months out of the year they are renting to doctors, nurses, and other professionals. • Jim Halberg is a business owner and City resident. He explained that the STL situation does not need to be so difficult. The key issue is affordable housing and there has not been a huge effect on affordable housing by STRs. Palm Springs had to shut things down because they had a large volume of STRs. A simplified plan involving registration and platform compliance is needed so the STR situation does not get out of control. He noted that he operates an STR that happens to be legal. • Greg Maust explained that housing is for living in, not making profit and money. He noted that sustainable affordable housing is not even close to being realized. Travelling Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 7 employees are bankrupting Olympic Medical Center because they cannot hire full-time employees. He noted that the second homeowner class is well -represented. He reiterated that residences are primarily intended to be lived in. • Shawna Turner stated that a lack of cost -benefit analysis in staff's presentation is a flaw. She believes the whole STL proposal should be scrapped and made part of the Comprehensive Plan. She noted that an STR is not defined clearly in the draft code. She is confused as to why the City allows ADUs in an attempt to increase affordable housing stock but then allows them to be used as STRs. • Carolyn Wilcox stated that the discussion has been robust and has been more balanced at this meeting. In December when attending a City Council meeting, she only heard from those with a financial interest in this issue. She stated that the disruption began with the founding of Airbnb in 2008 and that the technology companies are unregulated. The City needs to determine who housing is intended to be for. In Irvine California, the long-term rental market decreased in cost after their STR ordinance was passed. She explained that using a program named Host Compliance could help the City enforce the STL code. • Jim Haguewood is a resident of the City and clarified that he is not operating an STR. He recommends allowing residential rentals of 30 days or less in all zones in the City. The STR situation presents an unprecedented disruption to the community. The evidence shows that $8 million in economic value will be lost with the proposed regulations. A new ordinance should clean up the compliance issue and allow time for a more constructive discussion. • Ashlyn Ameliani is a City resident who operates an owner -occupied STR but received a cease and desist letter. She looked into renting to long-term tenants but received no interest for a maximum rental period of 90 days. She is not planning to turn her residence into a long-term rental and relied upon STR revenue for her retirement. She finds it frustrating that the community is going to tell her how her house should operate. • Lorrie Mittman is a City resident who operates an owner -occupied STR. She called the City in 2018 and asked about STR regulations. She was told that there were no regulations at that time but that there probably would be in the future. She appreciates that there is a pathway to compliance. She claimed that the City receives $300,000 a year from noncompliant STRs and accepted the money knowingly. She accused the City of hypocrisy for taking money from noncompliant STRs. She stated that long term rentals are being used to make money too, but she will not rent her residence on a long- term basis. • John Ralston is a City resident who does not own STRs. He attended the 2017 meetings and mentioned that staff would have problems at that time. He states that the city has provided incomplete information and the GovOS data should be fully released. The City should state that the number of dwelling units is an estimate and that tax revenue generated by STRs is closer to $400,000. The City should clearly state what GovOS is going to be charging. He also mentioned that the survey should have included a narrative explaining the rationale for the proposed alternatives. Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 8 • Stacy is a City resident who lives in a mixed density neighborhood. She stated that affordable housing is not the issue. STRs bring drug use, noise, and other disruptions. She explained that nurses cannot find housing in the City of Port Angeles. • Marvin Witherow cannot believe that regulations are going to be placed on his home. The people who would need to rent would not rent his house. He believes the owner of a property should be able to do what they want with their own property. • Shawn Washburn is a local real estate agent and lifelong resident of the City. He explained that the issue at hand is much larger than STRs. Homes are being transformed into offices and they can no longer be used as a residence. He asked where the City would be if the energy put toward STL regulations had been put into working on the blighted homes and utility issues in the City. • Justin Williamson stated that STRs are not the reason people come out to the Olympic Peninsula. The natural resources are the reason people come to the Peninsula. • Stephanie is a new resident who works as an RN at Olympic Medical Center. She is familiar with the trouble that local healthcare professionals face in finding housing. She is a noncompliant STR operator in the City. She wants everyone else to be economically sound. She noted that STRs are not automatically going to be transitioned into long-term rentals if STRs are limited. STR owners should not have choice taken away from them. Chair Stanley closed the public hearing to comments at 8:55 PM. He clarified that the function of the Planning Commission is help focus the City Council by making a recommendation. Detailed discussion by the Commission followed the public comment period. Staff answered questions from the Commissioners about the proposal. Several motions were made, as follows: Commissioner Taylor suggested a motion to recommend that no fines be imposed upon any STRs operating before fiscal year 2025. Commissioner Smith proposed amending the motion to recommend no fines for STL operations based on the 2017 Port Angeles Municipal Code requirements. Commissioner Taylor expressed agreement with this amendment and moved to recommend that the City Council adopt a suspension of fines associated with violations of the STL regulations in the 2017 Port Angeles Municipal Code. Further discussion and refinement of the motion's language ensued. Commissioner Smith moved that the Planning Commission recommends that the City Council pass an ordinance to amend the 2017 ordinance to allow STRs in all zones of the City. Commissioner Taylor seconded the motion. The motion failed (5-1) through a roll call vote, with Commissioner Smith voting yes. • Commissioner Ahuja moved that the Planning Commission recommends that the City Council: Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 9 o Amend the existing ordinance in such a manner that supports enforcement of the 2017 Port Angeles Municipal Code and provides a time -limited exception option for existing nonconforming short-term rentals; and o Pursue platform -based enforcement; and o Pursue a comprehensive assessment of an ideal short term rental process in the City of Port Angeles. Commissioner Young seconded the motion. The motion passed (5-1) through a roll call vote, with Commissioner Smith voting no. • Commissioner Smith moved to recommend that the Planning Commission become more proactive, explore government subsidized supportive housing to low- and middle -income residents, identify financial institutions that can help the City work better with builders in the community, and find vacant and abandoned properties that can be developed to devise an incentive program for promoting their development. Commissioner Taylor seconded the motion. After further discussion, Commissioner Smith withdrew the motion before a vote occurred. • Commissioner Taylor moved that the Planning Commission recommends that the City Council cap the registration fee for STR owners at $25. Commissioner Smith seconded the motion. The motion failed (4-2), with Commissioners Smith and Taylor voting yes. STAFF UPDATES City staff did not provide updates to the Commission. REPORTS FROM COMMISSION MEMBERS • Chair Stanley raised the issue of transparency, stating that the Commission had no input on the work plan for the Planning Commission going forward. • Commissioner Ahuja stated that he would like to have agenda topics decided upon through coordination with the Chair. Staff assured the Commission that staff will continue to work jointly with Commission Chairs to develop meeting agendas through a collaborative process. • Commissioner Ahuja stated that there is a lack of strategic alignment between the City Council and the Planning Commission. He recommends the establishment of an ad hoc standing committee to focus on strategic alignment between City bodies. • Commissioner Young noted that there was a joint City Council and Planning Commission meeting in June, which was insufficient to accommodate necessary discussion. He suggested holding a joint meeting at least twice a year. Chair Stanley expressed frustration with staff s presentation at the joint meeting that occurred in June because it took up most of the meeting time. • Commissioner Smith believes that the Commissioner emails should be publicly available to facilitate open communication. Planning Commission Minutes January 24, 2024 Page 10 ADJOURNMENT Chair Stanley moved to adjourn the meeting. Commissioner Smith seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously (6-0) through a consent vote. The meeting was adjourned at 10:58 PM. Zach Trevino, Secretary Benjamin Stanley, Chair MINUTES PREPARED BY: Zach Trevino, Secretary 1 Action Item #1 Facade and Sign Grant Application No. 24=01 0 RTANGELES DEPARTMENT OF � WASH I N G r o N, U.S. I COMMUNITY & ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TO: Planning Commission FROM: Pat Bartholick, Senior Development Services Specialist MEETING DATE: February 28, 2024 RE: Fagade Grant Application for Business (Grant No. 24-01) APPLICANT: Johanna Bartee 390 Osborn Road, Port Angeles, WA 98362 OWNER: HarborTowne LLC, 222 N Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 LOCATION: 222 N Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the fagade and sign grant award amount of $10,607.00 toward the replacement of signs and installation of doors, windows and awnings of the building located at 222 N Lincoln Street (Grant No. 24-01). PROJECT SUMMARY Johanna Bartee is requesting funding for the replacement of signs and installation of new windows, awning and doors with panic hardware for the building located at 222 N Lincoln Street (Grant No. 24-01). The applicant is requesting these funds as part of a larger effort to increase safety and aesthetics. A more in-depth description of the proposed work and its intended outcome can be found in "Attachment A" to this document. STAFF ANALYSIS The Community Fagade and Sign Improvement Program was authorized by the City Council through the passing of ordinance #3476. This authorization is represented in Chapter 2.80 of the Port Angeles Municipal Code. The Program will provide a grant for funding of fagade improvements that will enhance the physical appearance, accessibility, and overall value of individual buildings as well as the surrounding downtown area. In evaluating proposals for funding, Staff reviewed the "Evaluation criteria and prioritization" of Section 2.80.110: 1. Private contribution over and above the required match; Staff Analysis: Per the submitted budget, the applicant is providing the required 50 percent match. The applicant is ready to begin work during as soon as the grant approval process is complete. Present condition of existing fagade: Staff Analysis: As seen in Figure 1, the existing fagade is in need of upgrades to both doors, windows, and signage. For safety and appearance reasons the awnings have been removed. The sign(s) are weathered and in need of replacement. Doors require HarborTowne Mall at 222 N Lincoln Street, No. 24-1 February 28, 2024 Page 2 up to date panic hardware to current requirements for life -safety and egress. The proposed changes will assist in brightening up the public space along the Lincoln Street and Railroad Avenue corridor. 2. The buildings overall public visibility; Staff Analysis: This property is located at a highly visible corner, receiving large amounts of traffic from visitors as they arrive or depart our City from the Coho Ferry. Along with that, citizens and visitors attending activities at the City Pier, Hollywood Beach, or enjoying the Olympic Discovery Trail, pass by this location. Making it vitally important to the overall experience of our downtown shopping district. 3. Expected increase in assessed value of improvement; Staff Analysis: The improvements to the structure will increase safety and brighten up this highly visible location that is vital to our vibrant downtown. Though there isn't work being completed that would require meeting our block frontage standards, the proposed improvements provide elements that bring the structure closer to compliance with these standards. The improvements to the aesthetics and improvement to public safety through the upgrading of doors and windows will increase the assessed value of the structure. 4. Historic Preservation; Staff Analysis: The 2000 Downtown Port Angeles Historic Inventory Survey Report lists the HarborTowne Marketplace as being constructed in 1929 in the City's fourth phase of HarborTowne Mall at 222 N Lincoln Street, No. 24-1 February 28, 2024 Page 3 development. Use for the structure began as the Olympic Motorcoach Terminal. Later uses for the structure included a greyhound station into the 1950’sm, Lincoln Welding Company, and logging rigging supply. Most recently it has been sectioned off into two floors and three bays of separate restaurant and retail spaces. The report lists the building as serving as a visual gateway, point of arrival, to Port Angeles. 5. Context in the block or neighborhood; Staff Analysis: The structure has a unique roof line and is highly visible from Front Street, Railroad Avenue, and Lincoln Street 6. Benefit partner projects on same block; Staff Analysis: There have been several façade and sign grants within the general area that the HarborTowne Mall is located in, including the Wharf (Landing Mall), Storm King Crossfit, Barhop, Lee Plaza Suites. FINDINGS, CONDITIONS & CONCLUSIONS Staff determines the following findings based on Staff’s review of the Program’s criteria: Findings 1. The Façade Grant (Application No. 24-01) was submitted by Johanna Bartee to the Department of Community and Economic Development on 1/10/2024. 2. The location of the work proposed is 222 N Lincoln Street. 3. The project site is located within the Central Business District, CBD zone. 4. The grant request includes the replacement of deteriorated awnings, signage and door and widows for safety and appearances. Figure 2: Current Structure Southeast Elevation HarborTowne Mall at 222 N Lincoln Street, No. 24-1 February 28, 2024 Page 4 5. The application was reviewed by Planning Division Staff under the Façade and Sign Grant Program criteria, as included in Chapter 2.80 of the Port Angeles Municipal Code. 6. The applicant is requesting $10,607.00 toward façade and signage improvements valued no more than $22,905.00. 7. The request will be heard by the Planning Commission at the regularly scheduled meeting February 13, 2019. Conclusions Based on the findings above, Staff makes the following conclusions: 1. Grant Application No. 24-01 is found to provide for façade improvements that will enhance the physical appearance and overall value of the Lincoln corridor. 2. Grant Application No. 24-01 is found to meet the grant program’s criteria as included in Section 2.80.110 of the Port Angeles Municipal Code. 3. Therefore, Staff is recommending support of approval of the grant proposal with conditions of approval that outlines the requirements of the final award of funding. Conditions Based on Staff’s finding and conclusions, the following conditions are placed on this grant application approval: 1. Upon the date the Planning Commission’s approval, the applicant may proceed with the expenditures detailed in the application. 2. The applicant shall sign a grant contract with the City of Port Angeles for the reimbursement of a maximum amount of $10,607.00 for façade improvements. The applicant will be given 180 days to submit reimbursement of expenditures associated with the approved grant proposal as of the Planning Commission action. If progress on the project can be demonstrated, the applicant may request one 180-day extension of the contract. 3. Prior to contract signature, signed letters from the proposal’s property owners granting consent to the mural work on their property shall be provided to the Planning Division. The letters should indicate the acceptance of the 5-year requirement to preserve the grant work (Per standard contract language). 4. The applicant shall submit invoices for total reimbursement with a coversheet detailing each invoice number, amount, and type of payment and not exceeding the awarded grant amount. Reimbursement by the City will occur within 30 days of submission. 5. Prior to reimbursement, the property must be available to Staff for a site visit on the property confirming the work was done according to the approved grant application. 6. A building permit shall be required and submitted to the Department of Community & Economic Development for any and all construction work beyond repair. 7. Any labor performed in association with the grant proposal over $2,000.00 must meet federal prevailing wage standards. HarborTowne Mall at 222 N Lincoln Street, No. 24-1 February 28, 2024 Page 5 ATTACHMENTS A. Application materials B. Historic Property Survey Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 January 10, 2023 City of Port Angeles Community & Economic Development 321 E. 5th Street Port Angeles, WA 98362 Johanna Bartee 390 Osborn Rd. Port Angeles, WA 98362 Cell: 808.225.7394 Johannabartee@hotmail.com To whom it may concern, The submission of this project narrative is for consideration of the Façade and Sign Grant Program of the downtown Port Angeles commercial area. I am requesting the 50% matching grant amount for revitalization of the streetscape and overall downtown appeal of this historic neighborhood. The requested work includes, replacing the single ADA door to the north building entrance on Railroad Avenue, replacing the single ADA storefront door to the Unit 102 exterior entrance on Lincoln Street, replacing the 96” x 72” storefront window for Unit 102 on Lincoln Street, replacing the 10’ window awnings, and replacing the exterior HarborTowne signs affixed to the southern and western sides of the building. I purchased the HarborTowne building in February 2018, located at 222 N. Lincoln Street. It is the historic site of the Olympic Motor coach Terminal that became the Greyhound Bus Station, and later housed the Lincoln Welding Company and a logging rigging supply. In 1984 it was substantially remodeled, providing a mixed collection of specialty shops. It currently has six retail tenants on the upper street level, and five retail tenants on the lower level. The six street level tenants include two new eateries, Moby Duck Chowder & Seafood, and PNWonderland Wines, as well as Jasmine Bistro Thai, LaBelle Creperie, The Parlour Hair Salon, and Alkemy gift shop. The lower level includes Waterfront Wheels bicycle repair, Ettani Health & Wellness, Canvas Beauty, Somewhere in Time Vintage, and All About Here git shop. The exterior doors and window I hope to do as soon as possible. The old entrance on Railroad Avenue is a terrible door and doesn’t even fit the door frame so it blows cold air and debris into the building, and no longer opens from the outside. The bike shop owner is forced to enter through the south side of the building and open the door from the inside, leaving it propped open all day just to allow patrons into his shop. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 This is the primary entrance to the bike shop and the northern entrance to the building’s lower level and side entrance to Moby Duck Chowder & Seafood restaurant. The Storefront door and window on Lincoln Street are for Unit 102, the new home of PNWines, expected to open April 1, 2024. The door and window are vital for the opening of this business. We need six 10’ window awnings, all matching black. Four of these are to replace the window awnings that the previous tenant wrongfully took. We would like a fifth one for the window over the new wine shop, and the sixth one to replace the old and raggedy one over the Creperie. I would like to replace the old HarborTowne building signs on the southern and western sides of the building. The presentation contains photos showing the current condition. This signage is for the building directory and individual signs are the responsibility of the tenants. I would also like to complete this improvement as soon as possible, as new and existing tenants would like to hang their signs to let people know they are there. BUDGET The total façade project cost estimate, excluding tax, is $21,691.37. I am requesting the maximum façade grant amount of $10,000 since a 50% match exceeds that. The proposal from Glass Services to furnish and install the two exterior doors is $12,039.50, $6,019.75 each, and includes all labor and materials in the price. The quote from Savage Glass to replace and install the 96” x 72” store front window on Lincoln Street is $2,329.47 and also includes all labor and materials. The quote from Home Depot to furnish the awnings is $1,150.40 each, $6,902.40 for all six of them. The labor to mount them is $420.00. The total sign project cost estimate, excluding tax, is $1,214.00 and the 50% matching sign grant request is $607.00. The estimate from Miller Signs to replace and install the HarborTowne exterior signs are $397 each, $794 for both, and $420 in labor to repair the panels the signs are mounted to. Detailed estimates and after renderings are in the presentation and the expenses are as shown below and in the detailed Project Budget. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Thank you for your time and consideration of HarborTowne for the funding grant. Please don’t hesitate to contact me with any questions or concerns. I look forward to hearing from you! Sincerely, Johanna Bartee HARBORTOWNE FAÇADE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT BUDGET: 222 N. Lincoln Street, Port Angeles WA 98362 Doors Number Product Cost Total Cost 38” x 82” Aluminum Entry Door (2) $6,019.75 $12,039.50 Labor Installation included Windows Number Product Cost Total Cost Item # 5061 Storefront Window (1) $2,329.47 $2,329.47 Installation included Awnings Number Product Cost Total Cost 10.38 ft. Wide New Yorker Window (6) $1,150.40 $6,902.40 Labor (6) $$70.00 $420.00 Total Façade Project Materials Cost ........................$21,271.37 Total Façade Project Labor Cost ..............................$420.00 SIGN IMPROVEMENT PROJECT BUDGET: 222 N. Lincoln Street, Port Angeles WA 98362 Exterior Signs Number Product Cost Total Cost 8’ x 22” Vinyl on AlumaCore Panel (2) $397.00 $794.00 Labor (6) $420.00 $420.00 Total Sign Project Materials Cost ........................$794.00 Total Sign Project Labor Cost ..............................$420.00 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 January 10, 2023 City of Port Angeles Community & Economic Development 321 E. 5th Street Port Angeles, WA 98362 Johanna Bartee 390 Osborn Rd. Port Angeles, WA 98362 Cell: 808.225.7394 Johannabartee@hotmail.com HarborTowne Marketplace FAÇADE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT BUDGET: 222 N. Lincoln Street, Port Angeles WA 98362 Doors Number Product Cost Total Cost 38” x 82” Aluminum Entry Door (2) $6,019.75 $12,039.50 Labor Installation included Windows Number Product Cost Total Cost Item # 5061 Storefront Window (1) $2,329.47 $2,329.47 Installation included Awnings Number Product Cost Total Cost 10.38 ft. Wide New Yorker Window (6) $1,150.40 $6,902.40 Labor (6) $$70.00 $420.00 Total Façade Project Materials Cost ........................$21,271.37 Total Façade Project Labor Cost ..............................$420.00 SIGN IMPROVEMENT PROJECT BUDGET: 222 N. Lincoln Street, Port Angeles WA 98362 Exterior Signs Number Product Cost Total Cost 8’ x 22” Vinyl on AlumaCore Panel (2) $397.00 $794.00 Labor (6) $420.00 $420.00 Total Sign Project Materials Cost ........................$794.00 Total Sign Project Labor Cost ..............................$420.00 Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 These are photos of the current condition of the exterior door on Railroad Avenue. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 These are current photos of the store front door and window to Unit 201 on Lincoln Street. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 The awnings are for the four windows on the corner restaurant, two on Railroad Ave and two on Lincoln street. A fifth one for the window over unit 102 for the wine bar, and the sixth one to replace the black and white one over the Creperie. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 The top sign “HarborTowne Mall” are the exterior directory signage I would like to replace. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 The awnings are for the four windows on the corner restaurant, two on Railroad Ave and two on Lincoln street. A fifth one for the window over unit 102 for the wine bar, and the sixth one to replace the black and white one over the Creperie. Attachment A HARBORTOWNE HarborTowne, LLC 222 North Lincoln Street, Port Angeles, WA 98362 Tel.: +1 (808) 225-7394 Attachment A . ff l S-1 ORrl.-PKOP~Krt· 1-,.J\f t.Nl-O~Y fORM IDENTIFICATION SECTION Field Site No. LIN212 OAHP No Date Recorded 20 April 2000 Site Name Historic Olympic Motorcoach Terminal I Greyhound Bus Station Common Harbortowne Mall Field Recorder Gerald K. 8. Eysaman Owner's Name ___________ __,K=.,h.,,o"'a,.,_n.__.,B,_,o"-'a"-'n"'g,._ _____________ _ Address _________ -:----,--=2=2=5,-:D::co=::19c:.w..,o..,o""'d::.....:.P....,l_,,,a""c=e------------- City/State/Zip Code ______ P'-=o-'-'rt'"'A-=n__.q=e=le'""s'"'"'""'W--'-=as=h'-'-'-'-in"'g""t"'o.,...n'---"'9=8=3=6=2 _________ _ Status PHOTOGRAPHY ffl Survey/Inventory Photography Neg . No. R]. F 15A National Register (RoH No. & Frame No .) State Register 0 0 m 0 Determined Eligible Determined Not Eligible Other (HABS, HAER, NHL) Local Designation View of Southeast Corner 0 0 Date 30 Aug 99 Classification O District O Site flB Building District Status O NR O SR O LR Contributing O Non-Contributing 0 O Structure O INV O Object District/Thematic Nomination Name _________________________ _ DESCRIPTION SECTION Materials & Features I Structural Types Building Type Transportation Plan Rectangular Structural System Reinforced Concrete & Timber Truss No. of Stories 1 Cladding (Exterior Walt Surfaces) Olag O Horizontal Wood Siding O Rustic I Drop O Clapboard O Wood Shingle O Board and Batten O Vertical Board O Asbestos I Asphalt 0Brick O Stone O Stucco 0Terra Cotta ffl Concrete I Concrete Block O Vinyl I Aluminum Siding O Metal (Specify) O Other (Specify) RoofType O Gable ffl Flat O Monitor O Gambrel O Shed Roof Material O Wood Shingle O Wood Shake O Composition O Slate O Tar I Built-Up 0Tile OHip O Pyramidal Other (Specify) O Metal (Specify) __ O Other (Specify) ffl Not Visible --- Foundation Olag O Post& Pier O Stone O Brick O Not Visible Concrete O Block O Poured ffl Other (Specify) Pilings Integrity (Include detailed description in Description of Physlcal Appearance) Changes to plan .............................................................. . Changes to windows ....................................................... . Changes lo original cladding ........................................... . Changes to interior ···········································.················ Other (Specify) Exterior Cornice Intact 0 0 0 0 m Slight 0 0 0 0 0 Moderate m 0 m 0 0 Extensive 0 m 0 m 0 -· • of··· -~· gto_ ~ · rtrr. __ · ~--:on_ ·--~ , Tr _ __:__J --co .__J -,ev ,~ 1t umce ot Arcnaeology &tilstoric Preservation 420 Golf Club Road SE, Lacey Post Office Box 48343 Olympia, Washington 98504-8343 (360) 407-0752 LOCATION SECTION Address 212 North Lincoln Street Cityffown/County/Zip Code (Port Angeles, Clallam, Washington 98362 Twp 30 N Range 6 W Section 00 Y. Section Y. Y. Section ___ _ Tax No./Parcel No. 063000-500020-0000 Acreage Less than one Quadrangle or Map Name Port Angeles Quadrangle UTM References Zone 10 Easting E 468045 Northing N 5329480 PlaUBlock/Lot Tidelands I Block 1 I Lot 1 exc Tx & E10 lot 2 Supplemental Map(s) _______________________________ _ High Styles I Forms (Check one or more of the following) O Greek Revival O Spanish Colonial Revival/Mediterranean O Gothic Revival O Tudor Revival O Italianate O Craftsman I Arts & Crafts O Second Empire O Bungalow O Romanesque Revival O Prairie Style O Stick Style ffl Art Deco I Art Modeme O Queen Anne O Rustic Style O Shingle Style O International Style O Colonial Revival O Northwest Style O Beaux Arts I Neoclassical m Commercial Vernacular O Chicago I Commercial Style O Residential Vernacular O American Foursquare O Other (Specify) O Mission Revival Vernacular House Types O Gable front O Gable front and wing O Side Gable O Cross gable O Pyramidal I Hipped O Other (Specify) Field Site No.: LIN21; Attachment B :~ ,. r I ..... -------.. -..._ NAKMI IVt: sE't, 11uN "' ( I \ Study Unit Themes (Check one or more of the following) D Aariculture D ConservaUon O PolilicslGovemmenVLaw m Architecture I Landscape Architecture O Educallon O Religion OArts O Entertainment I Recreation O Science & Enaineerina O Commerce O Ethnic Heritage (Specify) O Social Movements I Organizations D Communications O l-lealth I Medicine m TransPortaUon O Community Planni ng I Development O Manufacturing / Industry O Other (Specify) OMilltary O Study Unit Sub-Theme{s) (Specify) Statement of Significance Date or Construction 1929 Archlt.ect I Engineer I Builder ---=Uc.:-n:.:.kaan-"o=-w=-:..:.n=---------------------!lm In the opinion of the surveyor, this properly appears to meet the c.riteria of the National Register of Historic Places. O In lhe opinion of the surveyor, this property is located irt a potential historic district (National and/or local}. ~ E\1 In the opinion of the surveyor, this property Is located In a potenUal conservation districL This building was originally constructed in 1929 as the Olympic Motorcoach Terminal later becoming the Greyhound Bus Station. It later housed the Lincoln Welding Company. It is currently known as the Harbourtowne Mall This bu ilding was constructed in the heydays of downtown's fourth phase of development, which is most visible today. It was a period of rapid commercial expansion framed by the Great War and U1e Great Depression. Older wood frame buildings were being replaced by larger more substantial structures. The railroad was now a permanent feature across the waterfront where Lincoln , Laurel , and Oak Streets reached out to expand the downtown north with an orthogonal web of docks. They seamlessly merged dry land with the numerous wharfs reaching out into the harbor. The once fom1idable and restrictive bluff across Lincoln Street had been sluiced away, ultimately allowing direct access to this site and far better access to the waterfront. First Street quickly filled up with new retail and commercial structures. The Olympic Motorcoach Terminal was connected to a larger regional bus syscem and brought visitors co Port Angeles from around Puget Sound. It was located a block from where Highway IOI , newly completed/upgraded all the way to Olympia, entered the downtown area and adjacent to the ferry docks where travellers left for Victoria and other Pugel Sound ports. Busscs initially supplemented boat and train service, allowing greater access to tourist areas of the Olympic Peninsula. hitherto, inaccessible by train. The rapid increase in vehicular modes of transportation. which this bus terminal supported, were beginning to transform the way people moved around the sound, usurping and ultimately decimating the inter-sound ferry traffic. This building served as a visual gateway, a point of arrival, to Port Angeles. It operated as a bus station into the I 950's. Since then a succession of owners have used the builcting, including the Lincoln Welding Company and a logging rigging supply See attached Continuation Sheet for more I \. OescrlpUon of Physical Appearance This is a single story commercial building. The center three bays are symmetrical and flanked by similar side wings of different lengths. It currently has a series of contemporary aluminum storefront window inserts in partitions that infill the histaric bus door and depot entry fenestration. A uniform facing of rough textured plaster covers the original concrete and recent infill partitions. Original relief pilasters and string courses are visible. A continuous highly decorative parapet in a blend of Art Deco with Spanish Colonial RevivaJ influence remains on the main east fayade . It contains original tcrra cotta volutes, obolisk finials and art deco-inspired end and center medalions. A large tapered wood flagpole with ball is centered in 1he parapet oflhe main Lincoln Street faca_de . Five heavy timber trusses project upward as a series of broad fins. They are clearly visible across the roof, a dominating feature of the building. The trusses are enclosed by a wood gram composition shingles in a square cut pattern and have a continuous wide metal cap running up the drag ends of the truss and across the top. The building's flat roof is set to the bottom of the trusses that with a composition shingle and continuous metal cap. A series of metal cable ties inter-connect the upper edges of the trusses securung them laterally. Major Bibliographic References Histories Clallam County Immigration Association. Port Angeles The Gateway City of the Pacific Coast J 897. Seallle: The Shorey Bookstore, Facsimile Reproduction 1965 , Hunt, Hcrben. Washington West of the Cascades. Chicago: Clarke Publishing Co ., 1917 . Lauridsen, G.M. The Story of Port Angeles and Clallam County Washington. Seattle: Lowman & Hanford Company, 1937 . Martin, Paul. Port Angeles Washington : A History Volume I. Port Angeles: Peninsula Publishing. Inc ., 1983 . McCallum, John and Lorraine Wilcox Ross. Port Angeles U.S.A. Wood and Reber, Inc., 1961. Peppard, Kurt . "Port Angeles Guide". Scaltle: Cascadia Publishing Company, 1995. Welsh, William. A Brief History of Port Angeles. Port Angeles: Crown Zellerbach Corp., Seventh Printing 1955. Maps Levy, Lewis, Compiled by. Town of Port Angeles Washington with Additions. Port Angeles: Lewis Levy Real Estate Broker, 1890. Mao of Port Angeles Washing1on . Tacoma: N.R. Bank Note Co:npany, 1912. Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps: 1891, 1897, 1911, 1917, 1924, 1947, 1949, 1952, l 955, and 1964. Smith C.E., Nonnan R ., Compiled by. Map of Port Angeles Washington. San Francisco: Schmidt Label & Lithograph Co., 189 l. Smilh, Nonnan R., Compiled by . Map of Port Angeles Wzshington Territory .• 1884. Ware, Edwin. Draughtsman. Port Angeles and Suburbs [sic). Port Angeles W.T., 1889 Ware, W.J. Compiled by . Townsjte of Port Angeles and Vicinity . Port Angeles: W.J. Ware, l 891. Other Sources Polk's Clallam County Classified Business Directory. Kansas City, Mo.: R.L.Polk Co .. various editions. Port Angeles Public Library: Palricia Campbell Room Vertical Files Port Angeles Public Library: Photograph Albums (including the Bert Kellogg Photographs Collection). Field Site No.: LIN212 Attachment B Action Item #3 Election of Vice Chair to the Planning Commission BYLAWS of THE CITY OF PORT ANGELES, WASHINGTON PLANNING COMMISSION (Amended April 14, 2022) ARTICLE I - NAME Section 1. Name The official name of the organization shall be “The City of Port Angeles, Washington, Planning Commission.” ARTICLE II - OFFICIAL SEAT Section 1. Official Seat The official seat of the Planning Commission shall be in the City Hall of Port Angeles, Washington, 321 East Fifth Street, and meetings shall be held there except on such occasions and at such times as the Commission may, by a majority vote of those present at any regular, recessed, or special meeting, otherwise direct. ARTICLE III - OFFICERS Section 1. Officers The elective officers of the Planning Commission shall consist of a Chair and Vice-Chair. Section 2. Nomination and Election of Officers Nomination of elective officers shall be made from the floor at the annual election meeting which shall be held at the last regular meeting of March of each year. The election shall follow immediately thereafter. A nominee receiving a majority vote of those present at the election meeting shall be declared elected. If meetings cannot occur because of an unforeseen circumstance, nominations and elections shall take place at the next available meeting. Section 3. Terms of Officers The term of office for elective officers shall begin in April and shall continue for a term of one year, or until nominations or elections have taken place at the next available meeting date. Elective officers shall serve no more than two consecutive terms in the same office. Section 4. Vacancies in Offices Vacancies in elective offices shall be filled immediately by regular election procedure for the unexpired portion of the term. Section 5. Duties of Officers (a) Chair The Chair shall preside at all meetings and public hearings of the Planning Commission and shall call special meetings when he/she deems it necessary or is required to do so. 2 They shall appoint all committees, shall be an ex-officio member of each, without the power to vote. They shall sign the minutes of Planning Commission meetings and all official papers and plans involving the authority of the Planning Commission which are then transmitted to the City Council. The Chair shall have the privilege of discussing all matters before the Planning Commission and voting thereon. They shall have all the duties normally conferred by parliamentary usage on such officers and shall perform such other duties as may be ordered by the Planning Commission except as otherwise provided in these Bylaws, in other Planning Commission regulations, or in City Ordinances. (b) Vice-Chair The Vice-Chair shall assume the duties and powers of the Chair in his or her absence. If the Chair and Vice-Chair are both absent, the Planning Commission members may elect a temporary chair by a majority vote of those present at a regular, recessed, or special meeting, who shall assume the duties and powers of the Chair or Vice-Chair during their absence. (c) Executive Secretary The Executive Secretary is a staff appointed position. The Executive Secretary shall keep the minutes of all regular, recessed, and special meetings of the Planning Commission; such minutes shall be approved by the Planning Commission. They shall also keep the minutes of Planning Commission committee meetings when requested to do so. They shall give notice of all regular and special meetings to Planning Commission members, shall prepare with the Chair the agenda of regular and special meetings, shall serve proper and legal notice of all public hearings, and shall draft and sign the routine correspondence of the Planning Commission. The Executive Secretary shall maintain a file of all studies, plans, reports, recommendations, and official records of the Planning Commission and perform such other duties as are normally carried out by a secretary and as the Planning Commission may determine. ARTICLE IV - MEETINGS Section 1. Regular Meetings: Time and Place Regular monthly meetings shall be held on the second and/or fourth Wednesdays of each month beginning at 6:00 P.M. in City Hall except as otherwise designated by the Planning Commission unless a meeting has been noticed as taking place virtually. If a stay at home order or other disruptive event has occurred that affects Port Angeles and precludes the Planning Commission from meeting in City Hall, meetings shall be noticed and the alternative physical or virtual location shall be specified in the notice. Any change in the hour, date, and place of regular meetings shall be given wide publicity for the convenience of persons having business before the Commission. When the regular meeting day falls on a legal holiday, the replacement date will be designated by the Planning Commission with notice posted to the public per the Open Public Meetings Act. 3 Section 2. Recessed Meetings Any regular meeting may be recessed to a definite time, place, and date by a majority vote of the Planning Commission members present at the meeting. Section 3. Special Meetings Special meetings may be called by the Chair or Planning staff with approval of the Chair. Section 4. Cancellation of Regular Meetings In the event it is necessary to cancel a meeting due to lack of agenda issues, Planning staff will contact the Chair and each Commission member prior to the meeting and will provide notice to the public per the Open Public Meetings Act. Section 5. Notice of Meetings Notice of all regular and special meetings shall be given by the Executive Secretary to the members of the Planning Commission in accordance with current RCWs. Notice to members of the Planning Commission and to members of the public of all special meetings shall be provided at least 2 days (48 hours) prior to the special meeting. In addition to the provision of the notice of all special meetings to the members of the Planning Commission, notice shall be provided to each local newspaper of general circulation in the City of Port Angeles and on the Newsflash located on the official City of Port Angeles Webpage. Said notice shall be transmitted electronically or mailed at least 24 hours before the time of the meeting specified in the notice. The notice shall state the time and place of the meeting and the business to be transacted by the Commission. The meeting agenda for the next regular meetings shall be closed on Friday at the close of business five (5) days prior to the next regular meeting of the Planning Commission except that urgent matters may be inserted on the agenda later at the discretion of the Chair. Petitions and communications from the audience and matters brought to the meeting by the Planning Staff and Commission members, which are not on the agenda for the meeting, may be received and discussed at the meeting. However, no official action may be taken on any matter at a Planning Commission meeting which is not included on the agenda for that meeting or which has been added to the agenda after it has been received by the Planning Commission members except that this requirement may be suspended at any meeting by the unanimous vote of the members present at the meeting. Section 6. Order of Business - Regular Meeting for Administrative, Routine, and Hearing-Type Matters (a) Call to order by Chair (b) Roll call (c) Approval of minutes of preceding meeting (d) Public hearings/Other business (e) Communications from the Public (f) Staff Updates (g) Reports of Commission Members 4 (h) Adjournment Section 7. Order of Business - Regular Meeting for Discussion of Matters Related to Comprehensive Planning (a) Call to order by Chair (b) Roll call (c) Approval of minutes of preceding meeting (d) Staff Updates for current business (e) Reports from Planning Commission members and committees (f) Communications from audience (related to comprehensive planning only) (g) Communications from Planning Commission members (h) Adjourn Section 8. Operational Guidelines (a) All requests and applications on zoning, annexations, and vacations will be tabled if the applicant or an authorized representative is not present at the hearing on the request or application. (b) All requests and applications will be tabled if all essential information is not provided to the Planning Department staff by Friday, five days prior to the regular Wednesday meetings of the Planning Commission for timely analysis and inclusion into the Commissioners information packets. (c) All requests and applications requiring legal opinion or interpretation will be tabled until the Planning Commission has received an opinion or interpretation from the City Attorney. (d) The Commission shall act as a body in making its decisions and in announcing them. (e) Willful misrepresentation of information pertaining to a request or application will void that request or application upon discovery of the misrepresentation. (f) The Planning Commission will not commence a new hearing after 10 P.M. unless agreed upon by the Planning Commission. Section 9. Public Hearing Procedure (a) Chair introduces the discussion item orally and outlines the public hearing procedures to be followed during the public hearing process. The Chair then reads qualifying questions to the Commissioners regarding the Appearance of Fairness and Conflict of Interest Doctrines and opens the public hearing. (b) Planning Staff presents a staff report and provides a recommendation. Commissioners are permitted to ask the Chair or staff any relevant questions about the application. The public hearing will be opened with a brief explanation of the procedures to be followed (c) The spokesperson for proponents in the audience shall be given an opportunity to speak in favor of the application. Information submitted should be factual, relevant, and not merely duplication of previous presentation(s). A reasonable time (10 minutes) shall be 5 allowed the spokesman; others shall be limited to short supporting remarks (5 minutes). Each person speaking shall give their name, location of residence, and nature of the interest in the matter. The Chair may allow additional public testimony if the issue warrants it. Any data presented shall be retained by staff and marked as an exhibit. (d) The spokesperson for opponents in the audience shall be given an opportunity to speak against the application. Information submitted should be factual, relevant, and not merely a duplication of a previous presentation. A reasonable time (10 minutes) shall be allowed the spokesman; others shall be limited to short supporting remarks (5 minutes). Each person speaking shall give his or her name, location of residence, and nature of the interest in the matter. The Chair may allow additional public testimony if the issue warrants it. Any data presented shall be retained by staff and marked as an exhibit. (e) Other interested parties shall be allowed to comment briefly (5 minutes) or make inquiries. (f) There can be a brief rebuttal (5 minutes) for proponents and opponents each heard separately and consecutively, with presentation limited to their spokesperson. The rebuttal shall be limited to factual statements pertaining to previous testimony. The Chair may allow additional public testimony if the issue warrants it. (g) The public hearing is closed. Commissioners voice their considerations and pose any relevant questions through the Chair. Specific questions may be posed through the Chair to a particular speaker to clarify testimony previously presented. (h) Motion for disposition is presented and an action taken. Section 10. Quorum Four members of the Planning Commission shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of business and the taking of official action. If there are vacancies on the Commission, quorum shall constitute a majority of the existing membership. Section 11. Motions Motions shall be restated by the Chair before a vote is taken. The names of the members making and seconding a motion shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting. Section 12. Voting Any action taken by a majority of those present, when those present constitute a quorum, at any regular, recessed, or special meeting of the Planning Commission shall be deemed and taken as the action of the Commission except that any proposed change of the Zoning Map must be approved by a majority of the total membership of the Planning Commission. Voting on amendments to the Zoning Ordinance and Map, all matters requiring a public hearing before the Planning Commission, and all matters referred to the Planning Commission by the City Council shall be by the vote of each member and shall be recorded in the minutes of the meeting. 6 Section 13. Staff Reports On all matters considered by the Planning Commission, the report and recommendations, if any, of the Planning staff shall be presented to the Commission and shall become part of the formal record of the action and recorded in the minutes of the meeting. Section 14. Conflict of Interest and Appearance of Fairness Any member of the Planning Commission who has an interest in any matter before the Commission that would or could tend to prejudice his or her actions thereon, shall so publicly indicate this fact and shall abstain from voting or participating in any way in the Commission's action on that matter. Section 15. Attendance Attendance at regular meetings and executive sessions is expected of all Commission members. Any members anticipating absence from an official meeting or executive session shall notify the Chair or Executive Secretary in advance. Any absence may be excused by the Commission, even for an extended period, provided the absence is approved in advance. Section 16. Parliamentary Procedure Parliamentary procedure in Planning Commission meetings shall be governed by Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised unless it is specifically provided otherwise in these Bylaws, in other Planning Commission resolutions, in City Ordinances, or in the State of Washington Planning Enabling Act (Chapter 35.63 RCW). Section 17. Public Nature of Meetings and Records All regular, recessed, and special meetings, hearings, records, and accounts shall be open to the public provided, however, executive sessions may be held by the Commission as provided in RCW 42.30.110. ARTICLE V - COMMITTEES Section 1. Establishment of Committees The Planning Commission may establish such standing or special committees as it deems advisable and assign each committee specific duties or functions. Each standing committee shall consist of 3 members. No standing or special committee shall have the power to commit the Planning Commission to the endorsement of any plan or program without the plan or program submitted and approved by a quorum of the Commission. Section 2. Appointment and Terms of Committee Members The Chair of the Planning Commission shall appoint the members of each standing or special committee and shall name the chair of each committee. The members of each standing committee shall be appointed at the first regular meeting in July for a term of one year. Special committees may be appointed at such times and for such purposes and terms as the Planning Commission approves. 7 Section 3. Committee Vacancies Vacancies on committees shall be filled immediately by the Chair of the Planning Commission for the unexpired portion of the term. Section 4. Meetings of Committees The committees shall meet at the call of the committee chairman; in addition the Chair of the Planning Commission shall also have the authority to call a special meeting of any committee at any time and upon such notice as They may specify. The Planning Staff shall issue notice of committee meetings at the request of a committee chair or the Planning Commission Chair. Section 5. Quorum and Voting The majority of the members appointed shall constitute a quorum of all committees. The affirmative vote of a majority of the committee membership shall be required for the adoption of a matter before the committee. ARTICLE VI - AMENDMENTS Section 1. Amendments These Bylaws may be amended at any regular meeting by the affirmative vote of five (5) members of the Planning Commission provided that the proposed amendments have been submitted in writing at a previous meeting. Amended April 14, 2021 As amended: 2/23/76; 8/23/78; 5/23/79; 1/19/88; 3/16/90; 4/25/90; 4/29/90; 6/23/93; 1/12/94; 3/24/2004; 5/08/13; 01/25/2017; 8/26/20; 4/14/22 Discussion Item #1 2025 Comprehensive Plan Periodic Update Scope of Work 2023 Amendment City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan This page is left intentionally blank 2023 Amendment Acknowledgements The following citizen volunteers, past and present elected officials and staff are acknowledged for their various contributions to the 2023 amendment of this Comprehensive Plan, last updated in 2019 and last periodically updated in 2016. These individuals contributed hundreds of hours to a citizen participation process, striving to reflect the wishes of the community in this long-range plan. Everyone's efforts have made this planning effort a success and are greatly appreciated. 2023 City Council Members Kate Dexter, Mayor Charlie McCaughan Brendan Meyer, Deputy Mayor LaTrisha Suggs Navarra Carr Lindsey Schromen-Wawrin Amy Miller 2023 Planning Commission Members Benjamin Stanley, Chair Marolee Smith Andrew Schwab, Vice Chair James Taylor Richie Ahuja Colin Young Tammy Dziadek 2023 Staff Nathan West, City Manager Calvin Goings, Assistant City Manager and Director of Community Services Shannen Cartmel, Deputy Director of Community Services and Community and Economic Development Manager Ben Braudrick, Principal Planner Zach Trevino, Assistant Planner 2019 City Council Members Sissi Bruch, Mayor Michael Merideth Kate Dexter, Deputy Mayor Jim Moran Mike French Lindsey Schromen-Wawrin Cherie Kidd 2019 Planning Commission Members Andrew Schwab Amy Powell Benjamin Stanley Mel Messineo Steve Hopkins Pamela Hastings Duane Morris Tara Lopez 2019 Staff Nathan West, City Manager Ben Braudrick, Assistant Planner Allyson Brekke, DCED Director Kevin Bagwell, Planning Technician 2016 City Council Members Patrick Downie, Mayor Michael Merideth Cherie Kidd, Deputy Mayor Lee Whetham Brad Collins Sissi Bruch Dan Gase 2016 Planning Commission Members Andrew Schwab Elwyn Gee Brian Hunter John Mathews Chad Aubin Matt Bailey Duane Morris 2016 Staff Dan McKeen, City Manager Craig Fulton, Public Works Director Nathan West, DCED Director Byron Olson, Finance Director Ben Braudrick, Assistant Planner Scott Johns, Associate Planner Consultants: Studio Cascade Inc., Spokane WA Minor amendments are made to the Comprehensive Plan on an annual basis. City Clerk Certification Table of Contents Chapter 1 - Introduction Foundation of City Policy ............................................................................................................ 1•1 GMA Compliance ........................................................................................................................ 1•1 Purpose of the Comprehensive Plan .......................................................................................... 1•2 Compliance with the Comprehensive Plan ................................................................................. 1•3 Plan Development & Public Participation ................................................................................... 1•4 Organization & Requirements of the Comprehensive Plan ........................................................ 1•4 Use of the Comprehensive Plan ................................................................................................. 1•8 Community Vision ...................................................................................................................... 1•9 City Actions Since the 2004 Update ........................................................................................... 1•13 Chapter 2 - Growth Management General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 2•2 GMA Goals & Policies ................................................................................................................. 2•3 Chapter 3 - Land Use General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 3•1 Land Use Categories ................................................................................................................... 3•2 Future Land Use Map (Figure 3.01) ....................................................................................................... 3•5 Land Use Map Goals & Policies .................................................................................................. 3•7 Residential Goals & Policies ........................................................................................................ 3•7 Commercial Goals & Policies ...................................................................................................... 3•8 Industrial Goals & Policies .......................................................................................................... 3•10 Open Space Goals & Policies ...................................................................................................... 3•11 Chapter 4 - Transportation General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 4•1 Transportation Goals & Policies ................................................................................................. 4•2 Chapter 5 - Utilities & Public Services General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 5•1 Utilities Goals & Policies ............................................................................................................. 5•2 Chapter 6 - Housing General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 6•1 Housing Goals & Policies ............................................................................................................ 6•2 i City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Chapter 7 - Conservation General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 7•1 Conservation Goals & Policies .................................................................................................... 7•2 Chapter 8 - Capital Facilities General Comments ..................................................................................................................... 8•1 Capital Facilities Goals & Policies ................................................................................................ 8•3 Chapter 9 - Economic Development General Comments .....................................................................................................................9•1 Economic Development Goals & Policies ...................................................................................9•2 Chapter 10 - Parks & Recreation General Comments ................................................................................................................... 10•1 Parks & Recreation Goals & Policies ......................................................................................... 10•2 Chapter 11 - Implementation General Comments ................................................................................................................... 11•1 Objectives Table (Table 11.01) ........................................................................................................... 11•3 Appendix A - Community Profile (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Appendix B - Definitions (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Appendix C - GMA Requirements (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Appendix D - Transportation Analysis (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Appendix E - City-Wide Performance Measures (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Appendix F - Comprehensive Plan Related Documents (See Appendix Table of Contents for listing) Table of Contents ii Introduction 1 Foundation of City Policy The comprehensive plan is the policy foundation for the City; it sets fundamental goals, policies, and objectives that are the basis for all action. The City’s budget, Capital Facilities Plan, work plan, transportation plan, and departmental performance standards are all based on and are consistent with comprehensive plan policy. The City's strategic plan also ties back to the comprehensive plan, specifically addressing how the City will implement comprehensive plan objectives over the next two years, establishing priorities for action. GMA Compliance In 1990, the Washington State Legislature enacted the State Growth Management Act (GMA), which requires all cities and counties subject to the Act to develop and adopt comprehensive plans and implementing ordinances that will regulate and guide future growth and development. In accordance with the Act, each county must also establish independent Urban Growth Areas capable of containing future growth for the next 20 years. To ensure compatibility between various comprehensive plans, the cities, county, and other affected agencies cooperatively developed a set of county-wide planning policies to guide this process. To ensure orderly development, the City of Port Angeles agreed to work with Clallam County in the development of comprehensive plan goals and policies for the Port Angeles Urban Growth Area (UGA). The Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan has been developed and periodically updated to meet the requirements of the GMA and is consistent with the Clallam County-Wide Planning Policy. This 2016 update was undertaken to meet the State's GMA requirements and included a process intended to capture comments and suggestions from the broadest range of the public. Purpose of the Comprehensive Plan A City's Comprehensive Plan acts as the guiding document for land use controls. All other city plans, ordinances, and regulations must be consistent with the goals, policies, and intent of the City’s Comprehensive Plan. If subordinate planning or regulations, such as the City's Zoning Ordinance or Capital Facility Plan, are not consistent with the goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan, then those documents may be determined to be illegal and rendered invalid. Prior to the passage of the State GMA, such compliance was considered desirable but actual consistency was not required. The GMA now makes such compliance a requirement. The Comprehensive Plan is the basis upon which local governmental decisions are to be made. It sets forth the City's goals and policies and visualizes directions the City will take over the next two decades. The Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map illustrates the desired development pattern for the city. It is, therefore, important that the Comprehensive Plan truly reflect the goals and desires of the community. In order for that to take place, it is vital that citizens take an active role in determining the quality, context, and vision incorporated within this Comprehensive Plan. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•2 Figure 1.01 – The 2016 update process reviewed and updated this plan's vision, as well as many of its implementing policies and objectives. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) Compliance with the Comprehensive Plan The Comprehensive Plan is the foundation upon which the City’s development regulations (zoning, environmentally sensitive areas protection, parking and sign codes, and subdivision ordinances) and Urban Services Standards and Guidelines Manual, Capital Facilities Plan and Urban Services and Utilities Plans are based, and from which the City’s future land use pattern will come. A community is a diverse and heterogeneous grouping of people. Individually, each of us has a set of treasured values. Together, we give the community a set of shared values. In a community, individual values often clash and indeed must confront each other if the shared values of the community are to develop. Good planning uncovers the values we share as a community and uses the shared values to guide development of the Comprehensive Plan. No plan can be expected to last for all time. Times change, conditions change, and what we value in our community changes. Even though this Comprehensive Plan is intended to cover a 20- year period, the State requires it to be reviewed at least every seven years and can be amended on an annual basis as necessary. This allows the City to adjust the Comprehensive Plan as conditions, Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•3 needs, and desires of the community change. Through the ongoing development of this Comprehensive Plan, the City of Port Angeles reaffirms that it is the rightful goal of the people of our community to take an active role, sharing the work and responsibility involved in determining the character, quality, and destiny of this community. Plan Development & Public Participation The Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan was initially updated from its 1976 version under the GMA in June of 1994. The City's last major update to the Comprehensive Plan was in 2016. Several minor amendments have been approved since that time. The 2016 updates reflected a citywide approach with an ambitious public participation program. The 2016 update of the Comprehensive Plan was updated to meet the requirements of the GMA. Areas of the plan that were expanded to include handling of archaeological discoveries and sites, the inclusion of low-impact stormwater management methods that more closely mimic natural processes, increased emphasis on urban forestry and landscaping and consideration of issues surrounding climatic change. The City of Port Angeles allows amendments to the Comprehensive Plan to occur on an annual basis, within limited time periods. The intent of this allowance is to address the community’s desire to adjust zoning, which might also require a change in land use designation. Individual citizens or groups may propose Comprehensive Plan amendments during the three-month period between January 1 and March 31 of each year. Proposed amendments require environmental review, consideration by the Planning Commission and opportunity for the public to participate, and a public hearing prior adoption by the City Council. Organization & Requirements of the Comprehensive Plan The Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan is organized with an (1) Introduction, (2) a series of required and included elements., and (3) various appendixes including community profile, definition section, the Capital Facilities Plan, Housing Needs Assessment, Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•4 and Environmental Impact Statement. Each element addresses a particular topic and contains a general comment section and multiple goals with various related policies and objectives. Some of the elements have an associated map or plan. The Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan goals are expressed as broad statements of intent that will fulfill the vision of what the city intends to become or how the city should look or feel in the future. The goals in the Comprehensive Plan are supported by policy statements that usually include the word should. The policy statements are directive, and provide a basis for decision- making and establish a principal of wise management leading to achievement of a goal. Objectives are statements of specific actions that when taken will result in the realization of a goal. The GMA requires that a comprehensive plan consist of a map or maps and descriptive text covering objectives, principles, and standards used to develop the comprehensive plan. The plan must also be an internally consistent document, with all elements made consistent with the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map. The Land Use Map is provided to show general uses to be located in generalized areas of the City. The plan shows six general land use categories: Low, Medium and High-Density Residential; and Commercial, Industrial, and Open Space. These general land use areas are not specifically bounded by streets, parcel lines, or other political boundaries. For purposes of this plan, they are separated by what is referred to as "imprecise margins." These, together with the land use categories, provide a framework and direction for desired development patterns, while at the same time, allow for flexibility in applying zoning designations. The GMA requires that comprehensive plans include a plan, scheme, or design for each of the following: ■ Land Use Element ■ Transportation Element ■ Utilities Element ■ Housing Element ■ Capital Facilities Plan Element. Additionally, comprehensive plans must contain a process for identifying and siting Essential Public Facilities. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•5 This plan contains each of the required elements as well as four additional optional elements: A Conservation Element, an Economic Development Element, a Growth Management Element and a Parks & Recreation Element. Each of the elements have been developed to be consistent with the GMA and to reflect the needs and desires of the City of Port Angeles and its citizens. Detailed minimum requirements for GMA-required elements are provided in Appendix C. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•6 Figure 1.02 – Comprehensive plans are organized as tiered systems, expressing community desires from broad-brush ideals (vision) through specific action items the City can lead (objectives). Other types of plans are sometimes prepared to identify or help implement objectives, taking vision, goal and policy cues from the comprehensive plan. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•7 Use of the Comprehensive Plan The Comprehensive Plan is designed to be used by the public as a way for citizens to learn the long-range goals and policies of the City. It is also used as a foundation upon which City officials make land use and other decisions, and as a tool which City staff uses to ensure desirable development of the City. This document provides a sense of predictability to citizens of the city or potential residents considering relocating to Port Angeles. The Plan's Environmental Impact Statement (EIS, Appendix A) is designed as a programmatic EIS and may be used as a phased reviewed environmental document for any plans, ordinances, programs, or development projects that are consistent with the goals and policies of the Comprehensive Plan. The EIS has been updated through addenda and regular State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) review as amendments to the Comprehensive Plan have been periodically approved. Any project proposed in the City will have to show that it is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. If it is not, it cannot be approved unless the Comprehensive Plan is amended and additional environmental review is completed Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•8 Community Vision The Comprehensive Plan public process with the 2016 mandated update resulted in the following vision statements for a variety of specific areas of interest to citizens, Vision statements are based on the anticipated conditions of Port Angeles in 2036. The City of Port Angeles is vibrant and prospering, nurturing a balance of innovation and tradition to create an environmentally, economically, and fiscally sustainable community, accepting and cherishing its social diversity, small-town character and natural setting. In achieving this vision, Port Angeles recognizes the important roles each of the following plays: Environment Port Angeles’ natural setting – with the Strait to the north and the Olympics to the south – is unique, with creeks, wetlands, steep slopes and a weather pattern that can be demanding. The town balances the community’s need for economic stability, its potential for growth and the preservation of the areas’ natural systems. Economic Development Keeping the community employed, prosperous, edu cated, and well-served are key economic development objectives. The City of Port Angeles facilitates sustained economic growth, directing investment to revitalize activity downtown, support local employment, and keep public services affordable and of high quality. Neighborhoods Slightly more than 25,000 people call Port Angeles home in 2036, residing in neighborhoods that are safe, attractive and rich in character. Airport Fairchild International Airport is an important aviation resource for local residents and businesses, operating as an important economic development and community safety priority and with regular commercial service to SeaTac International Airport. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•9 Downtown Port Angeles’ central business district is vital and prominent. The central commercial district is one of Port Angeles’ major assets, intimately connected to the waterfront and featuring a variety of retail, civic, residential and professional office uses. Small Commercial Centers Small-scale commercial centers are located in areas convenient for nearby residents and workers, offering a modest array of goods and services within an easy, enjoyable walk from nearby homes and employment centers. Waterfront The central waterfront is an active and successful civic and social space, equally welcoming to residents and visitors. Transportation Port Angeles’ transportation network moves people and goods to, through and within the community, harmoniously accommodating cars, bikes, trucks, public transportation, planes, boats, ferries, and travel by foot. Community Services The community’s systems of housing, transportation, economic development and parks and recreation coordinate to serve all of Port Angeles’ residents, ensuring public safety, economic opportunity, public health and overall community wellness. Trails Port Angeles’ trail system builds on the Olympic Discovery Trail and miles of local trails, contributing to the local quality of life by inviting community residents and visitors of all ages to wander and explore. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•10 Parks and Recreation Leisure is an important contributor to quality of life, and Port Angeles is committed to provide a robust parks and recreation system in response. Open spaces, both constructed and natural, function to enliven the human spirit. Whether it’s a small pocket park near downtown, a waterfront esplanade, a sculpture garden on the hill, or a vast sports complex, the system serves multiple community needs. The American Institute of Architects Sustainable Design Assessment Team Report Vision In 2009, the City of Port Angeles was inspired by the concept of bringing in individuals with an outside eye to review development trends and community issues. The City prepared a grant application to the American Institute of Architect’s Center for Communities by Design focused on tourism and community development. The application sought a Sustainable Design Assessment Team (SDAT) to travel to Port Angeles. In March of that year five (5) team members engaged the community to learn more about local challenges and to present a series of resolutions to those issues. An intense three day planning exercise ended with thirty new recommendations for the community to pursue. Allured by the quality and respect given to the American Institute of Architects organization participation was widespread resulting in a high level of interest far bey ond that of a typical planning process. Community members filled Council chambers and anxiously sought follow up to the recommendations. The City made a commitment to move forward with recommendations. Specifically the City Council sub-committee known as the Port Angeles Forward Committee assisted in getting the low hanging fruit of the plan implemented. Instead of waiting for the final report, the Committee dissected the power point presentation from the final evening meeting of the SDAT process and developed a detailed list of each specified project. Within two weeks, 10 items were moved forward to City Council for implementation. Next the City promoted an additional public meeting for members of the public to publicly rank each of the SDAT team recommendations. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•11 Immediate items included comprehensive plan changes and policy oriented issues which shifted focus towards specific capital projects and code changes. The first ten implementation items included the introduction of 5 new items in the City Capital Facilities Plan and 5 new policy items for insertion in the City’s Comprehensive Plan. Since this initial year new items from the plan have been implemented annually. The American Institute of Architects (AIA) report has become the Council endorsed vision for the City of Port Angeles. This vision complemented by the continued public input received at public meetings and engagement sessions over the last nine (9) years. The vision focuses on improving: the gateways to our community, our downtown, our primary transportation corridors and sustaining and enhancing the quality of our local environment and economy. The visions approach is: • integrative, holistic, and visual; • central to achieving a sustainable relationship between humans, the natural environment, and the place; • it gives three-dimensional form to a culture and a place; and • it achieves balance between culture, environment, and economic systems. Today the comprehensive plan acts as one of the primary implementing instruments of the AIA report. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•12 Figure 1.03 – Phase II of efforts identified in the 2013 Waterfront & Transportation Improvement Plan (a subarea plan) designed, permitted and re-established a beach just west of Oak Street. The site had formerly been graded and utilized for mill operations. (Images: City of Port Angeles, Studio Cascade, Inc.) City Actions Since the 2004 Update Since the last major update of the Comprehensive Plan, several objectives have been accomplished. Those accomplishments include the replacement of both century- old trestle bridges spanning Valley Creek and Tumwater Creek on 8th Street. The bridge spanning Peabody Creek at Lauridsen Boulevard was replaced with a structure that will allow truck traffic to make the turn and follow Lauridsen as intended for a cross-town alternative to Highway 101. The City's landfill has been closed and converted into a regional transfer station, and work to remove waste materials that remain in the marine bluff and stabilize the bluff to prevent further adverse impacts to the shoreline is now complete. A major project to resolve long-standing issues with combined sewer/stormwater systems overflowing into the Strait of Juan de Fuca has been completed and the second project phase is underway and nearing completion. The City has followed through with the creation of new zone designations in anticipation of future annexations, especially the Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•13 Figure 1.04 – Phase I of efforts identified in the 2013 Waterfront & Transportation Improvement Plan designed and created a new esplanade along Railroad Avenue between Laurel and Oak streets. (Image: LMN Architects) eastern UGA. The Commercial Regional zone was created to be applied to areas along Highway 101 where existing large commercial uses such as car dealerships and large-volume stores currently exist or where land is available for such uses. A major infrastructure goal was achieved with the extension of a sewer main line to the eastern UGA. A second new zone was created for large suburban-scale residential lots. The Residential, Low Density zone (R11), restricting residential lots to a minimum of 9,000 square feet or larger has been applied to areas within existing city limits. An Industrial Marine (IM) zone was also created to be applied to shoreline areas focusing primarily on marine trades that may need the support of commercial uses to provide a framework for mixed uses in a campus-like environment. In 2009 the City received a grant from the American Institute of Architects (AIA). The grant resulted community planning effort known as the Sustainable Design Assessment. The AIA Sustainable Design Assessment Team Report has been adopted and incorporated as an extension of the Comprehensive Plan. Implementation of the document can be found throughout the implementation chapter of this document as well as in the City’s Strategic Plan. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•14 Industrial zoning was modified to include the potential for work/live situations, where working artists requiring large work studios with industrial types of activities, are permitted to live at their studios by conditional use permit. A major planning effort was completed in 2014. The Shoreline Master Program (SMP) was approved and accepted by the Department of Ecology, completing a five-year effort that included the writing of a new Harbor Resource Management Plan, Shoreline Inventory/Characterization/Analysis Document, a Cumulative Impacts Analysis and a Shoreline Restoration Plan. The shoreline planning effort took place concurrently with several restoration projects occurring on the south shoreline of Ediz Hook. The last phase of shoreline restoration was completed during the summer months of 2016, and will result in a continuous restored shoreline from Harbor View Park on the east to Sail and Paddle Park on the west. A 358-acre area was annexed into the City in 2005. The area is located along the south side of Highway 101, west of the city limits at that time. The area primarily consists of the Eclipse Industrial Park, accommodating several large operations, and much of the area is zoned Industrial Heavy. Portions of the annexed area along Highway 101 also include commercial and residential uses. Another major accomplishment is the construction of a Waterfront Promenade located between Oak Street and Laurel Street in the city's downtown. The promenade was the first phase of a multi- phase project planned for the downtown waterfront. The second phase, also completed, included creation of two small beach areas where hard- armored shoreline once existed west of Oak Street to the Valley Creek Estuary Park. Enhancements to the Waterfront Trail are also an integral portion of the project. Subsequent phases will improve the portion of Railroad Avenue east of Laurel Street to City Pier Park. An associated downtown project that had been anticipated for several years was also completed. This "Gateway Project" resulted in a downtown transit center and covered pavilion area for public activities. The pavilion is now used regularly for the local Farmers Market, and as a venue for various festivals. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•15 A portion of downtown's sidewalks and water lines were replaced beginning in 2006. As part of that project, the west side of Laurel Street between First and Front was developed to preserve the last remaining portion of the "Port Angeles Underground." Regionally, a major effort involved the removal of the two dams placed on the Elwha River a century ago. This project included reconstruction of the City's water collection system and the intake for the industrial water supply. In addition, a new bridge was built spanning the river. The new bridge includes a suspended pedestrian/ bicycle segment of the Olympic Discovery Trail. The Olympic Discovery Trail between the western city limits and 18th Street was improved as the trail right-of-way and was also used for a sewer line extension to the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe's reservation lands. The sewer extension outside of the city was made necessary by the removal of the dams upstream from the reservation. The removal of the dams resulted in a higher ground water table, making on-site sewer drainfields unusable. The reservation is now served by City sewer facilities. In 2007, the City added a Parks & Recreation Element to the Comprehensive Plan. In 2009, the City implemented a Façade and Sign Improvement Grant program to help small businesses enhance the appearance of buildings in the city. Another effort at citywide beautification was accomplished in 2014 with the passage of a Street Tree Ordinance. The passage of the ordinance resulted in the City being awarded the "Tree City USA" designation from the National Arbor Day Foundation. All of the above-mentioned projects were included in the earlier version of the Comprehensive Plan as goals, policies, or objectives. Chapter 1 - Introduction 1•16 (This page is intentionally left blank) 2•1 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Growth Management This Comprehensive Plan has been developed in accordance with the requirements of the State Growth Management Act (GMA). The City met all of the Act's required deadlines for compliance and participated with Clallam County (The County), the City of Forks, the City of Sequim, area Tribes and other agencies in the development of a County- Wide Planning Policy. Early in the planning process, the City agreed with the County to address only areas within the current City Limits in the Comprehensive Plan and to work with the County on a joint Comprehensive Plan for the Urban Growth Area (UGA). On April 13, 1993, the Board of Clallam County Commissioners adopted an Interim Port Angeles UGA. In 2005, the City and County entered into an interlocal agreement on a phased annexation plan for the Eastern UGA. A similar agreement was reached regarding the western UGA. At that time, the City established the intended zones that would be applied to areas annexed to the City from the Eastern UGA. The following goals and policies are included to insure continued compliance with the GMA, and compatibility with the County's Comprehensive Plan outside of the Port Angeles UGA (PAUGA). Actions related to GMA goals and policies are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. 2 ■ GMA Goals & Policies Goal G-2A To manage growth in a responsible manner that is beneficial to the community as a whole, is sensitive to the rights and needs of individuals, and is consistent with the State of Washington's Growth Management Act. Policies P-2A.01 In all its actions and to the extent consistent with the provisions of this comprehensive plan, the City will strive to implement the following goals of the State Growth Management Act: a) Urban growth. Encourage development in urban areas where adequate public facilities and services exist or can be provided in an efficient manner. b) Reduce sprawl. Reduce the inappropriate conversion of undeveloped land into sprawling, low-density development. c) Transportation. Encourage efficient multi- modal transportation systems that are based on regional priorities and coordinated with county and city comprehensive plans. d) Housing. Encourage the availability of affordable housing to all economic segments of the population. Promote a variety of residential densities and housing types and sizes, and encourage preservation and expansion of existing housing stock. e) Economic development. Encourage economic development throughout the region that is consistent with adopted comprehensive plans, promote economic opportunity, especially for unemployed and for disadvantaged persons, and encourage growth in areas experiencing insufficient economic growth, all within the capacities of the region's natural resources, public services and public facilities. f) Property rights. Private property should not be taken for public use without just compensation having been made. The property rights of landowners should be protected from arbitrary and discriminatory actions. 2•3 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan g) Permits. Applications for both state and local government permits should be processed in a timely and fair manner to ensure predictability. h) Natural resource industries. Maintain and enhance regional natural resource-based industries, including productive timber management, agricultural, and fisheries industries. i) Open space and recreation. Encourage the retention of open space and development of recreational opportunities, conserve fish and wildlife habitat areas. Increase access to natural resource lands and water, and develop parks. j) Environment. Protect the environment and enhance the state's high quality of life, including air and water quality, and the availability of water. k) Citizen participation and coordination. Encourage the involvement of citizens in the planning process and ensure coordination between communities and jurisdictions to reconcile conflicts. l) Public facilities and services. Ensure that those public facilities and services necessary to support development should be adequate to serve the development at the time the development is available for occupancy and use without decreasing current service levels below locally established minimum standards. m) Historic preservation. Identify and encourage the preservation of lands, sites and structures that have historical or archaeological significance. P-2A.02 The Port Angeles Urban Growth Area (PAUGA) should be established based at a minimum upon land use demand as determined by the Clallam County 20-year population forecast for Clallam County and specified sub-areas, so long as the county-wide forecast is not less than the most recent forecasts available from the State Office of Financial Management. P-2A.03 Provide urban services/facilities consistent with the Capital Facilities Element. P-2A.04 Work with the County and other service providers to determine the appropriate levels of service for such facilities and services and to ensure consistency between service provision within the City, the PAUGA, and the County. P-2A.05 Include areas in the PAUGA that are characterized by urban growth adjacent to the existing City boundaries and take into account the area's physical features. P-2A.06 Locate land designated for commercial or industrial uses that encourage adjacent urban development within the PAUGA. P-2A.07 Base the amount of acreage designated for commercial, industrial, or other non-residential uses within the PAUGA upon the Land Use Element and Economic Development Element in the City's Comprehensive Plan. Chapter 2 - Growth Management Element 2•4 Goals & Policies P-2A.08 Avoid and exclude critical areas and resource lands in the inclusion of the PUAGA unless addressed as part of the City's Comprehensive Plan. P-2A.09 Include, at a minimum, planning and the provision of sanitary sewer systems, solid waste collection/disposal systems, water systems, urban roads and pedestrian facilities, street cleaning services, transit systems, stormwater systems, police, fire and emergency services systems, electrical and communication systems, school and health care facilities, and neighborhood and/or community parks within the PAUGA. P-2A.10 Be the ultimate provider of urban services within the City limits and the PAUGA for those services the City provides except to the extent otherwise provided in a UGA Urban Services and Development Agreement that is reached pursuant to the County-Wide Planning Policy. P-2A.11 Provide constructed urban services/facilities for which the City is the ultimate provider to meet the design and construction standards of the City. P-2A.12 Demonstrate the financial capability for continued operation of a new facility prior to construction. P-2A.13 Ensure the protection of critical areas occurring within the PAUGA. P-2A.14 Promulgate all development regulations with due regard for private property rights in order to avoid regulatory takings or violation of due process and to protect property rights of landowners from arbitrary and discriminatory actions. P-2A.15 Work with the County to designate and set aside additional lands on the west side of the City for industrial and commercial purposes, both inside the City limits and in the UGA. P-2A.16 Establish performance measures to review progress toward accommodating growth and to ensure appropriate actions are taken to achieve the goals within the Comprehensive Plan. Goal G-2B To ensure the orderly transition of land within the PAUGA into the City of Port Angeles. Policies P-2B.01 Annexation of land outside the established boundaries of the PAUGA shall not be allowed. P-2B.02 Annexation of land from within the established boundaries of the PAUGA shall be in accordance with the adopted annexation laws. P-2B.03 Annexation of land not adjacent to and/or contiguous with the established City Limits boundary-line, should not be allowed. 2•5 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-2B.04 Appropriately classify and zone such land at the time of annexation based upon the City Comprehensive Land Use Map and the City Comprehensive Plan. The provisions, restrictions, and requirements of The Port Angeles Zoning Code shall apply to development of the annexed area. P-2B.05 Remain consistent with the orderly extension of urban services/facilities and be in accordance with the City's Comprehensive Plan and capital facility planning in the annexation and development of land. P-2B.06 Restrict annexation of developed land that cannot meet established concurrency requirements of the City within six years from the time of annexation. P-2B.07 Restrict annexation of land that results in decreased minimum standards for City streets, water service, sewer service, and/or electrical service provided to existing residents of the City. P-2B.08 Restrict annexation of land that results in decreased minimum standards for City solid waste collection, stormwater management programs, emergency services and/or telecommunication services provided to existing residents of the City. P-2B.09 Draw annexation boundaries to eliminate boundary, interjurisdictional, and service problems. P-2B.10 Obtain necessary rights-of-way and easements prior to or at the time of annexation. P-2B.11 Facilitate annexation in a manner that will minimize financial impact to all residents and businesses. P-2B.12 Annex urban growth areas (UGAs) in accordance with State statutes as facilities are extended into those areas and as new urban development takes place. ■ Chapter 2 - Growth Management Element 2•6 Goals & Policies (This page is intentionally left blank) 2•7 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Land Use 3 The Land Use Element establishes City policy regarding how land may be developed. This element and its Future Land Use Map (Figure 3.01) establishes the following six comprehensive plan land use categories: ■ Low Density Residential ■ Medium Density Residential ■ High Density Residential ■ Commercial ■ Industrial ■ Open Space. These categories and their associated areas are configured in coordination with a wide range of planning considerations including population projections and a developable lands inventory, per GMA requirements. Details on these factors may be found in Appendices A and C. Together, the goal and policy framework presented in this element provides direction in realizing Port Angeles' long-range vision regarding land use - including optimizing the city's relationship with its setting; supporting safe, attractive and character- rich neighborhoods; creating a more dynamic, successful downtown; and supporting a wide range of recreational opportunities available to the entire community. Actions related to Land Use goals and policies are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. Land Use Categories These land use categories are described below and located on the Future Land Use Map. Low Density Residential (Up to 25 units per acre) The Land Use Map identifies three separate categories of residential land use. The first category is Low Density Residential, which allows an overall residential density up to 25 units per acre. The high majority of residentially designated property in the City will be of this designation. It is intended to accommodate single family homes, duplexes, triplexes, quadplexes, townhouses, and cottage housing in accordance with zoning regulations. Medium Density Residential (Minimum 8 units per acre) This category encourages property development involving multiple residential units including but not limited to duplexes, triplexes, quadplexes, townhouses, cottage housing, condominiums, and apartments at a density no less than 8 units per acre. High Density Residential (Minimum 12 units per acre) This category encourages development at a density no less than 12 units per acre. It is intended for areas where a higher concentration of residents is compatible with the surrounding area and uses. Condominiums and apartments are the most common types of building designs appropriate for this category. Commercial The Land Use Map contains one commercial category, thus providing maximum flexibility in the types of commercial uses allowed in permitted locations under the City’s Zoning Ordinance. Industrial The Land Use Map also designates only one industrial category, thus providing maximum flexibility in the types of industrial uses allowed in permitted locations under the City’s Zoning Ordinance. 3•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Open Space The Open Space category specifies areas of the City with unique or significant physical open spaces, such as marine shorelines, bluffs, ravines, major streams, wetlands, critical wildlife habitat, and other natural areas deemed important to the community. This category also includes developed parks and recreational spaces. The development of natural open space areas should minimize degradation of the remaining natural open space. Chapter 3 - Land Use Element 3•3 (This page intentionally left blank) Figure 3.01 – Future Land Use Map (This page intentionally left blank) ■ General Land Use Goals & Policies Goal G-3A To guide land development in a manner that balances providing certainty about future land use and allowing flexibility necessary to adapt to future challenges and opportunities. Policies P-3A.01 Use the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map as a conceptual guide when making all zoning and other land use decisions, including all land use decisions and approvals made by City Council and/or any of its appointed Commissions, Boards, or Committees. P-3A.02 Use low impact development techniques, where feasible in new land development. P-3A.03 Protect infrastructure along waterfronts, including roads, pedestrian paths, bikeways, and structures. P-3A.04 Evaluate risks of future building on coastal bluffs for sea level rise impacts. P-3A.05 Review all new development for impacts on climate change and adaptation to sea level rise through SEPA. Goal G-3B To protect and enhance the area's unique physical features, its natural, historical, archaeological, and cultural amenities, and the overall environment. Policy P-3B.01 Encourage identification, preservation, and restoration of sites and structures that have historical or cultural significance. Goal G-3C To build resilience and capacity to prepare for increased energy demand by enhancing energy and resource efficiency and diversifying the grid. Policies P-3C.01 Encourage the use of Green Building techniques for new developments and support Green Built certification for new developments. Chapter 3 - Land Use Element 3•7 Goals & Policies P-3C.02 Allow the conditional siting of clean-energy facilities (e.g., solar, wind, geothermal, wave, tidal) outside of industrial areas to increase the supply of renewable energy to the grid. P-3C.03 Provide incentives and education for low-income residents to participate in renewable energy access and energy efficient retrofits. Goal G-3D Promote cleanup of environmentally contaminated sites within the city. Policy P-3D.01 Actively pursue and participate in environmental remediation of contaminated sites using best available science. ■ Residential Goals & Policies Goal G-3E To ensure residential land use and development is compatible with the environment with existing uses and residents, and with desired urban design in a way that increases resilience against climate impacts such as drought and extreme heat. Policies P-3E.01 Provide urban services to all residential areas as required by the Capital Facilities Element concurrency policy. P-3E.02 Ensure that single family lots are of reasonable shape and have access provided by a collector arterial, local access street or alley. P-3E.03 Require the subdivision of large lots which leaves remaining lots larger than the minimum density for the zone to allow future subdivisions at the densities permitted for the zone in which they are located. P-3E.04 Design streets and circulation patterns in all new residential developments to enable fire protection and service vehicle access as key factors in street design and circulation pattern. P-3E.05 Encourage street improvements and acquisition of rights-of-way to further the grid street pattern in the central “townsite” area of the City. Permit cul-de-sacs and curvilinear streets in outlying areas subject to low impact development standards when designed in conjunction with the main street grid. P-3E.06 Encourage residential development to preserve and capitalize on existing unique natural, historic, archaeological, and/or cultural features including promotion of native and drought tolerant vegetation and scenic views. P-3E.07 Encourage new residential development to promote resilience by incorporating underground utilities. 3•8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-3E.08 Encourage design of new residential development that maximizes southern exposures and solar efficiency, protects from prevailing winds, and is designed to minimize energy use. P-3E.09 Emphasize the overall density of the development rather than minimum lot sizes when planning new residential development. Goal G-3F To create and maintain a fulfilling and enjoyable community of viable districts and neighborhoods with a variety of residential types attractive to people of all ages, characteristics and interests. Policies P-3F.01 Employ the district and neighborhood concept when developing residential land. Although such districts may be composed primarily of residential uses of a uniform density, the most healthy, viable districts are composed of residential uses of varying densities, and may be augmented, by other compatible uses. Single family and multi-family homes, parks and open-spaces, schools, churches, day care and residential services, home occupations, and district shopping areas are all legitimate components of residential districts P-3F.02 Ensure medium and high density housing is served by arterial streets of sufficient size in order to satisfy traffic demand and to lessen neighborhood traffic congestion. P-3F.03 Apply medium and high density housing policies to mobile home parks. P-3F.04 Treat manufactured homes that meet current state regulations as site constructed housing for zoning purposes. P-3F.05 Expand housing opportunities in the Central Business District for all income levels, with an emphasis moderately priced owner-occupied units. Goal G-3G Increase the housing stock to create more housing capacity, attainability, and an appropriate vacancy rate. Policies P-3G.01 Encourage high-density infill, affordable housing, and mixed-use development to increase the housing stock and increase walkability. P-3G.01 Decrease or remove parking minimums to allow higher occupancy land use. Chapter 3 - Land Use Element 3•9 ■ Commercial Goals & Policies Goal G-3H To create and maintain a healthy and diverse commercial sector for a balanced and stable local economy. Policies P-3H.01 Encourage the recruitment of new and the retention of existing commercial developments and businesses 3•8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-3H.02 Allow public uses such as government offices, public service buildings, and other public and quasi-public facilities and services in commercially designated areas. Goal G-3I To provide shopping areas meeting the needs of all City residents and visitors that are safe, compatible with surrounding land uses, and congruent with environmental goals. Policies P-3I.01 Mitigate the impacts of commercial development on adjacent residential properties, including the use of site design elements that soften the impacts. P-3I.02 Separate vehicles and bicycles from pedestrian areas whenever possible to accommodate vehicular traffic and pedestrian safety. P-3I.03 Locate shopping areas at the intersections of arterial streets of sufficient size to satisfy traffic demand and at the boundaries of neighborhoods so that more than one neighborhood may be served. Goal G-3J To provide a pleasant, safe, and attractive shopping environment in the traditional downtown waterfront area including a wide variety of shopping, dining, entertainment, arts, culture, and housing opportunities for visitors and residents alike. Policies P-3J.01 Guide commercial development in the traditional downtown to emphasize its waterfront location and historic heritage P-3J.02 Orient the design of commercial development in downtown around pedestrian travel, tourist enjoyment, and protection from adverse weather conditions. P-3J.03 Actively promote improvements to the traditional downtown area through beautification projects and in cooperation with downtown business merchants. P-3J.04 Encourage residential units in the downtown area as part of a mixed- use development concept, including live/work spaces. Ensure that the downtown physical environment is amenable to residential development by minimizing traffic impacts, maintaining security, and providing and maintaining amenities. Chapter 3 - Land Use Element 3•9 Goals & Policies ■ Industrial Goals & Policies Goal G-3K To create and maintain a healthy and diverse industrial sector for a balanced and stable local economy. Policies P-3K.01 Develop and promote a cooperative intergovernmental plan for comprehensive development of industrial infrastructure and amenities to attract and support light and heavy industry. P-3K.02 Allow office, commercial, and limited live/work uses in specifically designated industrial areas. Encourage live/work environments for art or media based cultural activities that are consistent with and avoid impact on neighboring industrial uses. P-3K.03 Consider the William R. Fairchild International Airport an essential public facility, as referenced in Appendix B (Clallam County-Wide Planning Process). Goal G-3L To provide and incentivize opportunities for industrial development in a manner, which efficiently uses the community's natural resources and physical environment, has minimal impact on the natural environment, contributes to quality of life, and is compatible with the desired development patterns Policies P-3L.01 Ensure provision of urban services to all industrial areas, as required by the Capital Facilities Element concurrency policy. P-3L.02 Develop infrastructure, which makes sites attractive and ready to develop, including transportation facilities and utilities at industrial parks. Industrial development should be encouraged to follow industrial park design concepts. P-3L.03 Ensure that industrial areas mitigate nuisances and hazardous characteristics such as noise, air, water, odor, pollution, or objectionable visual material. P-3L.04 Do not permit petroleum refineries, liquefied natural gas and liquefied petroleum gas facilities, non-clean energy facilities, energy plants and their associated facilities and associated transmission facilities (as defined in Chapter 80.50 RCW) outside the heavy industrial use area and without conditional use review. These facilities are hazardous to the community and detrimental to the general environment of the area. 3•10 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-3L.05 Discourage the siting of land uses incompatible with airport related uses and other neighboring land uses adjacent to the William R. Fairchild International Airport P-3L.06 Allow the conditional siting of clean-energy facilities (e.g., solar, wind, geothermal, wave, tidal) outside of industrial areas. P-3L.07 Through the SEPA process, consider the climate change impacts of any proposed new industrial activity or expansion before approval. Goal G-3M To facilitate reuse of large vacant or isolated industrial areas no longer in operation to improve the local economy and employment stability. Policy P-3M.01 Allow a wide range of land uses in the redevelopment of large vacant or isolated industrial areas no longer in operation, including mixed-use development, commercial development, or residential development as well as industrial uses, provided that these uses will not encourage the conversion of other industrial areas to non-industrial use. Goal G-3N Make Port Angeles food secure by promoting local and regional sustainable agriculture, utilizing multiple sources for food production and procurement, and increasing food production within the City. Policies P-3N.01 Partner with North Olympic Development Council to designate funding to promote and establish urban sustainable agriculture/food forests. P-3N.02 Encourage partnerships between local farms/farmers and residents to establish local food production projects and local composting and green waste recycling projects. P-3N.03 Work with the Department of Community and Economic Development and the Department of Public Works & Utilities to develop policies that foster agreement and resource availability systems for allowing gardening for food, habitat, or both in the right-of-way (e.g., planting strips) and explore irrigation incentives. P-3N.04 Leverage existing zoning regulations that encourage land use overlays for food production. Work with stakeholders and developers to promote land uses that facilitate local food security. P-3N.05 Implement zoning updates that simplify urban gardening like water conservation techniques, allow fencing, allow personal and community gardens, and manage poultry and livestock production. P-3N.06 Encourage the City of Port Angeles to operate a composting facility. Goals & Policies ■ Open Space Goals & Policies Goal G-3O To create open space within the urban landscape, retain natural landscapes, preserve fish and wildlife habitat, and to provide natural corridors connecting wildlife habitats. Policies P-3O.01 Preserve unique or major physical features such as marine shorelines, bluffs, ravines, streams, wetlands, wildlife habitat and other environmentally sensitive areas deemed of significant importance to the community as designated open space. P-3O.02 Promote the preservation of wildlife habitat and open space corridors between the waterfront and Olympic National Park. P-3O.03 Regulate access to natural areas open spaces so as to avoid degrading areas and to protect the rights of property owners. Discourage intensive recreational uses and construction of impervious surfaces in sensitive open spaces. P-3O.04 Preserve wooded areas, vegetation, and individual trees in the urban landscape, as they serve a functional purpose in climate, noise, light, habitat, and pollution control. Chapter 3 - Land Use Element 3•11 Goal G-3P To encourage the development of parks and recreational opportunities for all residents of the City and to increase access to natural areas in a manner that minimizes adverse impacts, and achieves the desired urban design of the City. Policies P-3P.01 Ensure that development and planning of parks and recreational facilities is consistent with the Capital Facilities Element. P-3P.02 Distribute public parks and recreational facilities equitably throughout the City to afford access to all residents. P-3P.03 Utilize land donated for public use to provide common open space, public buildings, parks, and recreational opportunities, while incorporating LID techniques and BMPs in all projects where feasible. P-3P.04 Preserve and maintain unique or major physical features contained within the boundaries of City parks and recreational areas for access and enjoyment by residents of the community. P-3P.05 Adapt parks and recreation facilities to reflect the risks of climate change including sea level rise, extreme heat, extreme precipitation, and drought. Prioritize actions based on the critical nature of the facility. P-3P.06 Consider the relationship of parks and recreation facilities to emergency management and human health such as facilities used as community hubs. Consider business continuity and economic development, such as the wharf, beaches, and trails. P-3P.07 Cooperate with the County and other jurisdictions in planning, funding, constructing, and managing multi-purpose recreation and transportation trails which link together various areas of the City, the Port Angeles Urban Growth Area (PAUGA), and other areas of the County and region. Adapt trail designs, materials, and locations to reflect the risks of sea level rise. Goal G-3Q To create open space within the urban landscape, retain natural landscapes, preserve fish and wildlife habitat, and to provide natural corridors connecting wildlife habitats. Policy P-3Q.01 Preserve unique or major physical features such as marine shorelines, bluffs, ravines, streams, wetlands, wildlife habitat and other environmentally sensitive areas deemed of significant importance to the community and those vulnerable to climate change impacts as designated open space. Goal G-3R Protect and preserve ecosystems by increasing resilience to climate hazards such as heat, flooding, drought, pest outbreaks, sea level rise, and reduced snowpack that pose a risk to forest productivity, fish and wildlife habitats, and water quality. Policies P-3R.01 Establish and implement an urban tree management program intended to retain and/or restore the overall tree canopy in the city by using plant materials as a unifying element and tool to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public. P-3R.02 Utilize the environmental services provided by trees to mitigate the negative effects of impervious surfaces and vehicular traffic such as increased temperatures, airborne particulates, carbon dioxide, noise, and stormwater runoff. ■ 3•12 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Transportation 4 The intent of the Transportation Element is to define in a comprehensive manner how vehicular traffic and non-motorized modes of travel are to be routed from one portion of the community to another in the most efficient, economical, and compatible manner. The City's Circulation Plan in accordance with the Statewide National Functional Classification System identifies the City's principal arterial streets, minor arterial streets, and collectors with the remaining streets classified as local streets (See Figure A•14). The City’s Circulation Plan acknowledges that such a regional system serves many functions. It is a means of intercity commuting, a way to promote economic development, a means to promote a healthy lifestyle, and a way to provide future utility right-of- way. Together, the goal and policy framework presented in this element (and the analysis in Appendix D) provides direction in realizing the City's long-range vision regarding transportation - including support for a strong economy; creating walkable, people- friendly environments; and improving the health and quality of life for all residents of Port Angeles. Actions related to Transportation are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. ■ Transportation Goals & Policies Goal G-4A To develop a coordinated, multimodal transportation system, which serves all areas of the city and all types of users in a safe, accessible, economical, and efficient manner. Policies P-4A.01 The safety of non-motorized modes of transportation shall be a primary consideration in the circulation system. P-4A.02 Planning for transportation services and facilities (including public streets, bikeways, pedestrian walkways, public and private air, marine and land transit services and facilities) shall be performed consistent with the goals and policies of the Capital Facilities Element. P-4A.03 Road improvements should provide for alternate modes of transportation, and new roads should be evaluated for the ability to accommodate alternate modes of transportation. P-4A.04 Encourage development of low-carbon-impact transportation infrastructure. P-4A.05 Consider converting alleyways into attractive pedestrian zones for access to local businesses. Encourage alleyways for use as pedestrian zones. P-4A.06 Improve trails, sidewalks, streets, and public facilities to encourage walkability and non-motorized transportation. P-4A.07 Support Clallam Transit in expanding public transit infrastructure and services to ensure access to buses is available at all times and decrease the need for travel in single-occupancy vehicles. This includes: • Develop strategies that promote transit equity and community safety by considering the most vulnerable, then design and implement transit to support pedestrians, bicycles, mass transit, and individual cars, in that order. • Increase use of the park and ride system. • Implement fare-free transit within Port Angeles city limits. • Explore the feasibility of adding a high-speed electric or hybrid passenger ferry to Seattle. • Reference Clallam Transit’s Comprehensive Operational Analysis for implementation. Goal G-4B To improve circulation patterns across and within the community, and to achieve the desired urban design of the City. Policies P-4B.01 Consider traffic flow modifications such as signalization, signing, parking restrictions, channelization, and one-way couplets before physical alterations are made to existing streets. Goals & Policies P-4B.02 Divert cross-town truck traffic around the downtown area. P-4B.03 Facilitate the planning processes necessary for the development of an alternate local cross-town route with improvements that provide full access at US 101 and SR 117 (the Tumwater Truck Route). P-4B.04 Strengthen the city’s development regulations as necessary to preserve the right-of-way within an identified US 101 corridor P-4B.05 Advocate a second crossing over White's Creek. 4•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan P-4B.06 Design and construct new arterial streets, local access streets, and alleys to conform to the most current editions of the Statewide National Functional Classification System for Federal Aid Systems, WSDOT, and Transportation Improvement Board minimum design standards and standards as adopted by the City. Permeable pavement is preferred for local access streets and alleys where feasible. P-4B.07 Publicly dedicate street rights-of-way associated with the subdivision processing advance of the time of individual lot development in accordance with the Comprehensive Plan's Circulation Plan Map. P-4B.08 Locate principal, minor, and collector arterial streets on the edge of district boundaries wherever possible. P-4B.09 Ensure off-street parking should be sufficient and accessible within business and residential areas so the traffic flow of the street is not impaired. P-4B.10 Police and fire protection should be a key factor in residential subdivision street designs and circulation patterns. P-4B.11 Coordinate the development of the City's comprehensive service and facilities plan for streets, bikeways, pedestrian walkways, and the overall transportation system and regional transportation plans. P-4B.12 Work with other jurisdictions to identify and protect a right-of-way for a second developed right of way P-4B.13 Work with public and private transportation providers to provide greater access and opportunities to residents, including Sunday and holiday service. P-4B.14 Consider potential environmental consequences, such as greenhouse- gas emissions and carbon footprints, when encouraging new commercial developments and businesses. Goal G-4C To provide a system of walking trails and bicycle paths to complement and coordinate with the existing street system and provide recreational opportunities and physical activity while reducing the dependence on traditional automobile transportation. Policy P-4C.01 Maximize bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure and other active- transportation systems and improve sidewalk connectivity. Goal G-4D To increase the resilience of transportation structures to floods, extreme precipitation events, sea level rise, and reduced snowpack. Policies P-4D.01 Protect and adapt critical facilities and their operations to reflect risks of sea level rise such as at the Black Ball Ferry Terminal and other essential public facilities. Goals & Policies P-4D.02 Coordinate with regional partners to assess roads for flooding and landslide hazards in conjunction with WSDOT. Goal G-4E Increase the access to EV charging infrastructure to support the transition to EV. Policy P-4E.01 Promote and incentivize EV infrastructure in the private and public sectors. Goal G-4F Enhance emergency services to address response to extreme heat, drought, flooding, sea level rise, and wildfire. Policy P-4F.01 Improve current emergency evacuation routes. P-4F.02 Site new emergency evacuation routes to increase route redundancy in case the primary emergency evacuation route is affected by the emergency. ■ Chapter 4 - Transportation Element 4•3 (This page intentionally left blank) Utilities & Public Services The Utilities and Public Services Element identifies and addresses the various services that make a community a safe and desirable place to live. It also establishes policies that define which services are the responsibility of the City to provide and which should be provided by the community as a whole. Taken together, the policy framework presented in this element will help Port Angeles realize many of its long-range goals - including sustaining the natural environment; supporting economic growth and opportunity; and helping keep services efficient and cost-effective. Actions related to Utilities and Public Services are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. 5 ■ Utilities Goals & Policies Goal G-5A To provide or allow the opportunity for services and facilities which enhance the quality of life for Port Angeles citizens of all ages, characteristics, needs, and interests and to achieve the desired urban design of the City. Policies P-5A.01 Include provisions in public facilities for citizens with disabilities and construct them according to accepted standards. P-5A.02 Locate social services providing home care in residential neighborhoods in a manner that maintains the character of the immediate neighborhood. P-5A.03 Comprehensive service and facility plans should be consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan and should be implemented through applicable land use approvals and construction permits. P-5A.04 Encourage age-appropriate services for all-age groups. P-5A.05 Incorporate tribal issues and interests into city projects. Goal G-5B To support services and facilities through different levels of participation in cooperation with other public or private agencies. Policies P-5B.01 The City should be the "primary responsible agency" and should take the lead in cooperation with other governmental entities to provide: ■ Utility and emergency services (water, sewer, electrical, stormwater, police, fire and emergency medical response services) ■ Transportation infrastructure, including trails and sidewalks and ■ Parks and recreation P-5B.02 The City should participate as a "financial partner" to support essential programs and services including: ■ Youth recreation programs and facilities ■ Library facilities ■ Senior programs ■ Low and moderate income housing programs ■ Facilities for senior programs ■ Utility assistance for low-income households, and 5•3 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies ■ Social and public health services. P-5B.03 As a "supporter," the City should promote and cooperate in providing programs and services including: ■ Library programs such as information and assistance ■ Affordable housing information and referral ■ Economic and business development services ■ Tourism information and services ■ Schools and community learning ■ Fine arts ■ Community recreation ■ Public and private youth, family and senior services ■ Telecommunications and ■ Crime prevention programs ■ Health Care programs. P-5B.04 Develop and use public facilities cooperatively, in the promotion of social and community services. Goal G-5C To provide safe, clean, usable, and attractive public facilities which enhance the cultural, educational, economic, recreational, and environmental attributes of the City. Policies P-5C.01 Support industrial diversification by the development of urban services. P-5C.02 Major parks and large open spaces should provide for a variety of outdoor activities and be located to take advantage of natural processes (such as wetlands and tidal actions) and unusual landscape features (such as cliffs and bluffs), and to integrate stormwater facilities into the natural landscape where feasible (such as LID techniques and BMPs and stormwater treatment wetlands). P-5C.03 Provide a variety of settings and activities suitable to people of all ages, characteristics, and interests. P-5C.04 Encourage more active involvement and communication between education (professional and student), business, community, art and cultural communities to help integrate key people into the startup community. P-5C.05 Work in partnership with the community as stewards of the area’s unique environment and quality of life. Chapter 5 - Utilities & Public Services Element 5•4 Goals & Policies Goal G-5D To provide utility services in an efficient and cost-effective manner. Policies P-5D.01 Design urban services for the maximum planned density and/or land use intensity of a given area as designated on the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map. P-5D.02 Provide urban services only in areas that are logical extensions of areas, which are currently served by such services or needed to implement a specific goal or policy of the Comprehensive Plan. P-5D.03 Promote and encourage energy conservation, renewable energy, distributed energy generation, improved distribution efficiencies, and recycling efforts throughout the community. P-5D.04 Promote the joint use of transportation rights-of-way and utility corridors for all forms of transportation, including non-motorized. P-5D.05 Promote coordination, consistency, and concurrency at all stages of utility development in the Port Angeles Urban Growth Area. P-5D.06 Planning for utility services should be consistent with the goals and policies of the Capital Facilities Element. P-5D.07 Serve new development with sanitary sewers. P-5D.08 Consider the policies adopted in the Water Resources Inventory Area 18 Watershed Management Plan, including the provision of water supply to the urban areas in and between the Elwha River and Morse Creek drainage basins. P-5D.09 Provide infrastructure to all industrial lands to encourage development. P-5D.10 Encourage the use of renewable energy in both the private and public sectors, providing all reasonable support and advocacy at the State level for regulations and incentives that encourage such installations. Goal G-5E To build resilience and capacity to prepare for increased energy demand by enhancing energy and resource efficiency and diversifying the grid. Policies P-5E.01 Provide incentives and education for low-income residents to participate in renewable energy access and energy efficient retrofits. P-5E.02 Incentivize active and passive solar building design and leverage existing Bonneville Power Administration programs (e.g., energy efficiency incentives) and state and federal funding sources and policy. Goal G-5F Enhance emergency services to address response to extreme heat, drought, flooding, sea level rise, and wildfire. Policies P-5F.01 Identify safe evacuation routes for earthquakes, tsunamis, high-risk debris flow, and landslide areas. P-5F.02 Improve knowledge of earthquake, tsunami, and landslide hazard areas and understanding of vulnerability and risk to life and property in hazard-prone areas. P-5F.03 Evaluate current earthquake, tsunami, and landslide warning systems to ensure effectiveness and efficiency and increase coordination between local jurisdictions. P-5F.04 Strengthen response to earthquakes, tsunamis, and landslides by incident management teams to increase resilience. P-5F.05 Create a Community Wildfire Preparedness Plan. P-5F.06 Provide education and outreach to residents to ensure their personal preparedness in the event of a wildfire. P-5F.07 Enhance Emergency Services to increase efficiency of wildfire response and recovery activities. P-5F.08 Complete a new wildfire assessment that accounts for Wildland Urban Interface areas. P-5F.09 Develop and disseminate maps relating to the fire hazard to help educate and assist builders and homeowners engaged in wildfire mitigation activities, and to help guide emergency services during response. P-5F.10 Improve brush clean-up operations to decrease wildfire fuel. P-5F.11 Improve current emergency evacuation routes. Site new emergency evacuation routes to increase route redundancy in case the primary emergency evacuation route is affected by the emergency. Goal G-5G Prepare conservation strategies and protect water quality to increase resilience to drought, sea level rise, and reduced snowpack. Policies P-5G.01 Enhance water supply monitoring to increase resilience during drought periods. P-5G.02 Reduce water consumption through education and incentive programs. For example: • Create a smart grid water use system and share data with consumers to increase conservation. • Promote and incentivize smart irrigation technologies for golf courses and parks. • Update water rates to discourage watering lawns. • Provide incentives for efficient food cultivation. P-5G.03 Maintain and enhance the quality of water resources through the regulation of clearing, grading, dumping, discharging, and draining and the provision of flood and erosion control measures and regulations to protect wetlands and other environmentally sensitive areas. Use adaptive management practices and best available climate science and projections to inform these efforts. ■ 5•5 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Housing 6 The City recognizes the extreme importance of available clean, safe, and affordable housing in the community. The results of the 2006 study and public input provided during the 2016 update process, and 2019 Housing Action Plan influenced the development of the following goals, policies and objectives, which strive to achieve Port Angeles' long-range vision for housing. Beyond improving the quality, affordability, attainability, and availability of housing for residents, this element is seen to support community objectives related to economic development, downtown growth, neighborhood character, and service-efficient, more cost-effective development patterns. The Actions related to Housing are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. ■ Housing Goals & Policies Goal G-6A To improve the variety, quality, availability, and attainability of housing opportunities in the City of Port Angeles. Policies P-6A.01 Expand the residential land use options in the Zoning Code by classifying residential zones by allowed density rather than by housing types. P-6A.02 Allow residential uses in all non-industrial zones. In situations where a limited work/live environment is found to be compatible with an underlying industrial zoning, limited work/live environments may be deemed suitable when the living space is subordinate in nature to the industrial use component and the integrity and intent of the industrial zone is maintained. P-6A.03 Encourage the retention and development of safe and attractive mobile home parks. P-6A.04 Plan for sufficient urban services to support future housing in a variety of allowable densities. P-6A.05 Allow accessory residential units in single family residential zones. P-6A.06 Promote acceptance of low and moderate income housing. P-6A.07 Consider the effect of impact fees on the affordability of housing prior to establishing such impact fees. P-6A.08 In accordance with RCW 59.18.440 and .450, require State and Federal publicly assisted housing under current contracts who demolish, substantially rehabilitate, change the use of residential property, or remove use restrictions developments to provide relocation assistance to those tenants displaced as provided for in sections 49 and 50 of the Growth Management Act. P-6A.09 Work with the County to increase densities in some areas of the sparsely developed southwestern UGA along Lauridsen Boulevard from low density to medium density, consistent with the recently developed airport safety zones and FAA use recommendations. P-6A.10 Investigate the appropriate siting of additional land to be designated medium density and high density. P-6A.11 Provide an appropriate balance between attainable market-rate housing and affordable housing and ensure that affordable housing is provided in a way that contributes to the physical appearance and economic and social health of the neighborhoods and the City. P-6A.12 Encourage the use of Green Building techniques for new developments and support Green Built certification for new developments. 6•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-6A.13 Encourage the use of Low Impact Development stormwater management techniques (such as vegetated roofs, permeable pavement, rainwater harvesting, and bio- retention) for all new developments. P-6A.14 Allow for mixed-use opportunities in neighborhoods, including commercial development and mix of housing densities. P-6A.15 Identify opportunities for housing revitalization in targeted areas including the downtown core. P-6A.16 Promote and increase the number of downtown residential living units. P-6A.17 Develop strategies to combat homelessness and housing insecurity amongst residents. P-6A.18 Develop and implement tools to support a range of housing types including affordable housing options. Goal G-6B To participate with Clallam County and other entities in programs to increase the availability and affordability of public assisted housing and rental units as well as other affordable housing opportunities. Policies P-6B.01 Participate in a county-wide housing task force comprised of representatives from government, financial institutions, business, construction, real estate, non-profit housing entities, and other citizens interested in housing issues. A major goal of the task force should be coordinating efforts to provide affordable housing, encouraging rapid review of low- and moderate-income housing projects throughout the County, and promoting public education and awareness regarding the need for and nature of affordable housing. P-6B.02 Cooperate with the county-wide housing task force and other agencies in assembling packages of publicly owned land, which could be used for low- and moderate-income housing and for shelter or transitional housing. P-6B.03 Cooperate with the County to promote innovative housing techniques and explore creative regulatory programs for the purpose of creating and preserving existing affordable housing opportunities. P-6B.04 P-6B.04 Invite the Peninsula Housing Authority to participate in a variety of affordable housing opportunities and seek representation on the Peninsula Housing Authority and non-profit housing organizations. P-6B.05 Provide adequate low- and moderate-income housing opportunities within the Port Angeles Planning Area. P-6B.06 Support affordable housing by developing utility cost savings programs and the provision of transitional and temporary housing for the homeless and/or displaced families. Chapter 6 - Housing Element 6•3 Goals & Policies P-6B.07 Designate specific medium and high-density zones where increased building height limitations could be increased. Goal G-6C To use the 2019 Housing Action Plan as a guide and implementation tool for future City actions in support of providing available State supported financing options, municipal code revisions that promote innovative housing products and designs, incentive zoning, and renovation/rehabilitation of existing of the City’s housing stock. Policies P-6C.01 Encourage innovative housing development based on Port Angeles’ forecasted demographic changes. P-6C.02 Designate timelines for planning actions that adequately address housing needs within the City and unincorporated UGA. P-6C.03 Promote housing renovation and rehabilitation. P-6C.04 Incentivize the provision of non-cash density offsets to assist in the development of affordable housing options. P-6C.05 Encourage the partnership and coordination of the City of Port Angeles, Clallam County, Peninsula Housing Authority, Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe, other local public agencies, and North Peninsula Builders Association to continue focusing on solving issues with the developed and provision of attainable housing on the North Olympic Peninsula. P-6C.06 Encourage the issuance of annual and periodic updates to the Housing Action Plan. P-6C.07 Develop measurable standards to assess the progress and implementation of the core recommendations of the Housing Action Plan. P-6C.08 Encourage high-density infill, affordable housing, and mixed-use development to increase the housing stock and increase walkability. P-6C.09 Decrease or remove parking minimums to allow higher occupancy land use. ■ 6•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Conservation 7 The Conservation Element establishes the importance of quality of life to the people of Port Angeles. A clean, healthy, and diverse natural environment along with a variety of historical and cultural amenities are critical elements of a high quality community. As with other elements, this chapter provides a goal, policy and action framework to support Port Angeles' long-range vision related to conservation. This includes efforts to optimize the city's relationship with its natural historic, and cultural setting by protecting and enhancing the environment and identifying and conserving sire and entities of historic or cultural significance. Actions related to conservation goals and policies are included in Chapter 11, Implementation. ■ Conservation Goals & Policies Goal G-7A To promote sustainable development and land use that is compatible with the overall natural environment, historical, archaeological, and cultural amenities. Policies P-7A.01 Require all development, including the location and design of all structures and open space areas, to be compatible with the unique physical features and natural amenities of the land and complement the environment in which it is placed, while recognizing the rights of private ownership. P-7A.02 Promote compatibility between the land and its use by regulating the intensity of the land use. P-7A.03 Adopt development criteria, which promote the use of innovative design techniques to provide for the use of the land in a manner compatible with any unique physical features or valuable natural, historical, and/or cultural amenities. P-7A.04 Building density should decrease as natural constraints increase. P-7A.05 Establish minimum standards for development of properties, which contain or adjoin critical areas for the purpose of protecting such areas and enhancing their natural functions. P-7A.06 Regulate site design, preparation, and development to avoid or minimize damage to wetlands and other environmentally sensitive areas. P-7A.07 Use regionally consistent requirements for industrial and commercial sewer discharge pretreatment and require new indirect dischargers to locate where appropriate sewer service can be made available. P-7A.08 Designate open space areas to preserve major or unique physical features, to serve as natural greenbelts and wildlife corridors, and to establish an urban edge to the PAUGA. P-7A.09 Coordinate its environmental regulations with County, State, and Federal regulations to simplify the permitting process and to reduce associated costs to the land user. P-7A.10 Review all new development for impacts on climate change and adaptation to sea level rise. P-7A.11 Implement site-specific requirements for individual development proposals to mitigate any negative impacts created by the development, particularly to an area identified as an environmentally sensitive area. 7•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Goal G-7B To protect and enhance the area's unique physical features, its natural, historical, archaeological, and cultural amenities, and the overall environment. Policies P-7B.01 Maintain and preserve the City’s unique physical features and natural amenities, such as creeks, streams, lakes, ponds, wetlands, ravines, bluffs, shorelines, and fish and wildlife habitats. P-7B.02 Promote and highlight Port Angeles' plentiful natural beauty, amenities and cultural history. P-7B.03 Recognizing the functions and values of wetlands, the City should strive to achieve no net loss of wetlands. P-7B.04 Preserve uniquely featured lands, which still exist in their natural states and which are notable for their aesthetic, scenic, historic, or ecological features. Prohibit any private or public development, which would destroy such qualities, or would subject features to damage from climatic change, while recognizing the rights of private ownership. P-7B.05 Enhance and preserve the quality of the City’s air and water as two of its unique physical features. P-7B.06 Protect air and water quality by minimizing pollution from new and existing sources including climatic change impacts. P-7B.07 Develop and implement a plan to improve water quality, which includes measures to reduce and minimize stormwater pollutants and combined sewer overflow pollutant discharges. P-7B.08 Maintain and enhance the quality of water resources through the regulation of clearing, grading, dumping, discharging, and draining and the provision of flood and erosion control measures and regulations to protect wetlands and other environmentally sensitive areas. P-7B.09 Protect water quality and prevent erosion through the retention of existing vegetation. P-7B.10 Encourage identification, preservation, and restoration of sites and structures that have historical or cultural significance. P-7B.11 Give precedence to long-term environmental impacts and benefits over short-term environmental impacts and benefits. P-7B.12 Promote and utilize environment enhancing conservation practices. Those practices may include waste reduction, use of energy efficient and conserving materials, and energy conservation techniques and should also encourage the development and use of alternative forms of energy and transportation. Chapter 7 - Conservation Element 7•3 Goals & Policies P-7B.13 Reference the most recently adopted Washington State Citations of Recommended Sources of Best Available Science for Designating and Protecting Critical Areas and other research identified as more locally appropriate and applicable when available as Best Available Science in the Critical Areas Ordinance. P-7B.14 Avoid adverse impacts to archaeological sites by following and requiring best management practices for archaeological preservation. P-7B.15 Publicly recognize the many values provided by trees in an urban setting and identify opportunities to plant trees. P-7B.16 Establish and implement an urban tree management program intended to retain and/or restore the overall tree canopy in the city by using plant materials as a unifying element and tool to protect the health, safety and welfare of the public, using the environmental services provided by trees to mitigate the negative effects of impervious surfaces and vehicular traffic such as increased temperatures, airborne particulates, carbon dioxide, nose, and stormwater runoff. P-7B.17 Plant trees along residential streets, in parking lots, and in other areas as opportunities arise. Trees should be retained whenever possible and maintained using Best Management Practices as appropriate for each tree type. P-7B.18 Seek strategies and technologies which reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by city facilities and operations. P-7B.19 Promote the use of alternative energy, energy conservation technology, and smart energy grid. Goal G-7C To promote community awareness and education of the importance and responsible use of our environmental, historical, and cultural amenities, with a focus on minimally impacting these resources. Policies P-7C.01 Inform the public concerning the long-term benefits of protecting and improving the quality of the region's air, land, and water. P-7C.02 Encourage the development and implementation of environmental, historical, and cultural awareness programs which focus on local and regional issues, including climate change impacts and preparedness. 7•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Goal G-7D To preserve and enhance the City's shoreline, its natural vegetation and wildlife and to mitigate for present and planned impacts in a manner consistent with the State Shoreline Management Act and the City's Shoreline Master Program. Policies P-7D.01 Preserve shoreline areas for future generations by restricting or prohibiting development that would interfere with the shoreline ecology or irretrievably damage shoreline resources. P-7D.02 Maintain and restore riparian vegetation in shoreline areas and on tributary streams, which affect shoreline resources wherever possible. P-7D.03 Employ techniques to rehabilitate degraded shorelines for the purpose of shoreline stabilization and habitat enhancement wherever possible. P-7D.04 Preserve and protect aquatic habitats including shellfish habitat, and important marine vegetation by periodically evaluating and adapting fish and wildlife habitat policies and codes to address and mitigate climate risks. P-7D.05 Development patterns and densities on lands adjacent to shorelines should be compatible with shoreline uses and resources and reinforce the policies of the Shoreline Management Act and the City's Shoreline Master Program. P-7D.06 Utilize common utility corridors for urban service facilities located in shoreline areas. P-7D.07 Designate an adequate shoreline area for water-oriented commercial and industrial development based on the Land Use Element. P-7D.08 Locate shoreline uses and activities to avoid environmentally sensitive and ecologically valuable areas and to insure the preservation and protection of shoreline natural areas and resources. P-7D.09 Locate utility facilities and rights-of-way outside of the shoreline area wherever possible, and if unavoidable, protect shoreline ecology and resources. Goal G-7E Preserve culturally important resources and practices that are at risk to climate impacts such as protecting salmon populations from flooding. Protect and restore cultural and historical sites from coastal flooding and bluff erosion due to sea level rise. Policies P-7E.01 Coordinate with Tribal partners to implement regional climate resilience policies that protect culturally significant resources, land, and artifacts. P-7E.02 Protect, enhance, and restore ecosystems in order to meet Tribal treaty rights and conserve culturally important consumptive and non-consumptive resources including foods, medicinal plants, and materials that could be adversely impacted by climate change. Goals & Policies Goals & Policies Goal G-7F Plan for and respond to extreme heat hazards on human health such as vector-borne illnesses, increased pollution, and increased heat-related illnesses, deaths, and hospitalizations. Policies P-7F.01 Consider habitat reduction and population control for arthropod disease vectors (e.g., mosquitos, ticks) and zoonotic disease reservoirs (i.e., rodents) using integrated pest-management methods. P-7F.02 Develop and implement a wildfire smoke resilience strategy in partnership with local residents, emergency management officials, regional clean air agency officials, and other stakeholders. P-7F.03 Protect air and water quality by minimizing pollution from new and existing sources and those exacerbated by climate change drivers like extreme heat, flooding, and sea level rise. Goal G-7G Protect and preserve ecosystems by increasing resilience to climate hazards such as heat, flooding, drought, pest outbreaks, sea level rise, and reduced snowpack that pose a risk to forest productivity, fish and wildlife habitats, and water quality. Policy P-7G.01 Develop an identification and monitoring program for urban trees to analyze risks or impacts of pests and disease, factoring in climate impacts. ■ Chapter 7 - Conservation Element 7•5 Goals & Policies (This page intentionally left blank) Capital Facilities 8 The Capital Facilities Element consists of two parts. The first part is the listing of goals and policies regarding the City's provision of urban services and its planning of capital improvements. The second part is the Annual Capital Facilities Plan which is adopted separately from the Comprehensive Plan but is included as part of the plan as an attachment. The Comprehensive Plan defines urban services in its definition section, which includes a listing of the following services and facilities, which should be available in an urban environment: ■ Surface transportation facilities ■ Water facilities ■ Sewer facilities ■ Stormwater facilities ■ Solid waste facilities ■ Parks and recreational facilities ■ Emergency services (police, fire and medical response) Public Facilities within the City of Port Angeles managed by outside agencies: ■ Public schools facilities ■ Regional facilities (libraries, corrections, and mass transit). The following goals and policies provide guidance on how these services and facilities should be provided. This includes the establishment of minimum levels of service standards for each service. The policies also call for the development of individual comprehensive service and facility plans which take an in-depth look at the current status of each service and the projected future demand for each service and which include a financial feasibility analysis on the costs of providing each service. The Capital Facilities Plan is a six-year plan, which establishes how, where, and when the City will develop the facilities necessary to provide its various services. 8•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan ■ Capital Facilities Goals & Policies Goal G-8A To provide and maintain safe and financially feasible urban services and capital facilities at or above stated levels of service to all City residents and the general public. Policies P-8A.01 The Comprehensive Plan should establish general level of service standards for each urban utility and service. Such standards should be used to determine the impacts of development. P-8A.02 Develop individual comprehensive service and facility plans for the following capital facilities and/or services: ■ Transportation, including streets, and non-motorized (bikeways and pedestrian walkways), ■ Water system, ■ Sanitary sewer system, ■ Electrical system, ■ Parks and recreation services, and ■ Emergency services (police, fire, and medical response). P-8A.03 Each comprehensive service and facility plan should be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, the County-Wide Planning Policy, and the State Growth Management Act. P-8A.04 At a minimum, ensure the continuation of established level of service standards for all urban utilities and services to the extent and in the manner provided herein. P-8A.05 Cooperate with the appropriate private and/or public agencies to develop individual comprehensive service and facility plans for each of the following utilities and/or services: ■ Telecommunications, ■ Schools, ■ Mass transportation, and ■ Solid waste collection and disposal. P-8A.06 Create and maintain comprehensive service and facility plans consistent with the general level of service standards established in the Comprehensive Plan and establish detailed level of service standards which, at a minimum, meet all local, state, and federal health and safety requirements. Chapter 8 - Capital Facilities Element 8•3 Goals & Policies Establish desired level of service standards and should include an inventory of current facilities, measurements of current and future service capacities, the determination of future service and facility improvements necessary to serve the twenty-year vision of the Comprehensive Plan Land Use Map, and a financial feasibility analysis. P-8A.07 Create and maintain comprehensive service and facility plan for streets and non- motorized facilities (bikeways, trails, and pedestrian walkways) that include specific actions and requirements for bringing into compliance any street facilities that fall below the required level of service, including demand management strategies which encourage reduced reliance on single occupant vehicle trips and encourage use of alternate modes of transportation such as the bicycles, walkways, and transit riding with incentive programs for and from local businesses. Include a future US 101 corridor to meet long- term local and regional non-motorized transportation needs. P-8A.08 The City should require concurrency and standards be met at the time of new development for the following utilities and services: ■ Paved streets, curbs, and sidewalks ■ Water service, ■ Sanitary sewer service, ■ Electrical service ■ Solid waste collection, ■ Stormwater management, ■ Telecommunications services, and ■ Emergency services (police, fire and emergency medical response). P-8A.09 Require the following services and facilities within six years from the time of development: ■ Parks and recreation services and facilities, and ■ Transit system. P-8A.10 Adopt an annual Capital Facilities Plan consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and State Growth Management Act. The Capital Facilities Plan's financing schedule may be corrected, updated, or modified without being considered as an amendment to the Comprehensive Plan, following a public hearing before the City Council. P-8A.11 Adopt a Comprehensive Parks and Recreation Plan consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the Growth Management Act as an Element of the Comprehensive Plan. P-8A.12 Require sidewalks be included in all development and redevelopment proposals where sidewalks do not exist at the time of application for development. Permeable materials are preferred for sidewalk construction where feasible. 8•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-8A.13 Develop and implement an Urban Forestry Program to properly manage street trees, park trees, and forested environmentally sensitive areas located within the City. P-8A.14 Create a unified, coherent design element for signage, street lighting, traffic control devices, and similar structures to be used throughout the City and specifically in the downtown area as a method for improved way finding and place identification for visitors and residents alike. P-8A.15 Consider climatic change impacts and adaptation strategies in planning and designing capital facilities. P-8A.16 Development shall be served with adequate transit service as determined in the comprehensive service and facilities plan for transportation within six years from the time of development. P-8A.17 Deny any development that will not be served at or greater than a citywide level of service standard of 10 acres of parks per 1,000 population within six years from the time of development. P-8A.18 Deny any development that will not be served at or less than the following level of service standards at the time of development. ■ Police 600 persons per one officer ■ Fire Four-minute response time or residential sprinkler system installation P-8A.19 Deny any development that will not be served with solid waste collection service at or less than a city-wide level of service standard of 400 pick- up accounts per 1000 population within six years from the time of development. P-8A.20 Participate with the County in the development, maintenance, and implementation of a regional solid waste plan, which addresses collection, disposal, and recycling of solid waste. P-8A.21 Consider the cumulative effect of development on the City's need for adequate public service buildings. P-8A.22 Consider projected climatic change impacts and adaptation strategies to determine whether adequate services can be provided into the future, prior to approving any development. P-8A.23 Support public education and Peninsula College, including initiatives for rebuilding schools. P-8A.24 Consider level of service standards for development based on the School District's projected enrollment figures and residential growth as provided for in the Land Use Element of the Comprehensive Plan: ■ High School 125 square feet of permanent, appropriate educational space per student ■ Middle School 104 square feet of permanent, appropriate educational space per student ■ Elementary School 100 square feet of permanent, appropriate educational space per student Chapter 8 - Capital Facilities Element 8•5 Goals & Policies Goal City shall not approve any development that is not served with water service at or greater than the following level of service standards at the time of development G-8B To provide urban streets and utilities at minimum levels of service for all city residents and the general public. Policies P-8B.01 All arterial streets shall function at an average daily Level of Service (LOS) of D or better. P-8B.02 Development on all arterial streets and any other streets identified as school walking routes should include pedestrian sidewalks on both sides of the street. P-8B.03 The City shall not approve any development that is not served with water service at or greater than the following level of service standards at the time of development: ■ Single family units: 2 gallons per minute @ 30 psi (Fire - 1000 gallons per minute @ 20 psi for single family residential > 3,600 square feet) (Fire - 500 gallons per minute @ 20 psi for single family residential < 3,600 square feet) ■ Multi-family units: 1 gallon per minute @ 30 psi (fire per Uniform Fire Code) ■ Commercial: per Uniform Fire Code ■ Industrial: per Uniform Fire Code P-8B.04 The City shall not approve any development that is not served with sewer service at or greater than a level of service standard of 300 gallons per day per person at the time of development. P-8B.05 The City shall not approve any development that is not served with electrical service at or greater than a level of service standard of 118 volts (120 volt base) at the time of development. P-8B.06 The City shall not approve any development that increases a site's post- development stormwater run-off beyond that allowed by the Department of Ecology Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington as adopted by the City. 8•6 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-8B.07 The City should not approve any development that cannot be served with telecommunications service at or greater than the following level of service standards at the time of development: Telephone Residential 1 service per unit Commercial 1 service per business Industrial 1 service per business Cable Television Residential 1 service per unit Commercial 0 service per business Industrial 0 service per business Internet Residential 1 service per unit Commercial 0 service per business Industrial 0 service per business P-8B.08 Highways of Statewide Significance (HSS) should function at Level of Service (LOS) D or better, consistent with the Regional Transportation Plan (RTP). P-8B.09 Develop a Capital Facilities Plan list, with public input, for prioritizing pedestrian walkway needs. P-8B.10 Seek funding to increase the provision of sidewalks in already developed areas where sidewalks do not occur. Goal G-8C To participate with the County, State, and Federal governments as well as other public agencies to provide adequate regional public services such as schools, highways, tie-ins to regional communication networks, libraries, and correctional facilities. Policies P-8C.01 The City should cooperate with the County and the community's health care providers to ensure quality health care facilities within the City that serve the region as a whole. P-8C.02 The City should cooperate with the County in planning regional library facilities within the City. P-8C.03 The City should cooperate with the County in planning for adequate correctional facilities. Chapter 8 - Capital Facilities Element 8•7 Goals & Policies P-8C.04 Essential public facilities of a county-wide or statewide nature must meet existing state laws and regulations requiring specific siting and permit requirements consistent with the City's Comprehensive Plan. Goal G-8D To reduce the amount of impervious surface created by new developments and thereby reduce stormwater management costs and environmental impacts to the City and its natural resources, reduce development costs to private property owners, and provide safe and more attractive streets through traffic calming, safe pedestrian amenities, and improved street edge landscaping. Policies P-8D.01 Revise existing urban development standards in low density residential areas to include low impact development standards for street, pedestrian and non- motorized access, sewer, and fire suppression to more nearly reflect the needs of suburban densities and conditions in outlying undeveloped areas of the City and PAUGA. P-8D.02 The City should invest in Green Infrastructure, Low Impact Development (LID), and similar technologies to maintain and enhance environmental quality. P-8D.03 Encourage the use of Low Impact Development stormwater management techniques (such as vegetated roofs, permeable pavement, rainwater harvesting, and bioretention) for all new developments. Goal G-8E Prepare for the increased demand for solid waste and recycling collection and disposal. Policy P-8E.01 Participate with the County in the development, maintenance, and implementation of a regional solid waste plan, which addresses collection, disposal, and recycling of solid waste. Goal G-8F Enhance emergency services to address response to extreme heat, drought, flooding, sea level rise, and wildfire. Policies P-8F.01 Develop resilience hubs — community-serving facilities augmented to support residents. P-8F.02 Coordinate resource distribution and services before, during, and after a hazard event. P-8F.03 Identify safe evacuation routes for earthquakes, tsunamis, high-risk debris flow, and landslide areas. P-8F.04 Improve knowledge of earthquake, tsunami, and landslide hazard areas and understanding of vulnerability and risk to life and property in hazard-prone areas. P-8F.05 Evaluate current earthquake, tsunami, and landslide warning systems to ensure effectiveness and efficiency and increase coordination between local jurisdictions. P-8F.06 Strengthen response to earthquakes, tsunamis, and landslides by incident management teams to increase resilience. P-8F.07 Create a Community Wildfire Preparedness Plan. P-8F.08 Provide education and outreach to residents to ensure their personal preparedness in the event of a wildfire. P-8F.09 Enhance Emergency Services to increase efficiency of wildfire response and recovery activities. P-8F.10 Complete a new wildfire assessment that accounts for Wildland Urban Interface areas. P-8F.11 Develop and disseminate maps relating to the fire hazard to help educate and assist builders and homeowners engaged in wildfire mitigation activities, and to help guide emergency services during response. P-8F.12 Improve brush clean-up operations to decrease wildfire fuel. P-8F.13 Improve current emergency evacuation routes. Site new emergency evacuation routes to increase route redundancy in case the primary emergency evacuation route is affected by the emergency. Goal G-8G Increase municipal cleanup and refuse capacity to prepare for increased need following extreme precipitation events. Policy P-8G.01 Develop and implement a strategy to expedite the removal of waste (e.g., downed tree limbs and buildings blocking roads and streams) during and after a disaster incident to reduce the risks of subsequent fire, flood, injury, and disease vectors. Goal G-8H Reduce waste-related greenhouse gas emissions from wastewater and landfills. Policies P-8H.01 Evaluate wastewater facility to reduce greenhouse emissions and build resilience to climate impacts such as landslides. P-8H.02 Maximize the co-generation and on-site utilization of natural gas from anaerobic digesters and other methods of harnessing energy in wastewater treatment. This will reduce vulnerability to power and fuel shortages, as well as reduce emissions. P-8H.03 Reduce vulnerability of access routes to the treatment plant and consider identifying alternative routes should primary routes be compromised. Goal G-8I Prepare conservation strategies and protect water quality to increase resilience to drought, sea level rise, and reduced snowpack. Policies P-8I.01 Enhance water supply monitoring to increase resilience during drought periods. P-8I.02 Reduce water consumption through education and incentive programs. For example: • Create a smart grid water use system and share data with consumers to increase conservation. • Promote and incentivize smart irrigation technologies for golf courses and parks. • Update water rates to discourage watering lawns. • Provide incentives for efficient food cultivation. P-8I.03 Maintain and enhance the quality of water resources through the regulation of clearing, grading, dumping, discharging, and draining and the provision of flood and erosion control measures and regulations to protect wetlands and other environmentally sensitive areas. Use adaptive management practices and best available climate science and projections to inform these efforts. ■ 8•8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Economic Development The intent of the Economic Development Element is to guide decision-making and investments that diversify and strengthen the local economy. ■ Optimizing the city's relationship with its natural setting ■ Supporting safe, attractive and character-rich neighborhoods ■ Creating a more dynamic, successful downtown ■ Improving Port Angeles' standing as a regional hub for business and Port-related enterprises. ■ Recognizing and supporting the economic impact of the college, Homeland Security, and Department of Defense presence. 9 ■ Economic Development Goals & Policies Goal G-9A To create and maintain a balanced and stable local economy with full employment and emphasis on strengthening the community's traditional natural resource related industries as well as diversifying the overall economic base. Policies P-9A.01 Remain a major economic center on the North Olympic Peninsula, meeting regional and local needs. P-9A.02 Promote long-term economic stability by encouraging businesses and industries to invest in modernization and environmentally sound technology. P-9A.03 Promote the diversification of the community's economic base by encouraging the location, retention, and expansion of local small and medium sized businesses. P-9A.04 Promote the “traditional downtown feeling” of retail, dining, arts, culture, and entertainment-oriented activities that are attractive to both tourists and local residents. P-9A.05 Develop sufficient utilities, improve traffic circulation, and identify environmental constraints in the airport industrial area in cooperation with other governmental agencies. P-9A.06 Encourage training and educational opportunities, which strengthen and increase the variety of skills available in the work force. P-9A.07 Promote the motivation and availability of the community's work force as a major economic development strength. P-9A.08 Encourage inter-jurisdictional discussion and cooperation with other governmental agencies to foster the economic development of the region and provide opportunities for civic cooperation by coordinating and supporting local non-profits, associations, and community service organizations to support economic development. P-9A.09 Work with other community organizations in developing an effective business assistance program directed toward the commercial business owner. P-9A.10 Support continued development of a strong marine related industry in the Port Angeles Harbor. P-9A.11 Promote the sustainability of the existing art and culture industry encouraging community participation and involvement. Enhancement of the creative economy contributes to the overall health of the community. P-9A.12 Encourage businesses with low carbon footprints. 9•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-9A.13 Consider projected climatic change impacts and adaptation strategies when encouraging new businesses to establish in Port Angeles. P-9A.14 Develop and economy which provides opportunities for Port Angeles' vulnerable and at-risk community members. P-9A.15 Invest in training and education for local residents, by providing access to state-of-the-art technology and training opportunities. P-9A.16 Encourage and incentivize youth entrepreneurship as well as jobs and businesses that attract young families. P-9A.17 Attract and retain businesses and industries which create family wage jobs for local residents. P-9A.18 Prioritize the airport as major economic asset and identify specific incentives to attract commercial services. P-9A.19 Encourage the location and support for adequate venues for community meetings, shows, music art, hobby and user groups, and professional and business meetings and particularly supporting the location of low-cost places where people (especially young people) can congregate and talk, and ensure that these have up-to-date communication facilities. P-9A.20 Recognize art, architecture, music, and performance as important community resources and continue to encourage and support cultural activities. P-9A.21 Support decorating public spaces with more art from the community. P-9A.22 Encourage the design of public spaces that encourage people to interact. P-9A.23 Support the concept and encourage the establishment of Maker's Spaces. (See definition) Public spaces where people make things and collaborate on projects, spaces are usually equipped with tools, 3-D printers, computers, design software, art and craft tools and supplies. Goal G-9B To have a healthy local economy that co-exists with the community's high quality of life through the protection, enhancement, and use of the community's natural, historical, and cultural amenities. Policies P-9B.01 Promote the region's high-quality environment and available natural and cultural resources as factors in attracting and retaining business, industry, and individual enterprises. P-9B.02 Promote the community's quality public school system and its diversity of other educational opportunities as factors in attracting and retaining business and industry. Chapter 9 - Economic Development Element 9•3 Goals & Policies P-9B.03 Encourage the enhancement of the existing four-year community college through such means as the expansion of its technical curriculum and additional four-year degree opportunities. P-9B.04 Promote development of planned office, business, and industrial parks, while conserving unique physical features of the land and maintaining compatibility with other land uses in the surrounding area. P-9B.05 Encourage the availability of housing that meets the needs of the entire spectrum of the community's residents. P-9B.06 Recognize, preserve, and promote its historic and cultural properties as a measure of its quality of life. P-9B.07 Support landscaping and detailing of the streetscape at the City’s east and west entries. P-9B.08 Utilize the Climatic Change Preparedness Plan in attracting businesses, to demonstrate a proactive approach to climatic change in the area. P-9B.09 Encourage and pursue economic development with positive environmental consequences, including non-polluting industries eco-friendly business, and low carbon footprints. Goal G-9C To create and promote a strong tourism industry for Port Angeles, as well as to recognize and support existing and prospective tourism attractions. Policies P-9C.01 Support improved access to the Olympic National Park, particularly to Hurricane Ridge. P-9C.02 Work to enhance the public use of Ediz Hook. P-9C.03 Take a leading role in enhancing visitors' first impression of the community by maintaining and upgrading the City’s public facilities, green infrastructure, and strengthen the nuisance abatement program. P-9C.04 Support development of an electric vehicle (EV) charging station network and EV maintenance facilities around the Olympic Peninsula. P-9C.05 Support tourism and recreation activities which highlights Port Angeles' natural, cultural, and historical amenities. Goal G-9D To strengthen and enhance the restoration and reinvigoration of our downtown historic buildings, infrastructure improvements, and beautification projects. 9•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Policies P-9D.01 Consider best available science on sea level rise and recommended mitigation and adaptation strategies in the development of downtown. Goal G-9E Create and maintain economic growth by supporting a diverse and balanced local economy. Prepare for changes in recreation due to heat, wildfire, and reduced snowpack. Protect businesses, travel, and shipping routes with increased infrastructure resilience. Policies P-9E.01 Ensure that the jurisdiction's Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan responds to the impacts of climate change and identifies roles and responsibilities to ensure a sustainable economic recovery after a disaster. P-9E.02 Encourage businesses with low carbon footprints by providing fee reductions, permit facilitation, and/or implementing land use code changes, among other strategies. P-9E.03 Promote long-term economic stability by encouraging businesses and industries to invest in modernization and environmentally sound, green technology. P-9E.04 Assess climate migration impacts with forecasting every 5 years. Integrate those findings into the Comprehensive Plan, infrastructure plans, revenue and expense forecasting, and housing assessments. ■ Chapter 9 - Economic Development Element 9•5 Goals & Policies Goals & Policies (This page is intentionally left blank) 10•1 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Parks & Recreation The intent of the Park Element is to provide a guide for the development and management of City parks in Port Angeles. The goal and policy framework that follow provide direction in realizing Port Angeles' vision regarding parks and recreation - including: ■ Optimizing the city's relationship with its remarkable natural setting ■ Supporting a wide range of recreational opportunities available to all ■ Creating vibrant, well-valued neighborhoods with access to parks, trails and natural areas ■ Sustaining Port Angeles' rich arts and cultural heritage and overall sense of community. 10 ■ Parks & Recreation Goals & Policies Goal G-10A To acquire, develop, renovate and maintain a sustainable system of parks, recreational facilities, and open spaces to ensure that the contributions of natural resources and recreation to human well- being are maintained and recognized as a value. Policies P-10A.01 Provide Port Angeles with a diversity of open spaces, parks, and recreation facilities and programs appropriately distributed throughout the City. P-10A.02 Ensure that equality is achieved to the extent possible in the types and variety of facilities, quality of maintenance, and the range of recreation services provided. P-10A.03 Retain and reflect the natural beauty that attracts visitors, business, and residents to the area. P-10A.04 Forge effective partnerships and strengthen ties with other public, private, and non-profit providers including providing high quality recreational opportunities. P-10A.05 Identify waterfront improvements to increase marine transportation and recreation. P-10A.06 Identify appropriate locations for small (pocket) parks, community gardens and food forests throughout the community and integrate them into its Parks system. P-10A.07 The City should continue to provide or participate with private sponsors to provide high quality recreational opportunities. P-10A.08 Continue to participate as a partner in the extension of the Olympic Discovery Trail through the City to the western City limits. Goal G-10B To enhance the quality of life in the community by providing facilities, services, and programs that offer positive opportunities for building healthy, safe, and productive lives to the broadest segment of the population. Policies P-10B.01 Provide consistently high-quality recreational experiences to residents and visitors through a wide variety of park types and features. 10•3 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies P-10B.02 Strive for excellence through efficient, accurate, and skillful performance in every process, service and product delivered by the Parks and Recreation providers. P-10B.03 Keep citizens involved and informed about parks and recreation issues, services, and family friendly features and amenities. P-10B.04 Manage park facilities in a manner that will ensure public safety, identify family friendly features and amenities, and keep the parks free of misuse to the greatest extent possible and resulting in a sustainable and resilient park system. P-10B.05 Incorporate health and nutrition into parks and recreation programming. P-10B.06 Provide high quality services, emphasize the design of park areas to reduce long-term maintenance and operating costs, and implement improved technology to conserve limited resources such as water, power, and people. P-10B.07 Provide programs and opportunities that are sensitive to the needs of all of its citizens, including those with limited financial resources, disadvantaged youth, the elderly, the disabled, and those with other special needs. Goal G-10C To establish and protect a visual character of the community through open spaces, streetscapes, borrowed landscapes, and publicly-owned natural resource areas. Policies P-10C.01 Strive to protect and retain the natural beauty of the area. P-10C.02 Supplement and enhance the visual attractiveness of the city through the use of formal landscaping in street medians, city entryways, and along sidewalks, as well as the use of other public spaces, flower beds, and street trees. Emphasize use of planter strips with drought tolerant vegetation and bio-retention facilities. Goal G-10D To promote economic growth through recreational tourism and attract visitors and new business by enhancing the image of the community through beautification and recreation programs. Policies P-10D.01 To encourage efficient transportation systems, support the use of shuttle services during events to move participants between venues. Chapter 10 - Parks & Recreation Element 10•4 Goals & Policies Goal G-10E To provide a system of walking trails and bicycle paths to complement and coordinate with the existing street system and provide recreational opportunities and physical activity while reducing the dependence on traditional automobile transportation. Policies P-10E.01 The City should continue efforts to improve or provide access to Valley, Tumwater, Peabody, Ennis and White's Creeks through the development of an integrated trails system. Goal G-10F To encourage the development of parks and recreational opportunities for all residents of the City and to increase access to natural areas in a manner that minimizes adverse impacts and achieves the desired urban design of the City. Policies P-10F.01 Preserve and maintain unique or major physical features contained within the boundaries of City parks and recreational areas for access and enjoyment by residents of the community. P-10F.02 Adapt parks and recreation facilities to reflect the risks of climate change including sea level rise, extreme heat, extreme precipitation, and drought. Prioritize actions based on the critical nature of the facility. Consider the relationship of facilities to emergency management and human health such as facilities used as community hubs. Consider business continuity and economic development, such as the wharf, beaches, and trails. ■ 10•5 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Goals & Policies Implementation 11 The following pages (Table 11.01) list a series of actions supporting the goals and policies contained in this plan's elements, showcasing a range of undertakings identified to implement the community's long-range vision. These actions constitute a part of the corresponding elements. It is provided to help City staff and leadership track progress, coordinate and combine various actions where it makes sense to do so, and to help guide budgeting of work and improvements in a more realistic, strategic fashion. As with the rest of the plan, this table represents the input, expressed priorities and values of the community and its leadership. Each listing includes columns identifying the anticipated timing of that action, as well as those primary agencies likely to be involved. These columns in no way obligate the City or identified partners to act or participate according to the timeframes described - rather, the table offers a means for the community to see, at a glance, its stated objectives in context of an intended timeframe. A 2019 Comprehensive Plan amendment identified policies that were specific or action oriented enough to justify placement into Chapter 11 Table 11.01 as actions. These former policies have been placed under each associated element in this chapter and identified by a placeholder number XX. A future Comprehensive Plan Amendment or Update will include the full evaluation of each proposed action for language, intent, timeline, partners and given a formal number. (This page intentionally left blank) Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete Growth Management Act A-2.01 Periodically update the City’s comprehensive plan as required by Washington State's Growth Management Act (GMA). ■ ■ ■ • Ordinance Passed June 30, 2024 O A-2.02 Review and update the City’s Buildable Lands Inventory on a biannual basis, helping inform land use decision-making. ■ ■ ■ • Matrix Produced December 21, 2018 O A-2.03 Acquire no-protest annexation agreements for all utility connections occurring in the Port Angeles Urban Growth Area (PAUGA). ■ ■ ■ • • Number Agreements N/A O A-2.04 Recommend expansion of the southwestern Urban Growth Area (UGA) to include twelve parcels located in an area bounded on the north by US 101; on the east by Old Joe Road (the western City limits at that location); on the west by the existing UGA boundary, and on the south by a line parallel to Old Joe Road right-of- way extended west to the UGA boundary. Also to be included are parcels 063017230050 and 063018120210. ■ • • Parcel mapped within UGA December 31, 2019 O Land Use A-3.01 Review and revise City development regulations for consistency with each major update of the Comprehensive Plan. ■ ■ ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2024 O A-3.02 Continue to develop programs encouraging the use of downtown for community events, gatherings, displays, and public markets. ■ • PADA Farmers Market Number of New Events N/A O A-3.03 Research and develop a program for consideration addressing approaches to open space preservation, including: ■ Land banking ■ Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) ■ Purchase of Development Rights (PDR). ■ • North Olympic Land Trust Ordinance Passed December 31, 2020 N Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects City of Port Angeles | 1 Chapter 11 - Implementation 11.3 COPA CLC POPA LEKT Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-3.04 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines to provide for development of low-impact trails in designated open spaces, including permeable materials where feasible. ■ • Number of trail Miles Completed December 31, 2021 O A-3.05 (SP) Adjust zoning to protect the prime commercial corridor ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2017 C A-3.06 (SP) Rewrite sign code (less clutter, more character) ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2019 N A-3.07 (AIA) Consider adoption of an overlay district for downtown to respond to sign, design, and parking issues. ■ • Budget for Form Based Code December 31, 2018 N Transportation A-4.01 Design and develop the following segments of the Olympic Discovery Trail: ■ Marine Drive to 10th Street ■ City Pier along Railroad Avenue to Laurel Street ■ Other segments as funding and opportunity provide, coordinated with the City's park, street and trail systems. ■ ■ ■ • • • Peninsula Trails Coalition ■ 100% Design ■ Grant Obtained ■ Number of Miles Complete ■ May 31, 2019 ■ December 31, 2018 ■ December 31, 2021 O A-4.02 Identify funding and implementation strategies for the Valley Creek Loop Trail, connecting the Valley and Peabody Creek corridors with the Foothills Trail system. ■ • • Washington State Parks Grant Obtained December 21, 2020 N A-4.03 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, including direction for transportation facility improvements that: ■ Include including bike path development and maintenance, signage, and storage ■ Assess cost/benefits of bicycle-friendly infrastructure. ■ • Clallam Transit Biannual Review Complete December 31, 2018 O Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects COPA CLC POPA LEKT 11.4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-4.04 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, encouraging public streetscape improvements including: ■ Street trees ■ Art and creative community-oriented beautification efforts ■ Pedestrian and bicycle amenities ■ Sidewalks on both sides of streets. ■ • Biannual Review Complete December 31, 2020 O A-4.05 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, helping: ■ Promote joint access and maintenance of driveways ■ Balance the needs for traffic movement and access to properties immediately adjacent to secondary and primary arterials. ■ • Biannual Review Complete December 31, 2020 O A-4.06 Develop a "Complete Streets" program for Port Angeles, helping identified travelways accommodate all modes of transportation as appropriate for the needs and conditions of each neighborhood or district. ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2018 C A-4.07 Prepare a study evaluating options for easterly access across Whites and Ennis Creeks in the vicinity of Golf Course Road. ■ ■ • WSDOT Completed Report / Study December 31, 2020 N A-4.08 In coordination with the County, RTPO and state and federal agencies, study a future US 101 corridor alignment including evaluation of the Heart of the Hills Parkway and Coastal Corridor concepts. (Route along Lauridsen Boulevard east of Race Street will not be considered.) ■ • • WSDOT; Clallam Transit Completed Report / Study December 31, 2020 N A-4.09 Plan and integrate the following into the Capital Facilities Plan: ■ Multi-modal street improvements along Edgewood Drive (south side of the airport), Lauridsen Boulevard, Airport Road (west side of the airport), and along Milwaukee Drive to Lower Elwha Road. ■ • Program as a CFP Item December 31, 2018 N A-4.10 (SP) Review and assess progress per AIA Urban Design Study; consider proposals to transform First and Front Streets ■ • Status Report December 31, 2019 O Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects Chapter 11 - Implementation 11.5 COPA CLC POPA LEKT Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-4.11 (SP) Transportation Benefit District on ballot ■ • Ballot Measure August 31, 2017 C Housing A-6.01 Identify appropriate areas of the city for higher-density housing, converting low-density residential areas into medium and high-density designations. ■ • List / Map Areas for Upzone December 31, 2019 O A-6.02 Evaluate revisions to height limitations in all commercial, medium, and high-density zones, helping accommodate increased residential densities without impacting viewsheds. ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2020 O A-6.03 (SP) Align Municipal Code for high density development zones. ■ • Amending Ordinance Passed March 31, 2017 O A-6.04 (SP) Partner with the Port Angeles Downtown Association to promote 2nd Story and above residential occupancy downtown ■ • PADA List / Map Available March 31, 2018 C A – 6.05 (HAP) Pursue partnership for a demonstration project that will provide: • A catalytic mixed-use project with affordable units. • A demonstration project to create a mixed- use prototype for market rate and affordable units in the downtown, medical center, commercial and/or residential neighborhood zones. ■ ■ Resolution Passed/Project identified December 31, 2022 N A – 6.06 (HAP) Assist in the development of accessory residential units by: • Developing a design manual and prototypes for ARU’s • Allowing the R-7 zone to increase the size of ARU’s attached to primary dwelling units. • Partnering with local lenders to establish an ARDU low-cost loan program. ■ ■ Amending Ordinance/ Resolution Passed December 31, 2020 N Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects City of Port Angeles | 4 COPA CLC POPA LEKT 11.6 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A – 6.07 (HAP) Encourage mixed use development and affordable housing units by: • Allowing Multi-family zones to create mixed housing type developments with internal drives (via circulation plan) as an alternative to public rights-of-way. • Allow ground floor residential and convertible space in CA, CN and CSD zones. • Identify Commercially-zoned properties that have multi-family capabilities on site. • Amend zoning code to adjust setbacks, maximum site coverage allowances, and other restrictions that prevent the use of to expand the definition of allowable innovative, functional, and cost-effective housing products. • Amend zoning code to eliminate larger lot size requirement for duplexes and assess the value of incentive zoning allowance beyond existing overlay zones ■ Ordinance Passed/ Study Completed December 31, 2020 N A – 6.08 (HAP) Continue to use Housing Rehabilitation Fund to match grants, offer low-cost loans to allow homeowners meeting income guidelines to remain resident in their home, maintain the value of a home, or upgrade to increase its market value. ■ ■ ■ Number of grants provided Ongoing O A – 6.09 (HAP) Partner with Peninsula Housing Authority to identify and address barriers to affordable housing and funding opportunities for affordable housing projects. ■ Study completed December 31, 2019 C A – 6.10 (HAP) In conjunction with local lenders and housing agencies identify rehabilitation program requirements including the potential number of housing projects, deferred or limited equity program participants, and required number and skill of renovation contractors or agents. ■ Program Adopted and Funded December 31, 2020 N Conservation Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects Chapter 11 - Implementation 11.7 COPA CLC POPA LEKT Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-7.01 Review and update the City's Façade Improvement Program to encourage participation in streetscape beautification projects and enhancements along entryway corridors. ■ • Amending Ordinance Passed December 31, 2021 O A-7.02 Develop and maintain an archaeological database, allowing for review and monitoring of ground-disturbing activities. The database should include: ■ Known archaeological and historical sites ■ A predictive model prescribing areas of high, medium and low archaeological site potential ■ A waterfront archaeological overlay ■ WA DAHP Establish Budget Item for Geographic Information Systems (GIS) December 31, 2018 O A-7.03 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, including requirements for development to provide: ■ Dispersion, infiltration and/or retention facilities necessary to protect water quality and provide flood protection and flow control ■ LID techniques and BMPs where feasible ■ Permeable paving materials for all sidewalks where feasible. ■ • Amend Urban Services Standards and Guidelines January 31, 2018 C A-7.04 Identify and inventory “habitats of local importance” areas, helping ensure wildlife corridors are not severed. ■ • • WA DOE Produce GIS Layer / Map December 31, 2021 N A-7.05 Develop and maintain an inventory of wetland delineations completed as part of land use permitting. ■ • • Produce GIS Layer / Map December 31, 2019 O A-7.06 Develop and periodically update a stormwater management plan consistent with NPDES Phase II permit requirements. ■ ■ ■ • WA DOE Program Infrastructure in CFP December 31, 2018 O Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects COPA CLC POPA LEKT 11.8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-7.07 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, including measures to coordinate new development with the protection of: ■ Scenic resources ■ Environmentally sensitive areas. ■ • Pass Resolution / Policy Document December 31, 2021 N A-7.08 Develop and adopt regulations supporting the preservation of identified, historically- significant buildings and sites. ■ • • WA DAHP Ordinance Passed December 31, 2019 N A-7.09 Develop and adopt a tree management program including: ■ Tree density targets ■ Urban forest management procedures and guidelines. ■ • Pass Resolution / Policy Document December 31, 2022 N A-7.10 Update the City's Shoreline Master Program by 2024. ■ • Ordinance Passed June 30, 2020 O Capital Facilities A-8.01 Update the City's Capital Facilities Plan on an annual basis. ■ ■ ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2017 O A-8.02 Develop and implement a schedule for preparation and adoption of all City service and facilities plans, coordinated with the Comprehensive Plan. ■ • LOS Plan December 31, 2018 O A-8.03 Establish review procedures for capital facilities plan projects, ensuring projects address: ■ Endangered Species Act requirements ■ Climate change adaptability ■ PAUGA impacts ■ Established levels of service. ■ • • WA DOE Policy Document December 31, 2020 O A-8.04 (SP) Deliver Capital Facilities Plan for 2018-2023 ■ • Resolution Passed July 31, 2017 C A-8.05 (SP) Secure municipal and industrial water rights ■ • Settlement Agreement December 31, 2019 O A-8.06 (SP) Provide and publish year end reports for the Waterfront Improvement Plan Phase 3 Design ■ • Report Published December 31, 2019 O Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects Chapter 11 - Implementation 11.9 COPA CLC POPA LEKT Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-8.07 (SP) Provide and publish year end reports for the Race Street Corridor Project 30% design ■ • 30% Design Published December 31, 2019 O A-8.08 (SP) City Signage and Wayfinding Program - RFP and design adjustments ■ • RFP Released December 31, 2019 C A-8.09 (SP) Complete downtown, parks, and trail enhancements for Civic Field, Calisthenics Park, Georgiana Park ■ • Enhancements Complete December 31, 2017 C A-8.10 (SP) Complete downtown, parks, and trail enhancements for Hill Street Olympic Discovery Trail Project ■ • 30% Design December 31, 2021 O A-8.11 (SP) Complete downtown, parks, and trail enhancements for adding amenities downtown (e.g., tables and benches) ■ • Amenities Added December 31, 2019 O A-8.12 (SP) Complete downtown, parks, and trail enhancements for Bike routes: address funding, route maps, parking obstacles ■ • Analysis Complete December 31, 2019 O A-8.13 (AIA) East entrance monument ■ • Added to CFP December 31, 2018 N A-8.14 (AIA) Expand street art program ■ ■ • Ordinance Passed July 31, 2020 N A-8.15 (AIA) Replace light and signal poles in downtown with new structures at pedestrian scale ■ • Added to CFP July 31, 2018 C A-8.16 (AIA) Place overhead utilities underground ■ • Added to CFP July 31, 2020 O A-8.17 (AIA) Create public view points and overlooks along bluff above downtown ■ • Added to CFP July 31, 2020 O Economic Development A-9.01 Negotiate a vegetation easement with the Port of Port Angeles, providing long-term resolution to concerns regarding trees at Lincoln Park. ■ • • Execute Easement / Interlocal Agreement December 31, 2019 O A-9.02 Develop policy encouraging the creation of new tourism events, enhancing tourism during the limited value season. ■ • • • • PADA Pass Resolution December 31, 2017 C Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects COPA CLC POPA LEKT 11.10 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete A-9.03 Review and update the City's Urban Services Standards and Guidelines, including: ■ Street and parking lot tree plantings ■ Use of appropriate vegetation in planter strips and bio-retention facilities. ■ • Amend Urban Services Standards December 31, 2020 O A-9.04 The City will support the implementation of the Mount Angeles View Project including a new Boys and Girls Club, recognizing that the overall project results in affordable housing and child care for the local workforce. ■ ■ • • Number of Letter of Support December 31, 2018 C A-9.05 The City will continue to make improvements as part of the Waterfront Development Plan while providing support to abutting investments made by the Port Angeles Waterfront Center (Preforming Arts Center) and Feiro Marine Life Center. ■ ■ • Number of Letters of Support, Number of Permits Issued December 31, 2019 O A-9.06 The City will work with Clallam County to ensure enhancements to William Shore Memorial Pool continue to provide benefits to the Port Angeles community. ■ ■ • Number of Letters of Support, Number of Permits Issued December 31, 2019 O A-9.07 (SP) Provide and publish year end reports for Façade Improvement Program – present 5 applications to Planning Commission ■ • Applications Presented December 31, Annually O A-9.08 (SP) If we continue to contract with PADA: Inventory vacant downtown commercial properties and apply Buxton study to identify needed business types. ■ • PADA Execute Contract March 31, 2020 O A-9.09 (SP) Create plan motivating vacant property owners to upgrade buildings or lots ■ • Plan Developed March 31, 2020 O A-9.10 (AIA) Improve the downtown banners at the entries to the downtown with PADA contract ■ • PADA Execute Contract December 31, 2029 O A-9.11 (AIA) Infill development in downtown ■ • Added to CFP and Comp. Plan December 31, 2022 O A-9.12 (AIA) National Park Center in City ■ • New Kiosk / DT Footprint December 31, 2022 O A-9.13 Assess climate migration impacts with forecasting every 5 years. Integrate those findings into the Comprehensive Plan, infrastructure plans, revenue and expense forecasting, and housing assessments. ■ _ Assessment complete, Plans updated December 31, 2025 O Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects Chapter 11 - Implementation 11.11 COPA CLC POPA LEKT Measurable Actions Number Action Short (0-2 yr.) Medium (2-4 yr.) Long (4+ yr.) Other Action / Metric Deliverable Date Complete Long-Range Financial Plan A-LRFP.1 (SP) Update Long-Range Financial Plan for 2018-2023 ■ Resolution Passed December 31, 2018 C A-LRFP.2 (SP) Sell Nichel and Lincoln Street Properties ■ • Execute Purchase/Sale December 31, 2018 C A-LRFP.3 (SP) Sell Morse Creek property ■ • Execute Purchase/Sale July 31, 2020 N A-LRFP.4 (SP) Increase EMS utility fee to cover additional paramedic resources ■ • Ordinance Passed July 31, 2020 N A-LRFP.5 (SP) Reexamine public safety funding option for tax exempt properties ■ • Ordinance Passed December 31, 2020 N Citywide Work Plan CA-CWP.1 N(SP)C Professional development plans for Council ■ • Plans Complete December 31, 2018 C A-CWP.2 (SP) Records management program - replace staff position ■ • Position Filled December 31, 2020 N A-CWP.3 (SP) Records management program - bring three departments onto ECM system ■ • Three Depts. on ECM December 31, 2018 C A-CWP.4 (SP) Deliver and support new online tools for data reporting and building permit process (public use) ■ • Online Permitting Available September 30, 2020 N A-CWP.5 (SP) Confirm Council community agenda topics and attendees ■ • Agendas Set September 30, 2017 C A-CWP.6 (SP) Education: Meet with superintendent, re: November Ballot ■ • Meeting Complete June 30, 2017 C Abbreviations: COPA = City of Port Angeles; CLC = Clallam County; POPA = Port of Port Angeles; LEKT = Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe; WSDOT - Washington State Department of Transportation; WA DAHP = Washington State Department of Archeology and Historic Preservation; WA DOE = Washington State Department of Ecology; SP = City of Port Angeles Strategic Plan 2017-2018; AIA = American Institute of Architects COPA CLC POPA LEKT 11.12 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan This page is left intentionally blank 2019 Amendment City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Appendices (This page intentionally left blank) Table of Contents: Appendices Appendix A - Community Profile City History ..............................................................................................................................A•1 Current Characteristics ............................................................................................................A•6 Location ...........................................................................................................................................A•7 Air .....................................................................................................................................................A•7 Water ...............................................................................................................................................A•7 Wildlife .............................................................................................................................................A•8 Natural Resources ............................................................................................................................A•9 Environmentally Sensitive Areas Map (Figure A.05) ...............................................................................A•6 Noise ................................................................................................................................................A•11 Population ........................................................................................................................................A•12 Population Projections, OFM (Table A.01) ..............................................................................................A•13 Land Use ..........................................................................................................................................A•13 Number of Parcels, by Zone (Figure A.06) ..............................................................................................A•11 Industrial Zone Land Use (Figure A.07) ...................................................................................................A•11 Residential Zone Land Use (Figure A.08) ................................................................................................A•11 Community Facilities ........................................................................................................................A•13 Planning Areas ..................................................................................................................................A•15 City Planning Areas Map (Figure A.09) ...................................................................................................A•12 Urban Growth Areas ........................................................................................................................A•18 Urban Growth Areas Map (Figure A.10) .................................................................................................A•14 Neighborhoods ................................................................................................................................A•18 City Neighborhoods Map (Figure A.11) ..................................................................................................A•16 Housing ............................................................................................................................................A•28 Transportation .................................................................................................................................A•28 Arterial Street System Map (Figure A.14) ...............................................................................................A•22 Clallam Transit System Map (Figure A.15) ..............................................................................................A•23 Urban Services .................................................................................................................................A•32 Fire Four-Minute Response Map (Figure A.17) .......................................................................................A•25 City Park Areas Map (Figure A.20) .........................................................................................................A•27 Public School Locations Map (Figure A.21) .............................................................................................A•30 Appendix B - Definitions Appendix C - GMA Requirements General Comments ..................................................................................................................C•1 Requirements for the Land Use Element .................................................................................C•2 Requirements for the Land Use Element (Table C.01`) .............................................................................C•2 Requirements for the Housing Element ...................................................................................C•3 Requirements for the Housing Element (Table C.02) ...............................................................................C•4 Requirements for the Capital Facilities Element ......................................................................C•4 Requirements for the Capital Facilities Element (Table C.03) ..................................................................C•5 apx•i City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Requirements for the Utilities & Public Services Element .......................................................C•5 Requirements for the Utilities & Public Services Element (Table C.04) ....................................................C•5 Requirements for the Transportation Element ........................................................................C•5 Requirements for the Transportation Element (Table C.05) .....................................................................C•7 Requirements for Siting Public Facilities ..................................................................................C•7 Requirements for Siting Public Facilities (Table C.06) ..............................................................................C•7 Appendix D - Transportation Analysis General Comments ..................................................................................................................D•1 Data Collection ........................................................................................................................D•2 Traffic Growth Forecast ...........................................................................................................D•2 Intersection Level of Service Analysis ......................................................................................D•3 Intersection Level of Service Criteria (Table 1) ........................................................................................D•4 Intersection Operations Summary - PM Peak Hour (Table 2) ..................................................................D•5 Roadway Segment Level of Service Analysis ............................................................................D•5 Roadway Segment Operations Summary - PM Peak Hour (Table 3) .......................................................D•7 Mitigation Measures ................................................................................................................D•7 Appendix E - City-Wide Performance Measures General Comments ..................................................................................................................E•1 Community and Economic Development Performance Standards Results ..............................E•3 Fire Department Perfromance Standards Results ...................................................................E•3 Police Department Perfromance Standards Results ................................................................E•4 Parks Department Performance Standards Results ..................................................................E•4 Legal Department Performance Standards Results ..................................................................E•4 Public Works Department Performance Standards Results ......................................................E•5 Finance Department .................................................................................................................E•5 Appendix F - Comprehensive Plan Related Documents Table of Contents apx•ii This page is left intentionally blank (This page intentionally left blank) Community Profile City History The City of Port Angeles has long been the primary urban center of the North Olympic Peninsula. The earliest residents of the area were the Klallam Tribe ("Strong People"), Native Americans who were sustained by the region's abundant natural resources. These same natural resources - the naturally protected deep-water harbor, abundant coniferous forests, prolific wildlife and marine resources, and an overall natural beauty also attracted the first non-natives to the area and continue today to encourage visitors and new residents alike from all walks of life. Known variously as "Old Dungeness," "False Dungeness," "Cherbourg," and "Port Angeles," settlement was intermittent and sporadic throughout the early history of the city. In 1862 (due largely to the efforts of one man: Victor Smith, the "Father of Port Angeles"), President Abraham Lincoln signed an executive order setting aside 3,520 acres of land on the site as a U.S. Government Lighthouse and Military Reservation. Soon after, the original townsite layout was platted AAppendix by the US Army Corps of Engineers, and the townsite of Port Angeles has endured to this day. Patterned after the plan of Cincinnati, Ohio (substituting the Harbor for the Ohio River), the streets are arranged and named the same: Front, First, Second, etc.; at right angles to these are Tumwater, Cedar, Pine, Valley, Cherry, Oak, Laurel, Vine, and Race Street. While the City has benefited greatly from that original planning with its grid-pattern street layout, various challenges were also created such as utility service provision and circulatory problems, due to the topography of the land. Six different streams, with associated ravines, travel through the community flowing north from the foothills of the Olympic Mountains as they quickly make their way to the Strait of Juan de Fuca. They are: Dry Creek, Tumwater Creek, Valley Creek, Peabody Creek, Ennis Creek, White's Creek, with Lee's Creek, and Morse Creek located within the City’s Urban Growth Areas. Despite such early planning, major settlement did not take place within the city until 1887, with the founding of the Puget Sound Cooperative Colony. A social experiment in communal living, the Colony contributed greatly to the early expansion of Port Angeles. Although short-lived, this settlement near the mouth of Ennis Creek built a sawmill, lath-mill and shipyard; constructed a 58-foot propeller-driven schooner ("The Angeles"); started the first newspaper in town ("The Model Commonwealth"); and built the first schoolhouse, office building and a city opera house - in addition to founding four different churches in Port Angeles. The colony was largely disbanded by 1889 due to internal disputes, but many of the colonists stayed and blended with the rest of the thriving community. A•3 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.01 – Port Angeles, as depicted in a 1917 Army Corps/USGS survey map (Image: University of Texas, Perry-Castañeda Library Map Collection) By 1890, the city population had soared to over 3,000 people, and the Government Reserve established 28 years earlier had become a bottleneck to progress, completely restricting further development of the city since it could not legally be homesteaded. The result was a "land rush" onto the federal property, as citizens took matters into their own hands as "Reserve Jumpers" - moving en- masse onto the reserve, platting lots, and establishing homesteads. Eventually, forced to recognize this matter officially, Congress conceded ownership to the squatters and opened the Reserve for sale to the public. The year 1890 was also notable as the year Port Angeles was officially incorporated as a city in the newly established State of Washington, and that same year it also became the County Seat of Clallam County. Thereafter, the City grew more slowly and developed much as other small towns in the Pacific Northwest. Gone were the early pretensions of becoming a great seaport or second national city patterned after Washington, D.C. Logging and timber have long been important industries, and in 1914 Port Angeles was home to the world’s largest sawmill. In 1920, a large pulp and paper mill was built by Washington Pulp and Paper Company. Purchased a few years later and operated by Crown Zellerbach for over 60 years, the paper mill, located at the base of Appendix A - Community Profile A•4 Figure A.02 – This detail of the "Ennis Creek" mural depicts a 1700s-era Klallum village. (Image: Feiro Marine Life Center) Ediz Hook, is now owned and operated by McKinley Co. The City experienced sporadic growth until the linking of Port Angeles with the transcontinental railroad in 1914 brought increased prosperity. As rail transport increased and sea travel waned, Port Angeles surpassed Port Townsend as the major center for trade and commerce on the Olympic Peninsula. Sustained largely by marine trades and the forest products and fishing industries, Port Angeles became a classic American small town and the center of urban life on the North Olympic Peninsula. In 1922, the Port of Port Angeles was formed. The natural deep-water harbor has always attracted shipping as well as commercial and sports fishing. The Port now operates the Boat Haven Marina and The William Fairchild International Airport, in addition to managing much of the shoreline properties west of downtown Port Angeles. The first Coast Guard air station on the Pacific Coast was established at Ediz Hook on June 1, 1935. It is the oldest United States Coast Guard Station in the country. The piece of land currently occupied by the Coast Guard Station is the one remaining part of the military reservation that once included all of what is now Port Angeles. The station officially became Coast Guard Group Port Angeles in September of 1944, and received its first helicopter in 1946. By far the largest civic project was the regrading of the downtown streets, which occurred in 1914. That project created the current street elevation in the downtown - which resulted in basement levels for then- existing businesses (now the "Port Angeles Underground"). The Olympic Power Company was formed in 1911 to construct the Lower Elwha Dam. The County Courthouse was built A•5 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.03 – Port Angeles, as located in Clallam County and relative to Washington State. Figure A.04 – Downtown Port Angeles was dramatically transformed in 1914 when street- level grades were raised 12 feet or more following a massive sluice operation - effectively a man- made mud slide using a nearby hillside for source material. on Lincoln Street in 1915. A new fire station was built in 1931. A new police station and jail was built in 1954, and a new City Hall in 1987. In 1953, Port Angeles received the "All American City" award. Over the past forty years, except for a few periods of more rapid growth in the 1920s and 30s, the city has grown at a fairly stable rate of approximately one percent per year, to its present population of 19,370. The City has used zoning to coordinate development and growth since the 1930s, and in the early 1960s, made a determined effort to improve planning efforts through development of a "701" master plan along with a new zoning ordinance and subdivision ordinance. In 1976, the City again reviewed its planning goals and processes, and adopted the 1976 Comprehensive Plan, which is the immediate predecessor of this Comprehensive Plan. Even before the State passed the Growth Management Act (GMA) of 1990 requiring cities and counties to revise or adopt comprehensive plans, the City of Port Angeles had decided it was time to revise the existing Comprehensive Plan, and had already begun that process when the GMA established new requirements for comprehensive plans. In response, the City has continued to move forward, consistent with the GMA, meeting all of its requirements, including the mandated completion dates. Appendix A - Community Profile A•6 Current Characteristics An essential part of developing goals and setting directions for the future lies in reviewing the past and evaluating the present. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), prepared by the consulting firm of Nancy A. Ryan and Company for the 1994 Comprehensive Plan takes an in-depth look at the physical, social, and economic aspects of Port Angeles. A second addendum to the original EIS was prepared and adopted for the updates that have occurred over a three-year period ending in 2004. The following descriptions are intended to provide the users of this document with a general view of the community. For a more detailed analysis, refer to the EIS and the 2004 update addendum. A•7 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.05 – This map of Port Angeles' "environmentally sensitive areas" shows general locations of marine bluffs, ravines, shoreline buffers and modified fill areas. Location The City of Port Angeles is located in Clallam County on the northern coast of Washington's Olympic Peninsula (See Figure A.03). It is less than three hours driving time (including the ferry ride) from Seattle or Olympia, and is located at the base of the Olympic Mountains' north slope. Immediately to the north is the coastal marine environment of the Port Angeles Harbor, one of the deepest naturally-protected harbors on the West Coast, and Strait of Juan de Fuca. To the south are the pristine alpine wilderness areas of the Olympic National Park, to the east is the semi-arid climate of the Sequim-Dungeness Valley, and within two hours time to the west is the Hoh Rain Forest and the beaches and rugged beauty of the Pacific Coast. Air The circulation of air around the Olympic Mountains and through the Strait of Juan de Fuca results in mostly easterly or westerly winds in the vicinity of Port Angeles. Highest winds are generally associated with intense winter storms, and may be from either an easterly or westerly direction. On most summer afternoons, a moderate to strong westerly breeze can be expected. Wind velocity and direction vary with the season. Winds from the west predominate and are strongest during the summer, averaging about 14 miles per hour. Winds from the south and east occur more frequently during the winter, with an average velocity of about nine miles per hour. Water Port Angeles is located in the Port Angeles watershed, which drains 65,000 acres (101.5 square miles). A gradually-descending slope from the Olympic Mountains north to the Strait of Juan de Fuca characterizes the topography of the immediate Port Angeles area. Steep hillsides and bluffs of 50 to 150 feet in elevation mark the northern edge of the slope. This region is segmented by streams, which flow from the mountains toward the Strait and have formed V-shaped ravines that are much lower in elevation than surrounding areas. These ravines contain the following major creeks passing through the community to Port Angeles Harbor and the Strait of Juan de Fuca: Dry Creek, Tumwater Creek, Valley Creek, Peabody Creek, Ennis/White's Creek; Lee's Creek and Morse Creek are located east of the City limits in the UGA. The Elwha River is located approximately 1.25 miles west of the City, and is the primary water Appendix A - Community Profile A•8 source for the city. Very few sites in the City obtain potable water from wells. Wildlife Port Angeles is located in an area replete with wildlife. The City is located adjacent to Olympic National Park and the Strait of Juan de Fuca. The drainages that pass through Port Angeles provide wooded corridors and habitat for a wide variety of wildlife. Various freshwater wetlands are scattered throughout the city. Port Angeles Harbor is approximately 2,435 acres in size and is one of the deepest natural harbors on the west coast. It provides habitat for many aquatic species. The wooded riparian areas provide food, cover, spawning, breeding, and rearing areas for a wide variety of wildlife species. Trees and other plants shade streams and help keep water cool while stabilizing banks and providing food and habitat for insects, amphibians, reptiles, mammals, birds and fish. Trees also provide cover for wildlife. When trees die and fall into the streams, the logs create small dams and pools that offer fish rearing habitat and cover from predators. Logs that remain on land provide cover for wildlife. Wildlife from the ravines also make use of surrounding developed properties and undeveloped lands for foraging. Within Clallam County, the Washington State Department of Wildlife (Priority Habitats and Species program) has indicated that there are 15 "priority habitats" and 104 "priority species" listed in Clallam County.2 Due to an agreement with the Department of Wildlife, the location of these habitats is not made available. The locations have been reviewed and considered as part of this analysis. The location of other less sensitive species has been identified in the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS). In particular, there are three areas that harbor seals use for haul-out. Those sites are the beach at the former Rayonier Mill site, Hollywood Beach near downtown, and the south shore of Ediz Hook in Port Angeles Harbor. Department of Wildlife maps identify an area along the Harbor side of Ediz Hook that has "regular large concentrations" of shorebirds. The bluff along the shoreline also provides a special and valuable habitat for shorebirds and other wildlife. Within the Olympic National Park, Roosevelt Elk roam the slopes of the mountains. Other wildlife include black bears, cougars, coyotes, mountain beavers, minks, raccoons, otters, wolves, eagles, hawks, 1. State of Washington Priority Habitats and Species List, August 2008 A•9 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan ravens, and grouse. Fisher have recently been reintroduced into the Olympic National Park as well. Mountain goats were introduced to the Olympic National Park during the last century and have become well-established. All of the creeks that make up the Port Angeles watershed are used for fish habitat, but most have barriers to fish migration. Coho, cutthroat and possibly steelhead use Dry Creek. Tumwater Creek provides anadromous use by coho, cutthroat, and steelhead well- upstream of the City limits. Valley Creek and Peabody Creek may be used by sea-run cutthroat, however, these runs are not felt to be self-sustaining. The stream ravines provide sections of relatively high quality habitat, and are recognized by the State as sustaining significant populations of resident fish and potentially having salmon runs restored - once downstream impediments are removed. The resident fish currently present in Ennis Creek are coho, sea-run cutthroat, and steelhead. The fish migrate up to 4.9 miles from the Port Angeles Harbor. White's Creek, which joins Ennis Creek, contains coho, steelhead, and sea-run cutthroat only up to Front Street. The estuary at Valley Creek was restored to its original condition as a mitigation action in 1996. Extensive restoration of Valley Creek has been accomplished upstream from the southern end of Valley Street to the Highway 101 crossing. Restoration efforts have been supported by City land acquisitions along the lower portions of Valley Creek, with the intent of future restoration projects. Natural Resources There are very limited forest areas, and no mineral lands located within the City. Much of the forested areas are located within stream ravines or along the marine bluffs. Approximately 35 acres of developable lands remain forested. Lincoln Park and Shane park also contain forested areas that are protected from development, however the trees in Lincoln Park are beginning to penetrate the air space needed for approach to Fairchild Airport, and will likely be removed in the future. The City of Port Angeles contains 26 miles of marine shoreline including Ediz Hook, a four-mile-long sand spit, and 17 miles of streams. Diverse scenic resources are abundant in Port Angeles. Notable visual elements include the Strait of Juan de Fuca, Ediz Hook, Vancouver Island, San Juan Islands, Mt. Baker, Hurricane Ridge, and the Olympic National Park. Of special note are the views along the bluffs above Port Angeles Harbor. The Ocean View Cemetery Appendix A - Community Profile A•10 A•11 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan 1331 897 834 457 445 197 171 161 140 117 117 115 109 61 24 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 RS-9 PBP RS-7 RHD CA CO CSD CN IL RMD PRD IH CBD RS-11 RTP NUMBER OF PARCELS by ZONE Figure A.06 – This chart shows the number of parcels associated with Port Angeles zoning categories. Figure A.07 – Developed and undeveloped industrial-zoned land, in acres. Figure A.08 – Developed and undeveloped residential-zoned land, in acres. 1358.27 322.97 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 Industrial Developed Industrial Undeveloped Industrial Zone Land Use 4% 14% 11% 23% 46% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% RS-7 RS-9 RHD RMD RS-11 % of Residen:ally Zoned Parcels Remaining Undeveloped at the west edge of town provides views northward and along the coastline. The beaches and beachfront trail along the shoreline also offer views of Ediz Hook, the Strait of Juan de Fuca, and Vancouver Island. Ediz Hook has superlative views of the Strait, mountains, waterfront, and the city. The vegetated creek ravines offer wooded open space, providing wildlife habitat and corridors connecting the waterfront with the foothills. Other open space amenities include wetlands, steep slopes, marshes, hilltops, and even open fields. Noise The primary sources of noise in Port Angeles is air traffic from the airport and the Coast Guard base, industrial activities along the Port Angeles Harbor shoreline, vehicular traffic, and construction activities. The ambient noise levels within the City of Port Angeles would be expected to vary depending on location within the city. In 1986, a Noise Compatibility Planning Study was conducted for the Fairchild International Airport under the guidelines of the Federal Aviation Regulations. The Planning Study included analyses of both existing and projected noise levels associated with the aviation traffic. The one remaining mill along the waterfront is a source of noise and is in a difficult place to provide noise attenuation. Since the mill is visible from many residential areas on the bluff top to the south, these residences can be expected to receive the greatest noise impacts. The Rayonier Mill closed in late 1990s, leaving no noise-producing industries east of the downtown area. The K-Ply mill near downtown closed in 2011, with site remediation completed in 2016. The Port of Port Angeles intends redevelopment of the site for marine trades industries. Higher noise levels are allowed for motor vehicles operations on public roads. Warning sirens and temporary construction equipment are generally exempt from the noise regulations. Traffic levels would be expected to be highest along major transportation routes of US 101, First Street, Front Street, Lincoln, Lauridsen Boulevard, Race Street, Tumwater Truck Route, and Marine Drive. Appendix A - Community Profile A•12 Population The population for the City of Port Angeles in 1993 was 18,270; this represented an increase of three percent over the 1990 population of 17,710. The population for Clallam County in 1993 was 61,400. The percentage of the County population residing in the City dropped to 28.5% in 2004. The 2000 population of 18,397 marked a 3.7% increase over the 1990 population. The population had risen to 18,740 by 2007, and was 19,090 in 2015. The State Office of Financial Management (OFM) has projected a five percent growth rate over the next 20 years for Clallam County; this, along with a linear projection for Port Angeles, is illustrated in Table A.01. The City population so far not grown at the projected rate. Table A.01 - Population Projections based on Office of Financial Management Population 2010 2015 2025 2035 2045 Port Angeles 19,038 20,509 23,802 27,623 32,058 Clallam County 71,404 75,717 85,142 95,739 107,655 The population figures in Table A.01 are projections based on an estimated 1.5% growth rate from 2010 census data. These numbers are considered high due to the historic growth rate for the City of 0.36% per year. Using information from the 2015 OF estimate, the percentage of Clallam County population attributed to the City of Port Angeles was 26.3%. Land Use The City of Port Angeles contains 10.7 square miles or 6,856 acres of land area. There are residential areas, industrial areas and commercial areas with a fairly well defined Central Business District (CBD). Figure A.06 shows the number of parcels within each zone. Port Angeles currently has land available in each zone designation to meet the anticipated future needs for developable lands. Figure A.07 and Figure A.08 indicate the amount of available land for industrial and residential lands, respectively. Currently, there are 567 parcels developed with infrastructure available for residential development. Community Facilities Community facilities include a 126-bed hospital, one public library, one fire station, one police station, 22 developed parks, the Senior A•13 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Services Community Center, a public swimming pool, the Vern Burton Community Center, a publicly owned cemetery, one private golf course, four cultural centers (Port Angeles Fine Arts Center, Arthur D. Fierro Marine Lab, The Lower Elwha Klallam Cultural Center, and the North Olympic Cultural Center). The Port Angeles School District Number 121 serves the City of Port Angeles and its surrounding community. The District operates five elementary schools, one middle school (grades 7-8), one high school, one alternative high school, and is host to the North Olympic Peninsula Skills Center. Within the City of Port Angeles there are three elementary schools; Franklin Elementary, Hamilton Elementary, and Jefferson Elementary. Dry Creek Elementary School is located west of the city limits and Roosevelt Elementary is located east of the City limits. Stevens Middle School, Port Angeles High School and Lincoln High School provide for secondary education. The Skills Center, working closely with Peninsula College and five neighboring school districts - Cape Flattery, Crescent, Quileute, Port Appendix A - Community Profile A•14 Figure A.21 – Public schools located in Port Angeles. Angeles and Sequim School Districts - provides the latest vocational/ technical education in a competency-based learning environment. Peninsula College, with its main campus located in the foothills of the Olympic Mountains and overlooking the Strait of Juan de Fuca, provides a vital center for higher education and diverse cultural opportunities, enhancing and strengthening community bonds for the residents of the North Olympic Peninsula. College programs include traditional academic transfer offerings, professional- technical training, Basic Education for Adults, adult continuing education, on-line learning courses and a center for baccalaureate degrees, allowing students many educational options. In addition to the many associate degree and certificate programs, Peninsula College offers a baccalaureate degree in Applied Management. The college also works with key university partners, providing numerous opportunities for residents to earn bachelor degrees locally. These partners include City University, Western Washington University, Goddard College and Evergreen State College. Peninsula College is committed to providing college/community connections and has numerous partnerships and collaborations in the community with the City of Port Angeles, the Port of Port Angeles, the Port Angeles School District, the Economic Development Council, local tribes, private businesses and others. The college offers classes, training and resources in support of workforce development and community enrichment. The college currently serves over 5,000 students and employs 145 full-time faculty and staff and approximately 390 part-time faculty and staff. The Port of Port Angeles operates a 16.1-acre marina, with approximately 375 boat slips and 3,000 feet of dock for tie-ups, and a public boat yard for repair and maintenance. The Boat Haven Marina was upgraded during 2007-2008. The port also operates the William R. Fairchild International Airport. Planning Areas The Comprehensive Plan divides the City into eight planning areas. For the purpose of description, the individual planning areas are identified as the Harbor, Northwest, Southwest, North Central, South Central, East, Eastern Urban Growth Area and Southwestern Urban Growth Area planning areas. These areas are located on Figure A.09 and are described as follows: A•15 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Harbor The Harbor planning area includes all shoreline areas adjacent to Port Angeles Harbor and contains the Coast Guard Station, the City- operated boat ramps, Harborview Park, and the McKinley Paper Company Mill, all on Ediz Hook. The historic downtown and waterfront are also essential parts of this sub-area. The boat haven marina, log export terminal, the Coho Ferry terminal, and City Pier Park line the waterfront. Entertainment activities (movie theater, bookstores, antique shops, galleries, historic underground tour and restaurants) abound within the pedestrian-oriented central business district. Also in the Harbor planning area is the former Rayonier Mill site. The mill has been closed since 1997, and has been demolished. The site is undergoing remediation for clean-up of materials left from the previous mill operation. In 2013, the City purchased a five million- gallon storage tank that remained on the site and has incorporated the tank into its facilities for the remediation of combined sewer overflows into Port Angeles Harbor. Appendix A - Community Profile A•16 Figure A.09 – Planning areas defined for purposes of this comprehensive plan. Northwest The Northwest planning area covers the western edge of the city lying west of Tumwater Creek and north of Fairchild International Airport. This area is comprised largely of older homes, however recent growth pressure has led to new subdivisions and home construction in the area. There is a commercial area located at 8th and "C" Street, serving the residents of the west end of the City. A pocket of industrial/ commercial activities is located along the Tumwater Truck Route near the US 101 junction. This area of town has limited access because of the Tumwater Creek ravine and the bluffs. The Northwest Planning Area has the largest segment of undeveloped residential land within the current City limits. Southwest The Southwest planning area includes Fairchild International Airport, the Clallam County Fairgrounds, Ocean View Cemetery, the Port Angeles Regional Transfer Station, The Extreme Sports Park property, A•17 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.10 – Urban Growth Areas (UGAs) defined for purposes of this comprehensive plan. Fairchild International Airport and Lincoln Park. In 2005, the city annexed 358 acres of land into the southwest planning area. Much of the area is included in the Eclipse Industrial Park. Industrial development is located at the airport industrial park, and the area was annexed in 2005. A few homes lie within the City limits along Lower Elwha Road, but otherwise this planning area contains predominantly industrial and public land uses. North Central The North Central planning area is an older, denser portion of town. It is an area bounded on the west by the Tumwater Creek ravine and divided by Valley Creek and Peabody Creek ravines. It contains City Hall, Clallam County courthouse, the William Shore pool and the Carnegie Library museum. The commercial uses along Lincoln Street provide community shopping opportunities. Recreation is provided by a number of neighborhood parks. Much of the city's multifamily housing is within this planning area. South Central The South Central planning area is the area of town with newer homes on larger lots. This planning area was annexed into the City after much development had occurred. The street pattern changes from traditional townsite blocks to smaller lots in older areas and large blocks and cul- de-sacs in newer areas. The Port Angeles High School lies within this planning area. The Olympic National Park Headquarters and Visitors Center is along the Heart of the Hills Road. East The East planning area is the area east of Race Street to the eastern city limits. This area has a mix of older homes and newer residential subdivisions and development, as well as a portion of the First and Front Street commercial corridor. This planning area includes Peninsula College facilities and Peninsula Golf Club. Urban Growth Areas Eastern UGA The Eastern Urban Growth Area (UGA) is generally the area east of the city limits. Remnant properties in the UGA that are located south of the city limits and east of Valley Creek are considered to be in this UGA until annexation occurs, whereby they will be considered to be part of the adjacent planning area. Policies for this planning area are adopted by Clallam County as a part of the Port Angeles Regional Comprehensive Plan. Appendix A - Community Profile A•18 Western UGA The Western UGA is generally the area west and south of the City limits. Remnant properties in the UGA that are located south of the pre-2005 city limits, north of Highway 101 and west of Tumwater Creek as far as Reddick Road are considered to be in this UGA until annexation occurs, whereby they will be considered to be part of the adjacent planning area. Policies for this planning area are adopted by Clallam County as a part of the Port Angeles Regional Comprehensive Plan. Neighborhoods The City's planning areas are made up of 18 separate neighborhoods. The distinct neighborhoods are described in the following sections. Downtown The downtown neighborhood is the smallest neighborhood, extending north from the marine bluff to the waterfront and east from Valley Street to Chase Street on the east, and extending east along the Waterfront Trail to Vine Street (extended). The Downtown neighborhood is the traditional community center of the City. Many of the structures are two stories tall, with a few having residential uses on the second floor, or are used for offices. Many others are in disrepair, or are vacant. Buildings in the downtown area span several decades and architectural styles, some dating to the early 20th century. Few structures are more than two stories tall. The Lee Plaza is the major residential structure in the downtown area, and is managed by the Peninsula Housing Authority for low-income individuals. The City's Comprehensive Plan and zoning ordinance support increased residential uses in the downtown. The downtown is a walkable neighborhood, with ample sidewalk areas, mid-block crosswalks and a large variety of eateries and gathering places. A locally-owned natural A•19 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.12 – Downtown is Port Angeles' smallest neighborhood, but it's also the city's most dynamic, featuring dozens of shops, restaurants, beach and community gathering areas, and the Coho Ferry serving Victoria, BC. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) foods market, specializing in organic products and locally-grown produce anchors the west end of the downtown area. Washington State Department of Health and Human Services operates out of a downtown location. Ample parking is scattered throughout the downtown area. There are no longer any large anchor chain stores in the Downtown, however there are many individual shops providing unique items, such as clothing, books, candy, brewing supplies, boutique clothing, athletic goods, auto parts, novelties, gifts, art and furniture. Several City projects have been undertaken in the downtown in recent years. Water mains, sewer lines, sidewalks and street trees have been replaced. The sidewalks are constructed of pavers to enhance the aesthetics of the area. A recent project has replaced shoreline armoring along a portion of Railroad Avenue west of the ferry landing. Improved waterfront treatments and removal of hard armoring in favor of two pocket beach areas has returned areas further west to a much more natural Appendix A - Community Profile A•20 Figure A.11 – Port Angeles neighborhoods defined for purposes of this comprehensive plan. appearance. This project also resulted in the formal extension of the Olympic Discovery/ Waterfront Trail through the downtown area, and created a block-long park on the west end of the Downtown, which complements City Pier Park located at the east end of the Downtown. The Downtown is an international port, hosting the Coho Ferry, which provides direct access to Victoria Canada. Pine Hill The Pine hill neighborhood extends from the center of Valley Creek ravine on the east to the center of Tumwater Creek ravine on the west. The northern boundary of the neighborhood is the marine bluff and the southern boundary is Highway 101. Pine Hill neighborhood is one of the older central city neighborhoods. The urban character of this neighborhood is similar to several other older neighborhoods, typically featuring 7,000 square-foot lots and standard grid pattern streets. The homes in this area typically are older structures built in the early 20th century, with a variety of more recent infill homes scattered throughout the area. The predominant style of house is typically American Craftsman. The area is generally level, with a slight rise from north to south. This aspect limits views towards the water (north) but many homes have views of the Olympic Mountains to the south. Very few commercial uses exist in this neighborhood. Those commercial uses that do exist are located along the 8th Street corridor. The Pine Hill neighborhood is only served by transit along 8th Street. Sidewalks do exist throughout the neighborhood. West End The West End neighborhood extends west from 'M' Street to the marine bluff, and south A•21 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.13 – 2016 updates to the Comprehensive Plan support greater housing diversity in Port Angeles neighborhoods, providing options for all. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) from 10th Street to 18th Street, and is one of the least-developed areas of the city. Larger-lot zoning (up to 11,000 square feet) and the allowance for curvilinear streets and cul-de-sacs result in a more suburban character. The neighborhood contains five different zone designations, allowing a range of densities from less than four dwelling units per acre to 12.44 dwelling units per acre. Two residential manufactured home parks exist in the neighborhood. Serenity House of Clallam County, Clallam County Housing Authority, and Habitat for Humanity all have developed housing for low-income families in the area. Much of this area remains undeveloped with large tracts of forested land. Two areas in the neighborhood have been set aside and used by industrial interests to store low-hazard waste materials, making those sites unlikely to be redeveloped in the near future. Several newer (1970s to current) subdivisions have been developed in this neighborhood, however not all of the developed lots are occupied yet. Many excellent building sites are developed with urban services but remain vacant. Homes in the area are newer, many of them single- story, ranch style structures. Although the development in this area is newer than other neighborhoods, streets are developed with few sidewalks for pedestrian use. No commercial services are available in the area. Due to this limitation, the neighborhood is not considered highly walkable. The Olympic Discovery Trail spans the neighborhood following Milwaukee Drive from 10th Street to 18th Street. The City-owned Ocean View Cemetery is located at the northwest limit of the neighborhood. Views from this neighborhood are primarily to the Olympic Mountains; the few developments west of Milwaukee Drive have outstanding views of the Strait of Juan de Fuca. Airport The airport neighborhood extends west from 'M' Street to the western City limit and south from 18th Street to the City's southern limits, and is the City's largest neighborhood with 1,217 acres. The primary land use is the William Fairchild Airport. The airport also contains an industrial park situated on the north side of the runways and south of 18th Street. The neighborhood also contains the City's refuse transfer station, recycling center, and compost facility. The Extreme Sports Park is located in the neighborhood's southwest corner. Several large tracts of forested land and farm sites exist in this neighborhood. This is the least populated neighborhood in the City. Appendix A - Community Profile A•22 Cherry Hill The Cherry Hill neighborhood extends from Lincoln Street on the east to Valley Creek on the west, and from Lauridsen Boulevard on the south to marine bluff on the north. This is an older neighborhood, and contains a large portion of the City's High Density Residential zoning located at the north end of the neighborhood. The southern portion of the neighborhood is primarily single-family residential zoning. The 8th Street commercial corridor separates the two zoning districts, and a second commercial corridor extends north and south along the west side of Lincoln Street. The neighborhood contains three small parks and the east slope of the Valley Creek ravine. Homes in the area are mostly older structures. Peabody Creek The Peabody Creek neighborhood extends east of Lincoln Street to Race Street, and from 8th Street on the south to the Georgiana/Front alley on the north. The boundaries of the Peabody Creek neighborhood are all comprised of commercial corridors, with high-density residential uses west of Peabody Creek and single family residential uses east of the creek. Peabody Creek Ravine divides the neighborhood diagonally from the southeast to the northwest. The neighborhood contains Jesse Webster Park, Erikson Park, and the Dream Playground; it also contains City Hall, Clallam County Courthouse, and the Senior Center. Crown The Crown neighborhood extends from 'I' Street on the east to the marine bluff on the west and from 10th Street on the south to the top of the marine bluff on the north. The Crown neighborhood contains Crown Park which provides panoramic views from the bluff top. Hamilton Elementary School is located within this neighborhood. The neighborhood is primarily a single-family residential neighborhood and contains no commercial zones. Much of the housing in the area is newer and there are still areas that are undeveloped. Ediz Hook The Ediz Hook neighborhood is made up of Ediz Hook itself along with the waterfront area extending west of Valley Street. The neighborhood is unique in that there are no residential uses in the neighborhood, with the exception of full-time residential use of boats in the marina. The primary uses are industrial, with a few commercial activities that support the industries. Several large industries make up the major uses, including the McKinley Paper Company mill, Westport Marine and Platypus Marine. Tesoro Petroleum provides fueling operations for large ocean-going vessels. Icicle Seafoods and the Puget Sound Pilots office and facility are located at the east end of Ediz Hook. The A•23 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Port of Port Angeles owns and operates several industrial/commercial operations along the waterfront, including log storage and bark removal, topside repair of large ocean-going vessels, and berthing of navy support boats. They also own and operate the Boat Haven Marina. The Native American village Tse-wit-wen is also located within the Ediz Hook neighborhood. Ediz Hook itself provides outdoor recreation opportunities through the Sail and Paddle Park at the west end of the spit, and Harbor View Park at the east end. The parks are connected by an extension of the Olympic Discovery Trail. A boat launch is provided at the east end of the spit and at the Boat Haven Marina. Ediz Hook has recently undergone extensive habitat restoration efforts led by the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe. Georgiana The Georgiana neighborhood extends north from the Georgiana/Front Street alley to the waterfront, and extends from Vine Street on the west to the Whites Creek Ravine on the west. Although this is primarily a single-family residential neighborhood, the Olympic Medical Center's hospital and associated medical support offices make up the bulk of uses in the central portion of the neighborhood. Two parks are located in the neighborhood - Georgiana Park and Francis Street Park - which provide access to the Waterfront Trail. The abandoned Rayonier Mill site is located on the waterfront at the east end of this neighborhood. Harbor View The Harbor View neighborhood extends from the Tumwater Creek Ravine west to 'I' Street and north from 8th Street to the marine bluff. This is also primarily a single-family residential zone, with commercial uses located only at the intersection of 8th and 'C' Street. Shane Park is the only park in the neighborhood. Jefferson The Jefferson neighborhood is located between Lincoln Street on the west and Race Street on the east. It is bounded on the south by Lauridsen Boulevard, and on the north by the 8th Street corridor. This neighborhood is also primarily a single-family residential neighborhood, with the exception of uses on the south side of the 8th Street corridor. Jefferson Elementary School is located in the southwest corner of the neighborhood. Civic The Civic neighborhood extends east from Race Street to the White's Creek ravine, and north from Lauridsen Boulevard to the Georgiana/ Front Street alley. The neighborhood contains the major commercial strip along First and Front Streets, but is otherwise a single-family neighborhood. Low- intensity commercial uses are also located along Appendix A - Community Profile A•24 Race Street. This neighborhood contains Civic Field - the City's major sports facility - the Fine Art Center, and Webster Woods, a premier art venue providing unique outdoor art. Lauridsen The Lauridsen neighborhood extends south of Lauridsen Boulevard to Park Avenue, and from the Valley Creek ravine on the west to Race Street on the east. Commercial uses in this neighborhood are confined to the western portion of Lauridsen Boulevard. The Housing Authority of Clallam County manages Mount Angeles View, an affordable housing project. Lyons Park is the only formal City park in the neighborhood. Lincoln Park The Lincoln Park neighborhood extends south from 8th Street to Highway 101 and west from Tumwater Truck Route west to 'M' Street (with some variation). Commercial areas are located along the 'C' Street corridor, and at the west end of the neighborhood along Highway 101. An industrial-zoned area exists at the south end of the Tumwater truck route, where several small manufacturing and construction-related industries exist. Park View Villas, a senior/retirement center, is located in this neighborhood as well as a cluster of high-density apartments found in the vicinity of the 'C' Street and Lauridsen Boulevard intersection. The remainder of the neighborhood is single- family residential. Schools in the area include Stevens Middle School - the only middle school in the City - the North Olympic Skills Center, and Choice Alternative School. The former Lincoln School has become the Clallam County Historical Society headquarters, and is planned to become the Clallam County museum. Lincoln Park is the City's largest park, and includes the Clallam County Fairgrounds, baseball fields, two ponds, and a large wooded area. Big Boy Pond, one of the City's largest wetland areas, is located west of Stevens Middle School. Mill Creek The Mill Creek neighborhood extends south from Park Street to the southern City boundary, and from the western City boundary to Race Street and Hurricane Ridge Road on the east. This neighborhood contains the northernmost portion of the Olympic National Park, and the Park headquarters building and maintenance area. Also located in this neighborhood is Port Angeles High School. Areas directly surrounding the high school are primarily single-family residential uses situated on standard-size lots. The southern portion of the neighborhood is also single family residential, however those A•25 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan lots are larger, less developed and are typified by newer homes. No commercial uses are located within the Mill Creek Neighborhood. Mt. Angeles The Mt. Angeles neighborhood extends south from Lauridsen Boulevard to the southern City limits, and from Hurricane Ridge Road on the west to the White's Creek ravine and the eastern City limits. A large portion of this neighborhood is occupied by Peninsula College, the only institution of higher education in the City. The neighborhood also contains Franklin Elementary School. Land uses are primarily single-family residential on larger suburban- size lots; however, some medium and high-density residential uses are located near the college campus. Southwest The southwest neighborhood is located south of Highway 101 and includes the entire area annexed into the City in 2005. Appendix A - Community Profile A•26 Figure A.17 – Port Angeles' station and fire response map. White's Creek The White's Creek neighborhood extends east from the White's Creek ravine east to the City limits on the north, south and east. This neighborhood contains a large private golf course, the only golf course in the City. Also contained within this neighborhood is the City's wastewater treatment plant, which now includes a five-million gallon storage tank recently acquired from Rayonier corporation. The area includes the eastern portion of the Rayonier mill site, which is currently unused and awaiting further cleanup efforts. Recently, the City constructed a new bridge spanning Ennis Creek to provide an appropriate crossing for sewer and stormwater pipes. The bridge is also capable of carrying vehicular traffic and the Olympic Discovery/ Waterfront Trail. Housing In 1990, 7,553 dwelling units were located in Port Angeles. By 1992, units had increased by 422 (or 5.6%) to a total of 7,975 dwelling units. By 2004, units had increased by another 797 (or 10%) to a total of 9,479 units. In the decade of the 1990s, the City of Port Angeles grew at a slow rate of 3.9%. The growth in the UGA during the same time was 6.3%. During the period of 1996 to 2003, building permit activity showed that only 10.7% of the county-wide residential building units were constructed in the City of Port Angeles, while 14.2% of the county’s residential construction was in rural areas of the Port Angeles planning region. Recent amendments to the Comprehensive Plan are intended to reverse the City’s no-growth trend. Currently, the City has 6,834 parcels that are zoned for residential use. Of those residentially-zoned parcels, 761 are available for building. The City currently has a number of large undeveloped areas, and based on anticipated densities, currently undeveloped parcels would provide area for 2,280 additional dwelling units. Transportation The Regional Transportation Planning Organization (RTPO) has designated Port Angeles as a primary center of mixed-use development, and the City's UGA has been identified as a secondary center of mixed use development in the Regional Transportation Plan. Goals and policies in the Growth Management Element of this plan support focusing new growth and mixed-use opportunities in the City and UGA. The road network in the City of Port Angeles is characterized by a gridded street pattern that is oriented east to west (parallel to the waterfront) and north to south. This pattern shifts slightly south of Lauridsen Boulevard, where the street orientation shifts to match the platting A•27 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan pattern established by the County before City boundaries were expanded. The regular geometry of this pattern is generally retained, except where topography of the foothills, deep ravines or bluffs along the Strait of Juan de Fuca force road realignment. Some areas located in the western portion of the City also diverge from the grid pattern, forming a more curvilinear, suburban-style pattern. Street grades are moderate in most areas, adapting to area topography - which rises from the waterfront and gently undulates as the foothills flatten to meet the Strait of Juan de Fuca. The most unique characteristic of the City's street network is the way it is interrupted by several deep ravines, which bisect east-west street connectivity and results in a limited number of streets that run continuously from one end of the City to the other. The RTPO identifies US 101 as the only Highway of Statewide Significance in Port Angeles. The Level of Service (LOS) for Highways of Statewide Significance is established by Washington State Department of Appendix A - Community Profile A•28 Figure A.14 – Port Angeles' street system. Transportation. There are five Highways of Regional Significance through the City, including: ¡US 101 ¡State Route 117 Tumwater Truck Route ¡Race Street leading to the Olympic Park Visitor Center and Hurricane Ridge ¡The First/Front Street couplet Marine Drive from US 101 to SR 117 ¡Lincoln/Laurel/Oak Streets connecting US 101 with the Coho Ferry landing on Railroad Avenue). There is one designated truck route in the City that runs from east to west along the Front/First Street couplet to Tumwater Truck Route (State Route 117) and along Tumwater Truck Route south to US 101. All roads in Port Angeles including highways of statewide and regional significance operate at LOS "D" or better. The City of Port Angeles is served by Clallam Transit System (CTS), the Public Transportation Benefit Area (PTBA) agency that serves Clallam County with a combination of fixed-route, paratransit, and vanpool services. Similar to trends seen by other rural transit providers during times of low fuel prices and strong economic growth, ridership has declined over the past several years. The hub of CTS’s fixed-route service is Gateway Transit Center, located at the corner of Lincoln and Front Streets in downtown Port Angeles. From Gateway Transit Center, passengers can board one of four routes circulating within the city or three routes connecting Port Angeles with Sequim, Forks, and Joyce. The Strait Shot, a regional express route started by CTS in 2017, connects Gateway Transit Center with the Bainbridge Island Ferry Terminal where travelers can make timed connections to Seattle, Seattle-Tacoma International Airport, and other regional destinations. An intermediate stop in Poulsbo provides connections with Kitsap Transit for service to Silverdale and Bremerton. Paratransit service is provided to all locations within the city for those who qualify. Vanpools extend the reach of the transit network and are frequently used by those commuting to locations which are difficult to serve with fixed-route service The Dungeness Line, a part of the Washington State Department of Transportation’s rural transit program, provides twice-daily service between Port Angeles and the Seattle area, including regular stops at major hospitals, Greyhound, Amtrak, and Seattle-Tacoma International Airport. A•29 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan The Port of Port Angeles is responsible for most operations along the waterfront, including ownership of the Black Ball Ferry Terminal, the Boat Haven Marina, and other waterfront properties supporting water related industry. The Port is also responsible for operations at Fairchild International Airport and the Airport Industrial Park. The William R. Fairchild International Airport is located approximately three miles southwest of the central city and serves a combination of commercial and private aviation demands in the region. The airport is owned and operated by the Port of Port Angeles and is classified as a commercial service airport by both Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the Washington State Department of Transportation, Aviation Division (WSDOT Aviation). The airport serves the commercial service needs of the entire Peninsula including Clallam, Jefferson and portions of Mason Counties and the general aviation needs of Clallam and portions of Jefferson Counties. The airport has more than 800 acres of property, with 690 in aeronautical use, and 110 in industrial park use. Two runways are available at the Airport for the needs of larger and smaller aircraft. The Primary runway is 6,350 feet long by 150 feet wide with the secondary smaller runway being 3,250 feet long by 50 feet wide and available during daylight hours only. The primary runway has the capacity for aircraft up to 115,000 pounds. The runway is equipped with an instrument landing system, visual approach slope indicator, eight runway-end identifier lights, medium intensity approach lighting Appendix A - Community Profile A•30 Figure A.16 – Commercial flights to and from Fairchild Airport have ceased, but the facility remains an important part of Port Angeles' economic development strategy. system with runway alignment indicator, runway and taxiway lighting, and signage. The 2011 Airport Master Plan describes the short, intermediate and long- term plans for facility development and maintenance. A copy of this plan is available on the Port of Port Angeles website at http://www.portofpa. com/ index.aspx?NID=276 Land uses surrounding the William R. Fairchild International Airport include residential, industrial and park/open space. The main landing approach area for the airport is over the most densely populated portion of the City, with the final approach over Lincoln Park located immediately east of the airport. Due to the height of the trees growing in Lincoln Park, debate over the future of Lincoln Park has been an on-going discussion. The area to the west of the airport (the primary take-off area contains the City’s solid waste Transfer Station, recycling center and composting facility. Farther to the west, the area is located in the County and is zoned Rural Low and Moderate density and Rural Character Conservation (RCC3) to maintain low-density residential areas in the flight path area. The lands adjacent to the airport on both the north and south are designated and zoned as industrial to buffer the impacts that may be expected from airport use to less intense land uses adjacent to the airport. Urban Services Police The Port Angeles Police Department provides the full range of police services within the city limits of Port Angeles, operates PenCom (the county wide 911 dispatch center for police, fire and EMS calls that represents 18 agencies) and works with allied agencies on a regional basis to include the Olympic Peninsula Narcotics Enforcement Team A•31 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.15 – The Clallam Transit system provides service covering large portions of the county. Four routes circulate within Port Angeles' city limits. (OPNET), police k-9 response and the Major Incident Response Team (MIRT). The police department provides patrol, crime prevention, community policing, a school resource officer, police k-9, crisis negotiators and criminal investigation services. The police operations headquarters and PenCom are located at City Hall. The Department has 62 personnel, which includes 32 authorized commissioned officers, 1 parking enforcement officer, 6 records specialists, 20 communications officers, 1 administrative coordinator and an additional 25 civilian police volunteers. The PenCom manager is a contracted position with Jefferson County 911. Fire The Port Angeles Fire Department provides fire response and advanced life support emergency medical services within the city limits of Port Angeles. The Fire Department headquarters station is located at 5th and Laurel Streets. The Department has 23 career personnel, including 21 firefighters who are cross-trained as emergency medical technicians, with 11 certified as paramedics. In addition to career personnel, the Department has an active volunteer component that is consolidated with the adjoining fire district. City Parks & Recreation Facilities The City Parks and Recreation Department maintains over 114 acres of developed park land, another 81.5 acres of undeveloped land reserved for future park development, and 91.8 acres of undeveloped lands set aside for protection as open space. The Parks Department maintains 14 playground equipment sites, 13 baseball and/or softball fields, 9 football and/or soccer fields, and 12 tennis courts. Approximately 10 acres are taken up by community facilities. The Senior and Community Services Center and the Vern Burton Community Center provide a wide range of year-around recreational services. Civic Field provides a full athletic complex for soccer, football and baseball, with lighting for nighttime activities, concessions, covered stadium seating, and locker rooms. The Carnegie Library has been converted to a museum leased by the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe and neighbors the City's former fire hall. The City owns and operates the 41 acre Ocean View Cemetery. Other city facilities include the Feiro Marine Life Center, located in City Pier Park, and a traditional native long house, the Loomis Building and several other log structures at Lincoln Park. The Port Angeles Fine Arts Appendix A - Community Profile A•32 Figure A.18 – The Port Angeles Police Department also operates 911 dispatch services for police and fire operations across Clallam County. Center is located in Webster Woods Park. Two public walkways connecting the downtown area with the residential area at the top of the bluff are owned and maintained by the City. One of those walkways terminates at the Conard Dyar Memorial Fountain in downtown. The City operates a boat launch ramp and floats for boat moorage on the eastern end of Ediz Hook. The City pier also provides moorage for transient boaters. The City maintains the Olympic Discovery/ Waterfront Trail from Morse Creek to the Coast Guard Base entry on Ediz Hook and through the city to the western city limits at Lower Elwha Road. Water Utility The City of Port Angeles water service area includes the land within the city boundaries, along with services within Clallam County PUD No. 1, 52 Dry Creek customers, 5 Black Diamond customers, and one government account outside the city limits. The City also provides wholesale water to Clallam County PUD No. 1, subject to certain conditions consistent with GMA. In the City's 2002 Comprehensive Water Plan, the future service area limit was from Morse Creek to the Elwha River and bordered on the south by the Olympic National Park. The current water supply for the City is from the Elwha River. The Elwha River Ranney Well System with a minimum yield of 11 million gallons was originally constructed in 1977 with major renovations made during the Elwha Dam removal project started in 2010. This source provides for domestic and commercial and some industrial needs of the City. There is also a separate industrial water supply line serving the McKinley Paper Co. Mill. Stormwater Management The City maintains all public storm sewers, culverts, and stormwater facilities, including the WSDOT conduits, culverts, and stormwater facilities along the US 101 corridor within the A•33 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.19 – Lincoln Park is one of Port Angeles' most diverse activity-oriented parks, including disc golf, a BMX track, a dog park, event facilities, fairground areas, wetlands and play fields. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) city limits. The City is currently making a major shift in its approach to stormwater management, moving away from the more traditional system of hard surfaces draining to catch basins and being piped to the nearest water body to a more natural acting system of allowing stormwater to be absorbed into the earth through the installation of rain gardens and enhancing vegetative cover, including vegetated roof systems. Wastewater Utility The City’s wastewater system includes a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) built in 1968-69 as a primary treatment facility, and upgraded to a secondary wastewater treatment plant built in 1994. The plant is the trickling filter/solids contact treatment system. Biosolids are hauled to the City’s composting facility where it is composted and sold for beneficial reuse. The sewer conveyance system includes 119 miles of sanitary and combined sewer pipe ranging from 4 to 36 inches in diameter, 17 pump stations, and two marine out-falls. The treatment Appendix A - Community Profile A•34 Figure A.20 – Park and open-space areas in Port Angeles. plant was modified most recently in 2014, when the first phase of the CSO Reduction program was completed. Modifications included a 4.9 million gallon storage tank for temporary storage of peak flows of sewage diluted by stormwater (combined sewage) during rain events, a refurbished deep water marine outfall providing improved dispersion of WWTP effluent, improvements to the trickling filters and headworks, and associated elements. The wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) located at the west end of Ennis Creek road, has a treatment capacity expected to be adequate beyond 2021. The wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) is rated at 10.8 million gallons per day (MGD) maximum month design flow, and can handle peak combined sewer flows of up to 20 MGD. The WWTP treated an average of 2.5 MGD of domestic sewage in 2014. Peak system flow capacities average 3.3 MGD (dry weather) with a maximum peak flow of 13.4 MGD. The peak system flow for 2014 was 9.86 MGD. The second and final phase of the CSO Reduction program is under construction, and scheduled for completion in 2016. When complete, combined sewer overflows to Port Angeles harbor will be reduced to less than once per year per outfall location. By design, overflows will occur at the 8000 foot long refurbished marine outfall before they occur at the two near-shore outfalls. One outfall location will be eliminated entirely. This represents a significant reduction, from an average of over 70 overflow events per year, and is a big pollution control achievement for the City. The Utility serves unincorporated areas of Clallam County (the Eastern and Western Urban Growth areas, and the Lower Elwha reservation land) and treats 2 million gallons annually of septage generated in Clallam and Jefferson County that is trucked to the WWTP. The WWTP treats about 0.5 million gallons of leachate generated by the COPA landfill and the Rayonier Mount Pleasant landfill annually. The sewer system serves approximately 3,700 acres in Port Angeles. The city has mostly 8-inch local sanitary sewers and even some small 6-inch. However, the city's original collection system was designed as a combined sewer system with storm water. There were no storm sewers in the city until the 1950s. The existing storm sewer system grew in bits and pieces as individual renovation projects and Local Improvement Districts (LID) responded to local problems. The storm A•35 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Figure A.22 – Port Angeles is working to diversify its local economy, growing marine trades and industries as well as activities related to the city's spectacular natural setting. (Image: Studio Cascade, Inc.) sewers are 6" and 8" diameter due to the steep terrain of the city. The existing storm sewers run primarily in the north/south "short block" orientation picking up catch basins, which happen to be at the east/west "long block" intersections. In summary, the old downtown has combined sewers and the rest of the city has varying degrees of partially separated sewers. The Wastewater Utility employs a Source Control Specialist as part of the Pretreatment program, to better control what comes to the WWTP and to provide education and technical assistance to business owners. Several sources of grease and oils have been identified and remedied to relieve sewer backups. The Wastewater Utility staff operates, inspects, maintains and repairs the sewer conveyance system, the pump stations, and the WWTP. The Utility funds an organized program of Capital Improvement projects that is approved by City Council each year and includes a six-year plan for future projects. Solid Waste Utility The Solid Waste Utility operated by the Port Angeles Public Works and Utilities Department provides solid waste services. Residential customer's waste is picked up weekly or biweekly and collection is mandatory. Commercial customers are picked up 6 days a week. Curbside yard waste and recycling is offered and provided by a private contractor. Current participation in the curbside recycling program is 80% per cent of the residential customers. Curbside participation in the yard waste program is around 50% per cent of the residential customers. The City of Port Angeles owns and operates the Port Angeles transfer station. The Port Angeles Regional Transfer Station began operation in 2007 after conversion from a landfill. The landfill conversion was mandated by the Federal Aviation Administration because of the potential for scavenger birds at the landfill interfering with air traffic from the adjacent airport. This site accepts municipal solid waste from residential, commercial, and industrial customers throughout Clallam County. The Port Angeles Regional Transfer Station does not accept out-of-county waste. Recycling drop boxes are provided and accept glass, aluminum, and paper. Used oil, antifreeze, and batteries are also accepted at the site. Municipal solid waste is transported to regional landfills in Eastern Washington or Oregon. A second issue related to the landfill has been the release of buried refuse onto the beach as normal bluff erosion continued. Two major projects have been undertaken by the City to relocate waste materials and stabilize the bluff erosion to resolve the problem. Appendix A - Community Profile A•36 A composting facility for managing green yard waste received from the public, curbside yard waste pick-up and biosolids from the wastewater treatment plant at the facility. Yard waste and biosolids are processed then tested and becomes finished compost available for sale to the public. Electric Utility The Light Division of the City of Port Angeles Public Works and Utilities Department is the electric power provider within the city limits. Clallam County PUD is the electric power provider for the unincorporated areas surrounding Port Angeles. The Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) via its transmission lines delivers the power used by both the City of Port Angeles and Clallam County PUD The PUD has one substation within the Eastern UGA at Monroe Street, and another in the Western UGA near Benson Road and Highway 101. There are 7 electrical substations owned by the City of Port Angeles within the City limits. n A•37 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Definitions The following definitions are for terms, which are used in this document and are provided for clarification purposes in the interpretation and implementation of the various goals and policies. BAppendix A Action (Previously Objective) A more specific subset of goals providing measurable and budgetable strategy. Adequate Public Facilities Facilities, which have the capacity to serve development without decreasing levels of service below locally, established minimums. Affordable Housing The adequacy of the community's housing stock to fulfill the housing needs of all economic segments of the population. Accessory Residential Unit A residential unit, which is subordinate in area, extent, or purpose to a principal residential unit and is located on the same zoning lot as the principal residential unit. Available Public Facilities That facilities or services are in place or that a financial commitment is in place to provide the facilities or services within a specified time. B Best Available Science That scientific information prepared by local, state or federal natural resource agencies, a qualified scientific professional or team of qualified scientific professionals, that is consistent with criteria established in WAC 365-195-900 through WAC 365-195-925. Best Management Practices Methods or techniques found to be the most effective and practical means in achieving an objective (such as preventing or minimizing pollution) while making the optimum use of available resources. Bio-retention BMP Engineered facilities that store and treat stormwater by passing it through a specified soil profile, and either retain or detain the treated stormwater for flow attenuation. Refer to Chapter 7 of Volume V of the Department of Ecology's SWMMWW (2014) for Bio-retention BMP types and design specifications. C City The City of Port Angeles, Washington. B•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Climatic Change A change in global or regional climate patterns, especially a change due to an increase in the average atmospheric temperature. Climatic change may be attributed largely to the increased levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide produced by the use of fossil fuels, but may also result from natural events such as volcanic eruption or earth quake Cluster Commercial Development Retail or other commercial uses, usually arranged in a group of buildings, that create a node of uses with a cohesive design plan and shared access points on an arterial street. Cluster commercial development is characterized by a cohesive design plan that includes at least two of the following elements: (1) pedestrian connections, (2) shared parking concepts, (3) buildings arranged in groups to create a node of commercial uses without individual street access points rather than along the linear pattern of a strip commercial development, and (4) common building design features and signage. Community Services Cultural, social and recreational services necessary to enhance the quality of life, such as libraries, parks and recreation services, fine arts, and festivals. Concurrency That adequate public facilities are available when the impacts of development occur. This definition includes the two concepts of "adequate public facilities" and of "available public facilities" as defined above. Consistency Requires that no feature of a plan or regulation is incompatible with any other feature of a plan or regulation. Consistency is indicative of a capacity for orderly integration or operation with other elements in a system. County Clallam County, Washington. D District A portion of a planning area, which is defined by the primary uses located in that portion of the planning area. Development Any activity which would alter the elevation of the land, remove or destroy plant life, cause structures of any kind to be installed, erected, or removed, divide land into two or more parcels, or any use or extension of the use of the land. Development Rights A broad range of less-than-fee-simple-ownership interests. Appendix B - Definitions B•3 Domestic Water System Any system providing a supply of potable water, which is deemed adequate pursuant to RCW 19.27.097 for the intended use of a development. E Essential Public Facilities Public capital facilities of a county-wide or state-wide nature which are typically difficult to site. Essential public facilities include the following: ¡Airports ¡Hazardous waste facilities ¡State education facilities ¡State or regional transportation facilities ¡State and local correctional facilities ¡Solid waste handling facilities ¡In-patient facilities including ¡Substance abuse facilities ¡Mental health facilities ¡Group homes ¡Regional Transit Authority facilities. Emergency Services Services, which are a City responsibility, and consists of provisions for police, fire, emergency medical and disaster services. Environmentally Sensitive/Critical Areas Environmentally Sensitive Areas means any of the following areas and their associated buffers: ¡Aquifer recharge areas ¡Streams or Stream corridors ¡Frequently flooded areas ¡Geologically hazardous areas: ¡Erosion hazard areas ¡Landslide hazard areas ¡Seismic hazard areas ¡Habitat areas for priority species and species of concern ¡Locally unique features ¡Ravines ¡Marine bluff ¡Beaches and associated coastal drift processes ¡Wetlands. B•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan F Facility Something designed, built, installed or utilized for the specific purpose of providing a service. Financial Commitment That sources of public or private funds or combinations thereof have been identified which will be sufficient to finance public facilities necessary to support development and that there is reasonable assurance that such funds will be timely put to that end. G Goal A general expression or broad statement of desired outcome in the City. Growth Management Act The Growth Management Act as enacted in Chapter 17, Laws of 1990 1st ex. sess., and chapter 32, Laws of 1991 sp. sess., State of Washington. I Impact Fees Payments to the city for the acquisition and development of new infrastructure or facilities, i.e., parks, schools, transportation systems, etc., based on a per unit (impact) assessment. Imprecise Margin The area between land use designations is called an imprecise margin. The margin is used to provide flexibility in determining the boundary between various zones. When determining appropriate zoning designations for an area near a margin, the goals, policies and objectives of the Land Use Element should take precedence. L Level of Service (LOS) An established minimum capacity of public facilities or services that must be provided per unit of demand or other appropriate measure of need. Low Impact Development (LID) A stormwater and land use management strategy that strives to mimic pre- disturbance hydrologic processes of infiltration, filtration, storage, evaporation and transpiration be emphasizing conservation, use of on-site natural features, site planning and distributed stormwater management practices that are integrated into a project design. Appendix B - Definitions B•5 M Manufactured Home A factory built, single-family structures that meet the National Manufactured Home Construction and Safety Standards Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5401), commonly known as the HUD (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) Code. Manufactured homes placed in Port Angeles must also meets the following requirements: 1) Consists of two or more fully enclosed parallel sections each of not less than 12 feet wide by 36 feet long 2) Bears an insignia issued by the appropriate federal agency indicating compliance with the construction standards of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) as amended and as approved by the State of Washington 3) Is placed on an on-grade permanent foundation or on footings and piers or on blocks in accordance with HUD’s specifications for the specific home with skirting installed so no more than one foot of the skirting is visible above grade 4) Has all travel appurtenances removed 5) Is served by underground electrical power 6) Was originally constructed with and now has a composition or wood shake or shingle, coated metal, or similar roof of not less than 3:12 pitch. Medical Services Licensed professional medical services and retail services directly related to medical services, such as hospitals, physicians' clinics, and pharmacies. Mixed-use A type of urban development that blends residential, commercial, cultural, institutional, or industrial uses, where those functions are physically and functionally integrated, and that provides pedestrian connections. N Neighborhood An area located within a district or planning area where people live, and is defined by the primary type and/or density of the residential units located in that particular area of the district. B•6 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan P Permeable Pavement Pervious concrete, porous asphalt, permeable pavers or other forms of pervious paving material intended to allow passage of water through the pavement section. It often includes an aggregate base that provides structural support and acts as a stormwater reservoir. Planning Area A large geographical area of the City which is defined by physical characteristics and boundaries. Policy A topic-specific statement providing guidelines for current and future decision making. Public Capital Facilities Existing, new or expanded physical facilities, which are owned, licensed or sanctioned by a public entity, are large in size and serve a county-wide or statewide population. Public capital facilities of a county-wide or state-wide nature may include but are not limited to the following: ¡Airports ¡State educational facilities ¡State and federal transportation facilities ¡Regional transportation facilities ¡State correctional facilities ¡Local correctional facilities ¡Solid waste handling, disposal and storage facilities ¡In-patient facilities including: ¡Abuse facilities ¡Mental health facilities ¡Group homes ¡National, state and regional parks and recreational facilities ¡Marine terminals ¡Libraries ¡Fairgrounds ¡Hospitals ¡County courthouse. Public Services Includes fire protection and suppression, law enforcement, public health, education, recreation, environmental protection, and other governmental services. Appendix B - Definitions B•7 Public Facilities Includes streets, roads, highways, sidewalks, street and road lighting systems, traffic signals, domestic water systems, storm and sanitary sewer systems, parks and recreational facilities, and schools. R Rain garden A non-engineered shallow, landscaped depression, with compost-amended native soils and adapted plants. The depression is designed to pond and temporarily store stormwater runoff from adjacent areas, and to allow stormwater to pass through the amended soil profile. Regional Transportation Plan The transportation plan for the regional designated transportation system, which is produced by the regional transportation planning organization. Regional Transportation Planning Organization The voluntary organization conforming to RCW 47.80.020, consisting of local governments within a region containing one or more counties, which have common transportation interests. Regulatory Reform Act Engrossed Substitute House Bill, ESHB 1724 was enacted in 1995 to establish new approaches to make government regulation more effective, and to make it easier and less costly for citizens and businesses to understand and comply with requirements. ESHB 1724 amended a number of laws, including the Growth Management Act (GMA), Shoreline Management Act (SMA), and State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA). Commonly referred to as the Regulatory Reform Act, ESHB 1724 amended the Growth Management Act and State Environmental Policy Act to more thoroughly integrate the SEPA process into the planning process. Appeals of SEPA determinations or permits must also be consolidated so that only one public hearing is held. ESHB 1724 is codified by the City of Port Angeles in Chapter 18.02 PAMC. Residential Care Services The providing of residential care on a daily or live-in basis including special needs housing such as group homes, adult-care homes and day-care facilities. S Sanitary Sewer Systems All facilities, including approved on-site disposal facilities, used in the collection, transmission, storage, treatment, or discharge of any waterborne waste, whether domestic in origin or a combination of domestic, commercial, or industrial waste. B•8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan School District The Port Angeles School District No. 121. Service The supplying or providing of utilities, commodities, accommodations and/or activities. Shall Means the statement is mandatory, and the action so stated is required to be done without discretion by decision-makers. The use of "shall" in a statement indicates that the action is imperative and ministerial. Should Means the statement ought to be done, but the action so stated is not required to be done by decision-makers. The use of "should" in a statement indicates that discretion may be used in deciding whether or not to take action. The use of "should" is intended to give decision-makers discretion in matters where exceptions are warranted by such factors as physical hardships and special circumstances or when funding must be taken into consideration. Solid Waste Handling Facility Any facility for the transfer or ultimate disposal of solid waste, including landfills, waste transfer stations and municipal incinerators. Social Services Those services necessary to support life and health, such as food banks, hospices, home health, congregate care, and day care services. Strip Commercial Development Retail or other commercial uses, usually one-story high and one-store deep, that front on an arterial street with individual access points. Strip commercial development differs from central business districts, shopping centers, or other cluster commercial developments in at least two of the following characteristics: 1) There are no provisions for pedestrian access between individual uses 2) The uses are only one-store deep 3) The buildings are arranged linearly with individual street access points rather than clustered, and 4) There is no design integration among the buildings. T Transfer of Development Rights The conveyance of development rights by deed, easement, or other legal instrument to another parcel of land and the recording of that conveyance. Appendix B - Definitions B•9 Transportation Facilities Facilities related to air, water, or land transportation. Transportation Systems Management The use of low capital expenditures to increase the capacity of the transportation system. TSM strategies include but are not limited to signalization, channelization, and bus turnouts. U Urban Growth Refers to growth that makes intensive use of land for the location of buildings, structures, and impermeable surfaces to such a degree as to be incompatible with the primary use of the land for the production of food, other agricultural products, or fiber, or the extraction of mineral resources. When allowed to spread over wide areas, urban growth typically requires urban governmental services. "Characterized by urban growth" refers to land having urban growth located on it, or to land located in relationship to an area with urban growth on it as to be appropriate for urban growth. Urban Growth Area Those areas designated by the County to accept future urban population densities with the intent of future annexation into the city pursuant to RCW 36.70A Urban Services Services that are normally available in an urban environment which include provisions for sanitary waste systems, solid waste disposal systems, water systems, urban roads and pedestrian facilities, transit systems, stormwater systems, police and fire and emergency services systems, electrical and communication systems, school and health care facilities, and parks. Utilities Enterprises or facilities serving the public by means of an integrated system of collection, transmission, distribution, and processing facilities through more or less permanent physical connections between the plant of the serving entity and the premises of the customer. Included are systems for the delivery of natural gas, electricity, telecommunications services, and water, and for the disposal of sewage. W Will The statement is an action decision-makers intend to do to implement plan goals and policies. The use of "will" in a statement indicates that the outcome can be measured. B•10 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Work/live space A living arrangement where the residential use and living area is subordinate in size to the work space. n Appendix B - Definitions B•11 (This page intentionally left blank) GMA Requirements The following pages list the minimum requirements for the various elements as listed in the State of Washington Revised Code of Washington (RCW) and Washington Administrative Code (WAC). Included with the requirements for each mandated element is a table, which shows how this comprehensive plan meets these requirements. CAppendix Requirements for the Land Use Element This element shall contain at least the following features: a) A future land use map showing city limits and urban growth area (UGA) boundaries. [RCW 36.70A.070(1), RCW 36.70A.110(6) and WAC 365-196-400(2), WAC 365-196-405(2) (i)(ii)] b) Consideration of urban planning approaches that increase physical activity. [RCW 36.70A.070(1), WAC 365-196-405(2)(f)] c) A consistent population projection throughout the plan which should be consistent with the Office of Financial Management forecast for the county or the county's sub-county allocation of that forecast. [RCW 43.62.035; WAC 365-196-405(2)(i)] d) Estimates of population densities and building intensities based on future land uses, [RCW 36.70A.070(1); WAC 365- 196-405(2)(i)] e) Provisions for protection of the quality and quantity of groundwater used for public water supplies [RCW 36.70A.070(1)] f) Identification of lands useful for public purposes such as utility corridors, transportation corridors, landfills, sewage treatment facilities, stormwater management facilities, C•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Table C.01 - GMA Requirements for the Land Use Element Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 1a Land Use Element text 1a Land Use Map, GIS database 1b Community profile text 1b Appendix A, EIS and addenda 1b Land Use Element text 1b Land Use Map, GIS database 1c & d Community profile text 1e Conservation Element: goals, policies and objectives 1d Appendix A, EIS and addenda 1j Conservation Element: goals, policies and objectives 1i Shoreline Master Program 1j Appendix E: Stormwater Management Plan 1k PAMC 15.20: Environmentally Sensitive Areas Protection Ordinance 1k Conservation Element: goals recreation, schools, and other public uses. [RCW 36.70A.150; WAC 365-196-340] 1) Identification of open space corridors within and between urban growth areas, including land useful for recreation, wildlife habitat, trails, and connections of critical areas. [RCW 36.70A.160, WAC 365-196-335] 2) Policies, land use designation (and zoning) to discourage the siting of incompatible uses adjacent to general aviation airports. [RCW 36.70A.510, RCW 36.70A.547; WAC 365-196- 475] 3) Policies, land use designation, and consistent zoning to discourage the siting of incompatible uses adjacent to military bases. [RCW 36.70A.530(3); WAC 365-196-475] 4) A review of drainage, flooding, and stormwater run-off in the area and nearby jurisdictions, and provide guidance for corrective actions to mitigate or cleanse those discharges that pollute water of the state. [RCW 36.70A.70(1), WAC 365-196-405(2)(c)] 5) Policies to designate and protect critical areas including wetlands, fish and wildlife habitat protection areas, frequently flooded areas, critical aquifer recharge areas and geologically hazardous areas. [RCW 36.70A.030(5), RCW 36.70A.172; WAC 365-195-900 through 925, WAC 365-190- 080] Requirements for the Housing Element This element shall contain at least the following features: a) Goals, policies, and objectives for the preservation, improvement, and development of housing. [RCW 36.70A.070(2)(b); WAC 365-196-410(2)(a)] b) An inventory and analysis of existing and projected housing needs. (RCW 36.70A.070(2)(a); WAC 365-196-410 (2)(b) &(c)] c) Identification of sufficient land for housing, including, but not limited to, government-assisted housing, housing for low-income families, manufactured housing, multifamily housing, and group homes and foster care facilities [RCW 36.70A.070(2)(c)] d) Adequate provisions for existing and projected housing needs of all economic segments of the community. [RCW 36.70A.070(2)(d); WAC 365-196-410] e) Identification of land use designation within a geographic area where increased residential development will assist Appendix C - GMA Requirements C•3 achieving local growth management and housing policies. [RCW 36.70A.540; WAC 365-196-870] f) Policies so that manufactured housing is not regulated differently than site built housing. [RCW 35.21.684, 35.63.160, 35A.21.312 &36.01.225] Requirements for the Capital Facilities Element This element shall contain at least the following features: a) Policies or procedures to ensure capital budget decisions are in conformity with the Comprehensive Plan. [RCW 36.70A.120] b) An inventory of existing capital facilities owned by public entities showing the locations and capacities of the capital facilities. [RCW 36.70A.070(3)(a); WAC 365-196-415(2)(a)] c) A forecast of the future needs for such capital facilities. [RCW 36.70A.070(3)(b); WAC 365-196-415(b)] d) The proposed locations and capacities of expanded or new capital facilities. [RCW 36.70A.070(3)(c); WAC 365-196-415(3) (C)] e) At least a six-year plan identifying sources of public money to finance planned capital facilities. [RCW 36.70A.070(3)(d) &36.70A.120; WAC 365-196-415] f) A policy or procedure to reassess the Land Use Element if probable funding falls short of meeting existing needs and to C•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Table C.02 - GMA Requirements for the Housing Element Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 2a Community profile text 2a Appendix A, EIS and addenda 2a Appendix C, Measuring Housing Need: A Data Toolkit for Clallam County 2a Housing Element: goals, policies, and objectives 2b Community profile text 2c Community profile text 2c Land Use Map, GIS database 2c Appendix A; EIS and addenda 2d Housing Element: goals, policies and objectives 2d Land Use Map, GIS database 2e Land Use Map, GIS database 2f Land Use Element, Policy C6 ensure that the Land Use Element, Capital Facilities Element, and financing plan within the Capital Facilities Element are coordinated and consistent. [RCW 36.70A.070(3)(e); WAC 365- 196-415] Requirements for the Utilities & Public Services Element This element shall contain at least the following features: a) The general location, proposed location, and capacity of all existing and proposed utilities, including, but not limited to, electrical lines, telecommunication lines, and natural gas lines. [RCW 36.70A.070(4); WAC 365-196-420] Requirements for the Transportation Element This element shall contain at least the following features: Appendix C - GMA Requirements C•5 Table C.03 - GMA Requirements for the Capital Facilities Element Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 3a Capital Facilities Element: goals and policies 3b Community Profile 3b Appendices: E - Stormwater Management Plan; F - Comprehensive Water System Plan 2010; G - Transportation Services and Facilities Plan; H - Facility Plan for Port Angeles Secondary Level Wastewater treatment Facilities 3b GIS database 3c Appendix A; EIS and addenda 3d Appendix A; EIS and addenda 3e Capital Facilities Plan 3f Capital Facilities Element: goals and policies Table C.04 - GMA Requirements for the Utilities and Public Services Element Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 4a Capital Facilities Element: Goals, policies and objectives 4a Appendices: E - Stormwater Management Plan; F - Comprehensive Water System Plan; G - Transportation Services and Facilities Plan; H - Facility Plan for Port Angeles Secondary Level Wastewater Treatment Facilities; I. Capital Facilities Plan. 4a GIS database a) An inventory of air, water, and land transportation facilities and services, including transit alignments, state owned transportation facilities, and general aviation airports, to define existing capital facilities and travel levels as a basis for future planning. b) Adopted levels of service (LOS) standards for all arterial streets, transit routes and highways to serve as a gauge to judge performance of the system. These standards should be regionally coordinated. [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a)(iii)(B); WAC 365-196-430] c) Identification of specific actions to bring locally-owned transportation and services to established Levels of Service (LOS). [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(iii)(D); WAC 365-196-430] d) A forecast of traffic for at least ten years including land use assumptions used in estimating travel. [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a) (i), 36.70A.070(6)(a)(iii)(E); WAC365-196-430(2)(f)] e) A projection of state and local system needs to meet current and future demands. [RCW 36.70A070(6)(a)(iii)(F); WAC 365- 196-430(2)(F)] f) f) A pedestrian and bicycle component. [RCW 36.70A.070(6) (a) (vii); WAC 365-196-430(2)(k)(iv)] g) A description of any existing and planned Transportation Demand Management (TMD) strategies, such as High- Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) lanes or subsidy programs, parking policies, etc. [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a)(vi); WAC 365-196-430(2) (k)(iv)] h) An analysis of future funding capability to judge needs against probable funding resources. [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a) (iv) (A); WAC 365-196-430(2)(k)(iv)] i) A multi-year financing plan based on the needs identified in the comprehensive plan, the appropriate parts of which shall serve as the basis for the six-year street, road, or transit program. [RCW 35.77.010 & RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a)(iv)(B); WAC 365-196-430(2)(k)(ii)] j) If probable funding falls short of meeting identified needs, a discussion of how additional funding will be raised or how land use assumptions will be reassessed to ensure that level of service standards will be met [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(iv)(C); WAC 365-196-430(2)(L)(ii)] C•6 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan k) A description of intergovernmental coordination efforts, including an assessment of the impacts of the transportation plan and land use assumptions on the transportation systems of adjacent jurisdictions and how it is consistent with the regional transportation plan. [RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a)(v); WAC 365-196-430(2)(a)(iv)] Requirements for Siting Public Facilities The Comprehensive Plan shall be consistent with the following: a) A process or criteria for identifying essential public facilities. (EPF). [RCW 36.70A.200; WAC 365-196-550(d)] b) Policies or procedures that ensure the Comprehensive Plan does not preclude the siting of essential public facilities. [RCW 36.70A.200(5); WAC 365-196-550(3)] Appendix C - GMA Requirements C•7 Table C.05 - GMA Requirements for the Transportation Element Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 5a Appendix A, EIS and addenda 5a Appendix G: Transportation Services and Facilities Plan 5a GIS database 5b Capital Facilities Element: Goals, policies and objectives 5b Transportation Element: Goals, policies and objectives 5b Appendix A; EIS and addenda 5b Appendices: E - Stormwater Management Plan; F - Comprehensive Water System Plan; G - Transportation Services and Facilities Plan; H - Facilities Plan for Port Angeles Secondary Level Wastewater Treatment Facilities, I - Capital Facilities Plan 5c Capital Facilities Element: Goals, policies and objectives 5c Appendices: E - Stormwater Management Plan; F - Comprehensive Water System Plan; G - Transportation Services and Facilities Plan, H - Facilities Plan for Port Angeles Secondary Level Wastewater Treatment Facilities; I - Capital Facilities Plan 5d Transportation Element: Goals, policies and objectives 5e Transportation Element: Goals, policies and objectives Table C.06 - GMA Requirements for Siting Public Facilities Legislative Requirement How requirements are addressed 6a Definitions 6b Capital Facilities Element: Goals, policies and objectives (This page intentionally left blank)n Transportation Analysis The following pages present a detailed analysis of Port Angeles' transportation system, evaluating system performance and likely impacts to it as a result of this comprehensive plan's adoption and implementation. DAppendix 1001 4th Avenue | Suite 4120 | Seattle, WA 98154 | (206) 576-4220 | Fax (206) 576-4225 www.fehrandpeers.com MEMORANDUM Date: May 19, 2017 To: Allyson Brekke, Planning Manager, City of Port Angeles From: Will Lisska, AICP, Fehr & Peers Subject: Port Angeles Transportation Element – Level of Service Analysis SE17-0535 This memorandum summarizes an intersection and roadway segment level of service (LOS) assessment, supplemental to Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Transportation Element, for state highways within the City of Port Angeles. This assessment includes a discussion data sources, traffic growth forecasts, existing and future year (2035) LOS, and how LOS deficiencies will be addressed by the Transportation Element. DATA COLLECTION Existing traffic data including weekday PM peak hour intersection counts and average daily traffic (ADT) along roadway segments was compiled from the following sources: • Port Angeles Waterfront and Transportation Improvement Plan (2012) • Lauridsen Boulevard Bridge Replacement Project (2014) • Nippon Paper Industries USA Company Biomass Cogeneration Project EIS (2010) • WSDOT Traffic Data GeoPortal (ADT counts current to 2015) Additionally, a weekday PM peak hour intersection count at E 1st Street (US 101) / E Front Street / S Golf Course Road count was conducted in April 2017. TRAFFIC GROWTH FORECAST The Growth Management Act requires a city’s Transportation Element to include traffic forecasts that are consistent with Land Use Element growth assumptions and describe conditions at least D•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan 1001 4th Avenue | Suite 4120 | Seattle, WA 98154 | (206) 576-4220 | Fax (206) 576-4225 www.fehrandpeers.com MEMORANDUM Date: May 19, 2017 To: Allyson Brekke, Planning Manager, City of Port Angeles From: Will Lisska, AICP, Fehr & Peers Subject: Port Angeles Transportation Element – Level of Service Analysis SE17-0535 This memorandum summarizes an intersection and roadway segment level of service (LOS) assessment, supplemental to Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Transportation Element, for state highways within the City of Port Angeles. This assessment includes a discussion data sources, traffic growth forecasts, existing and future year (2035) LOS, and how LOS deficiencies will be addressed by the Transportation Element. DATA COLLECTION Existing traffic data including weekday PM peak hour intersection counts and average daily traffic (ADT) along roadway segments was compiled from the following sources: • Port Angeles Waterfront and Transportation Improvement Plan (2012) • Lauridsen Boulevard Bridge Replacement Project (2014) • Nippon Paper Industries USA Company Biomass Cogeneration Project EIS (2010) • WSDOT Traffic Data GeoPortal (ADT counts current to 2015) Additionally, a weekday PM peak hour intersection count at E 1st Street (US 101) / E Front Street / S Golf Course Road count was conducted in April 2017. TRAFFIC GROWTH FORECAST The Growth Management Act requires a city’s Transportation Element to include traffic forecasts that are consistent with Land Use Element growth assumptions and describe conditions at least Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 2 of 7 10 years into the future. Previously, Fehr & Peers developed a citywide travel model for the Port Angeles Waterfront and Transportation Plan that includes existing and 2035 forecasting scenarios. For the 2035 scenario, it was assumed that existing land uses and regional trip-making would grow at a rate of 1.5% per year. These growth assumptions are in line with the Comprehensive Plan local population growth projections, which also estimate annual growth between 2010 and 2035 to occur at 1.5% per year (Pg. 30, Table 7). However, it should be noted that between 2010 and 2015, the City population grew from 19,038 to an estimated 19,448, a rate of 0.4% per year. Because growth has been somewhat lower than projected, the traffic growth forecasts developed from the citywide travel model may be considered conservative. INTERSECTION LEVEL OF SERVICE ANALYSIS The following intersections were analyzed for PM peak hour under existing and forecasted 2035 conditions: 1. US 101 / SR 117 2. US 101 (E Lauridsen Boulevard) / S Lincoln Street 3. US 101 (S Lincoln Street) / E 8th Street 4. US 101 (N Lincoln Street) / E 1st Street 5. US 101 (N Lincoln Street) / E Front 6. US 101 (E 1st Street) / S Race Street 7. US 101 (E Front Street) / S Race Street 8. US 101 (E 1st Street & E Front Street) / Golf Course Road 9. SR 117 / Marine Drive Level of service (LOS) and average intersection delay was calculated for each intersection by the methods described in the following sections. Signalized Intersection Methodology. Traffic operations at signalized intersections are evaluated using the LOS method described in Chapter 16 of the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM). A signalized intersection’s LOS is based on the weighted average control delay measured in seconds per vehicle and includes initial deceleration delay, queue move-up time, stopped delay, and final Appendix D - Transportation Analysis D•3 Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 3 of 7 acceleration. Table 1 summarizes the relationship between the control delay and LOS for signalized intersections. Unsignalized Intersection Methodology. Traffic conditions at unsignalized intersections are evaluated using the method from Chapter 17 of the HCM. With this method, operations are defined by the average control delay per vehicle (measured in seconds) for each movement that must yield the right-of-way. For all-way stop-controlled intersections, the average control delay is calculated for the intersection as a whole. At two-way or side street-controlled intersections, the control delay (and LOS) is calculated for each controlled movement, the left turn movement from the major street, and the entire intersection. Table 1 summarizes the relationship between delay and LOS for unsignalized intersections. TABLE 1: INTERSECTION LEVEL OF SERVICE CRITERIA Level of Service Description Average Control Delay (seconds per vehicle) Signalized Intersection Unsignalized Intersection A Little or no delays < 10.0 < 10.0 B Short traffic delays > 10.0 to 20.0 > 10.0 to 15.0 C Average traffic delays > 20.0 to 35.0 > 15.0 to 25.0 D Long traffic delays > 35.0 to 55.0 > 25.0 to 35.0 E Very long traffic delays > 55.0 to 80.0 > 35.0 to 50.0 F Extreme traffic delays with intersection capacity exceeded > 80.0 > 50.0 Source: Highway Capacity Manual 5th Edition (Transportation Research Board, 2010) LOS Standards. The Capital Facilities Element of the Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan states that “all arterial streets shall function at an average daily Level of Service (LOS) of D or better.” In addition, it notes that Highways of Statewide Significance (US 101) should function at LOS D or better, per the WSDOT and the Peninsula Regional Transportation Planning Organization. LOS Results. Traffic operations were analyzed using the Synchro 9 software package. Synchro calculations are based on procedures outlined in the HCM and described in the preceding sections for signalized and unsignalized intersections. Table 2 shows the LOS results for the D•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 4 of 7 existing and forecasted 2035 weekday PM peak hour. Under existing conditions, all intersections operate at LOS C or better. Under the 2035 forecast conditions, several intersections along the US 101 corridor would degrade to LOS D operations, but none would exceed the LOS D threshold established by WSDOT and the Peninsula Regional Transportation Planning Organization. TABLE 2: INTERSECTION OPERATIONS SUMMARY – PM PEAK HOUR # Intersection Control Existing Conditions 2035 Forecast Delay3 LOS3 Delay3 LOS3 1 US 101 / SR 117 SSSC1 19 C 24 C 2 US 101 (E Lauridsen Boulevard) / S Lincoln Street Signal 11 B 14 B 3 US 101 (S Lincoln Street) / E 8th Street Signal 34 C 44 D 4 US 101 (N Lincoln Street) / E 1st Street Signal 25 C 36 D 5 US 101 (N Lincoln Street) / E Front Signal 28 C 45 D 6 US 101 (E 1st Street) / S Race Street Signal 21 C 47 D 7 US 101 (E Front Street) / S Race Street Signal 10 A 11 B 8 US 101 (E 1st Street & E Front Street) / S Golf Course Road Signal 11 B 17 B 9 SR 117 / Marine Drive Signal 16 B 27 C Notes: 1. Signal = signalized intersection 2. SSSC = side-street stop-controlled intersection 3. Traffic operations results include LOS (level of service) and delay (seconds per vehicle). LOS is based on delay thresholds published in the Highway Capacity Manual 5th Edition (Transportation Research Board, 2010). Source: Fehr & Peers, May 2017. ROADWAY SEGMENT LEVEL OF SERVICE ANALYSIS The following roadway segments were analyzed for PM peak hour under existing and forecasted 2035 conditions: 1. SR 117 from Marine Drive to US 101 2. US 101 from Cameron Road (West City Limits) to SR 117 Appendix D - Transportation Analysis D•5 Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 5 of 7 3. US 101 from SR 117 to E Lauridsen Boulevard / S Lincoln Street 4. US 101 from S E Lauridsen Boulevard / S Lincoln Street to E 1st Street / E Front Street 5. US 101 (E Front Street) from S Lincoln Street to S Golf Course Road 6. US 101 (E 1st Street) from S Lincoln Street to S Golf Course Road 7. US 101 from S Golf Course Road to N Baker Street (East City Limits) Level of service (LOS) was calculated for each intersection by the methods described in the following sections. Roadway Segment LOS Methodology. Roadway segment LOS can be measured by comparing bi- directional traffic volume to Maximum Service Volume (MSV). For this analysis, each study segment is assigned a maximum PM peak hour service volume, or capacity. If the actual two-way PM peak hour volume on the segment exceeds the MSV, then the segment does not meet the LOS standard. WSDOT does not maintain a protocol for selecting MSVs for state routes, so a set of tables developed by the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) based on the Highway Capacity Manual 5th Edition (Transportation Research Board, 2010) was used to assign MSVs to the roadway segments and determine grade A – F LOS thresholds. These FDOT tables can be found in Appendix A. The MSV threshold is determined by factors such as area type (urban or rural context), number of lanes, presence of median, speed, and presence of turn lanes. LOS Standards. The Capital Facilities Element of the Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan states that “all arterial streets shall function at an average daily Level of Service (LOS) of D or better.” In addition, it notes that Highways of Statewide Significance (US 101) should function at LOS D or better, per the WSDOT and the Peninsula Regional Transportation Planning Organization. LOS Results. The calculation of roadway segment MSV thresholds and LOS grades is summarized in Table 3. Under existing conditions, all roadway segments operate at LOS D or better. Under the 2035 forecast conditions, one roadway segment (US 101 from S Golf Course Road to N Baker Street) would operate at LOS F, exceeding the LOS D threshold established by WSDOT and the Peninsula Regional Transportation Planning Organization. As discussed in the following section, the Port Angeles Transportation Element and Capital Facilities Element contain several policies and objectives that would address congestion and capacity on this corridor. All other roadway segments would operate at LOS D or better under 2035 conditions. D•6 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 6 of 7 TABLE 3: ROADWAY SEGMENT OPERATIONS SUMMARY – PM PEAK HOUR # Roadway Segment Existing Conditions 2035 Forecast Bi- directional Volume MSV1 LOS Bi- directional Volume MSV1 LOS 1 SR 117 from Marine Drive to US 101 610 2,170 B 780 2,170 C 2 US 101 from Cameron Road (West City Limits) to SR 117 1,200 2,170 C 1,470 2,170 C 3 US 101 from SR 117 to E Lauridsen Boulevard / S Lincoln Street 980 1,330 D 1,280 1,330 D 4 US 101 from S E Lauridsen Boulevard / S Lincoln Street to E 1st Street / E Front Street 840 1,330 D 990 1,330 D 5 US 101 (E Front Street) from S Lincoln Street to S Golf Course Road 1,500 1,927 D 1,730 1,927 D 6 US 101 (E 1st Street) from S Lincoln Street to S Golf Course Road 1,600 1,927 D 1,840 1,927 D 7 US 101 from S Golf Course Road to N Baker Street (East City Limits) 3,100 3,580 C 3,970 3,580 F Notes: 1. MSV = maximum service volume, as determined by Florida Department of Transportation generalized service volume tables (Appendix A) Source: Fehr & Peers, May 2017. MITIGATION MEASURES As discussed in the previous section, the roadway segment of US 101 from S Golf Course Road to N Baker Street would operate at LOS F, exceeding the established LOS D threshold. The Port Appendix D - Transportation Analysis D•7 Allyson Brekke May 19, 2017 Page 7 of 7 Angeles Transportation Element and Capital Facilities Element contain several policies and objectives that would address this deficiency through planning and inter-agency coordination: • Transportation Element, Goal B, Policy 3 – The City should facilitate an additional route for local cross-town traffic across White’s Creek ultimately connecting with US 101. • Transportation Element, Goal B, Policy 19 – The City should work with other jurisdictions to identify and protect a right-of-way for a second street accessing the City from the East. • Transportation Element, Goal B, Objective 5 – The City will prepare a study to evaluate options for easterly access across Whites and Ennis Creeks in the vicinity of Golf Course Road. • Transportation Element, Goal B, Objective 19 – The City will coordinate with the County, RTPO, and State and Federal agencies in the study of a possible future US 101 corridor including the Heart of the Hills Parkway and Coastal Corridor concepts. East of Race Street, the alternate local cross-town route (along Lauridsen Boulevard) will not be considered as a future US 101 corridor. • Capital Facilities Element, Goal A, Policy 7 – The comprehensive service and facilities plan for streets, bikeways, and pedestrian walkways should include a future US 101 corridor to meet long-term local and regional transportation needs. D•8 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan City-Wide Performance Measures The adoption of performance standards can be useful for the objective evaluation of organizational effectiveness, with the end result being the attainment of desirable outcomes. Performance standards are observable, measurable, specific measures of expectations that are typically expressed in terms of quantity, timeliness, quality or cost. • Quantity addresses how much work is produced. • Quality addresses how well the work is performed and how effective it is. • Timeliness addresses how quickly or when the work is accomplished. • Cost-Effectiveness addresses working within a budget or saving money. In order to be most useful, performance standards written to address these measures should be reasonable, attainable and when possible, based upon a recognized standard. The standards should be designed in order to provide a result that can EAppendix directly lead to the determination of whether or not desirable outcomes have been achieved. Within the City organization, there is no “one size fits all” set of performance standards that can be adopted. That said, it is assumed that there are a number of “universal” performance standards that will apply to all City Departments. Clearly, the provision of excellent customer service, fiscal responsibility, stewardship of resources and the recognition of achievement are all standards that should be expected and they are reflections of the values of the organization. Beyond the performance standards that reflect core organizational values, each individual department within the City will have unique performance standards that are tailored to the specific outcomes that are desired. As was mentioned above, these standards could take into consideration the results (outcomes) that are desired, however specific budget constraints, regulatory requirements, measures of success and measures of quality should also be considered E•2 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Community and Economic Development Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Number of building permits issued within 30 days 30 days 90% Number of land use applications issued within 90 days 90 days 80% Total number of new residential units approved *Subject to private sector investment decisions 27 80% Total number of grants dollars awarded $250,000 >250,000 Linear feet of facade changes approved through the Facade and Sign Grant Program *Subject to private sector investment decisions 350 80% Total number of lodging tax events awarded funding October 15th to May 15th *Subject to LTAC & Council Approval 7 85% Port Angeles Fire Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Turnout Time 2 min 90%Yes 1:16 First Arriving Apparatus at Fire 8 min 90%Yes 5:20 Full First Alarm Fire Response (14 or 15 people)18 min 90%N/A EMS Response 8 min 90%Yes 6:20 Hazardous Materials (Operations)8 min 90%Yes 7:00 Technical Rescue (Operations)8 min 90%N/A Marine Response 28 min 90%N/A Wildland Fire-First Engine 8 min 90%Yes 6:59 Appendix E - City-Wide Performance Measures E•3 Port Angeles Police Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Use of force incidents reviewed and within policy Yearly total numbers 99% Pursuits reviewed and within policy Yearly total numbers 99% Yearly reduction in property crime Yearly total numbers 5% reduction Yearly increase in DUI arrests Yearly total numbers 5% increase Yearly increase in community interactions Yearly total numbers 5% increase Meet standards and maintain WASPC Accredidation Maintain WASPC Accred. Meet 135 standards Parks Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Improve aging/existing infrastructure 3 Projects CFP Projects Complete Increase Cemetary Revenues $125,000 5% Increase Increase Rental Revenues $80,000 5% Increase Increase Sports Player Revenues $60,000 5% Increase Increase Senior Center Membership Revenues $25,000 5% Increase Legal Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Public Records Requests Respond w/in standard E•4 City of Port Angeles Comprehensive Plan Public Works Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD Maintain local streets and sidewalks to safe standards Respond within 24 hours No Complaints Maintain street signage in accordance to Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) requirements/standards 100% Compliance 10% of signs replaced annually Perform roadside safety improvements such as guardrail, handrail and traffic delineator installation/repair Complete on time Meet WSDOT standards Perform Citywide roadside vegetation management program Complete on time No complaints Meet regulatory permit requirements with Department of Health and Department of Ecology 100% Compliance No violations Perform de-icing and snow removal on City Streets as necessary to ensure safe driving conditions 100% Compliance Meet goals within Snow Plan Respond to after-hour callouts 30 minutes 90% w/in 30 mins. Finance Department Performance Standards Results Performance Standard Measured Result Standard Met?Actual YTD CAFR Filed Filed on time Annual Yes Yes CFP Completed Filed on time Yes Yes CFP with Comp Plan Integration Cross reference included Yes Yes Budget Amendments Completed Completed on time Tri-annual Yes Yes GFOA CAFR Award Awarded Annual Pending Clean SAO Audit No findings Annual Yes Yes Payroll and AP Processing Completed on time Biweekly Yes Yes n Appendix E - City-Wide Performance Measures E•5 (This Page is intentionally left blank) Comprehensive Plan Related Documents A. Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement November 14, 1995 & Second Addendum to the 1993 EIS for the City of Port Angeles 2004 Comprehensive Plan update. B. SEPA review / Determination of Non Significance #1374 dated May 23, 2016 C. Clallam County Wide Planning Policy, June 30, 1992 D. Background Report Clallam County Housing Needs Assessment; April 1991 E. Measuring Housing Need: A Data Toolkit for Clallam County; May 2006 F. Peninsula RTPO Comprehensive Plan Consistency and Certification Checklist G. Public Surveys and Response Summaries from 2016 Comprehensive Plan Update H. Stormwater Management Program I. Water System Plan J. Facility Plan for Port Angeles Secondary Level Wastewater Treatment Facilities K. Capital Facilities Plan & Transportation Improvement Plan L. Port Angeles Preliminary Park and Recreation Inventory & Year 2010 Level of Service Analysis, M. Community Bicycle Meeting and Survey and Mapping Exercise FAppendix Staff Updates Date: January 16, 2024 To: City Council From: Nathan A. West, City Manager Subject: Lincoln School Redevelopment Opportunities Background / Analysis: For the past seven years the City of Port Angeles has been diligently working to develop a toolbox of housing incentives to inspire and encourage multi-family housing development in Port Angeles. This effort has included passage of the Multi-Family Tax Exemption (MFTE) program and major code changes such as Fee Waivers and increased Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) allowances that have been trend setting for Washington State. As part of the City’s expanding efforts to support new multi-family developments the City should now more directly pursue advancing the construction and development of new units in Port Angeles. To this end, the Housing Pipeline Pilot Project was created and introduced to the Capital Facilities Plan to develop options to enable a pipeline of new affordable/multi-family housing units. City staff is working diligently to identify partnerships and opportunities for the capital development of new multi-family development in Port Angeles. The overall goal will be to improve multi-family housing market outcomes and overcome the housing unit gap in the City's Housing Action Plan. The project will begin with an independent consultant study that evaluates alternatives for a path to developing new multi-family units and could evolve into a City capital project(s) and/or public-private partnerships, as well as action-oriented relationships with local housing providers. Staff is recommending that Council authorize the City Manager to submit a proposal to the North Olympic History Center for a formal due diligence review of multi-family redevelopment opportunities of the former Lincoln Elementary School building at 926 W. 8th Street. Funding Overview: $50,000 has been budgeted in the 2024-2029 Capital Facilities Plan. Summary: Housing is a top priority for the City of Port Angeles. The City has made huge strides forward with recent innovative initiatives. The City is now proposing to further expand its effort on the need for additional multi-family development. Funding: $50,000 has been budgeted in the 2024-2029 Capital Facilities Plan. Recommendation: 1) Authorize the City Manager to submit a proposal to the North Olympic History Center for a formal due diligence review of multi-family redevelopment opportunities of the former Lincoln Elementary School building at 926 W. 8th Street and 2) authorize the City Manager to secure an independent consultant to evaluate redevelopment options. 2023 Year End Building Report JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC Year to Date Total 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $210,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $210,000 6 6 4 9 7 6 11 7 9 13 7 7 92 $104,422.00 $1,056,500.00 $44,300.00 $324,207.00 $175,164.00 $95,848.00 $515,652.00 $187,474.00 $205,546.00 $315,441.00 $1,765,744.00 $244,872.00 $5,035,170 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $42,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $42,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0 2 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 7 $183,500.00 $4,500.00 $5,000.00 $0.00 $60,000.00 $0.00 $797,973.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $4,630.00 $0.00 $1,055,603 0 0 2 0 0 0 3 1 0 0 0 0 6 $0.00 $0.00 $120,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,000,000.00 $175,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $3,295,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 2 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $48,500.00 $85,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $133,500 3 7 1 2 6 0 0 1 1 2 1 24 $246,064.00 $441,604.00 $2,031,136.00 $137,382.00 $664,000.00 $1,231,498.00 $0.00 $0.00 $159,362.00 $50,000.00 $474,000.00 $232,700.00 $5,667,746 0 0 2 0 2 2 0 0 2 2 3 1 14 $0.00 $0.00 $80,000.00 $0.00 $83,000.00 $140,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $112,064.00 $141,860.00 $120,600.00 $120,000.00 $797,524 24 20 27 28 48 29 31 25 25 24 18 15 314 $248,853.00 $253,972.00 $716,266.00 $391,293.00 $1,053,846.00 $585,497.00 $528,018.00 $516,392.00 $570,869.00 $372,729.00 $293,119.00 $174,713.00 $5,705,567 0 1 0 2 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 8 $0.00 $40,000.00 $0.00 $12,001.00 $800.00 $0.00 $8,000.00 $50,000.00 $0.00 $0.00 $1,800.00 $0.00 $112,601 32 31 43 40 62 43 48 35 37 42 32 24 469 $782,839.00 $1,796,576.00 $2,996,702.00 $864,883.00 $2,246,810.00 $2,052,843.00 $4,898,143.00 $1,013,866.00 $1,047,841.00 $922,030.00 $2,659,893.00 $772,285.00 $22,054,711 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 1 2 1 0 7 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 6 1 3 7 1 2 6 0 0 1 1 2 1 24 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 0 0 0 0 0 27 1 3 12 1 2 8 28 3 2 3 3 1 67 1 5 2 2 4 1 2 6 3 4 0 0 30 $14,650.13 $26,442.52 $85,928.99 $14,851.28 $46,821.40 $58,855.84 $124,371.92 $23,424.32 $21,624.45 $19,611.69 $41,784.01 $16,921.03 $495,287.58 Dwelling Units - Single Family Dwelling Units-Manufactured Home Dwelling Units - Multi Family (3+) Total Dwelling Units Total Permits Issued Total Construction Valuation Dwelling Units - Duplex New Construction Repair and Alteration New Multi Family New Manufactured Home Dwelling Units - ADU Certificate of Occupancy Permit Fees Paid Comm Ind Public Res New Construction Repair and Alteration New Construction New Single Family New Accessory Structure Repair and Alteration Demolition and Moving Repair and Alteration